3 ms·
tl;dr version: The FBI has been up to all the same sorts of abuses and incompetence as large, minimally-supervised security/law enforcement agencies have been
by bell-cot 4y ago
tl;dr version: The FBI has been up to all the same sorts of abuses and incompetence as large, minimally-supervised security/law enforcement agencies have been up to for the past ~5,000 years. Laughably naive and under-resourced reform attempts - "we'll write a great-sounding new rule on this piece of paper, and loudly announce that they have to follow it, and this magical piece of paper will fix all the problems!" had done about as little good as any experienced grown-up would expect.
Bluntly put, don't expect it to get substantially better, no matter what nice new rules are written on magical pieces of paper. Organizations like the FBI default to crudely upholding the social hierarchies which feed them, in ways which appeal emotionally to organizations' members. Most higher-ups in those social hierarchies know how to enjoy the benefits of that behavior - while conveniently overlooking the dirtier details. Further down the social hierarchies, there are plenty of "Santa Claus fans" - really Wanting To Believe that their FBI / CIA / police / etc. are paragons of morality and competence - who react poorly to messengers bearing bad news.
Vs. savvy advocates of real oversight and reform, with the the skills, resources, and attention spans to make that happen & stick? Those are less common than Elvis impersonators in Putin's personal security detail.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 23skidoo 4y ago> Further down the social hierarchies, there are plenty of "Santa Claus fans" - really Wanting To Believe that their FBI / CIA / police / etc. are paragons of morality and competence - who react poorly to messengers bearing bad news. I'll take this opportunity to plug the Iron Law of Bureaucracy which states that in any organization there are two kinds of people: those loyal to the goals of the org, and those loyal to the org itself. Organizations tend to get captured by those loyal to the org itself, even though the people loyal to its goals are the ones you actually want running the show. Eventually you end up with a top-heavy organization that's divorced from its stated goals and exists only to further its own influence and existence. You'll find it in schools, cancer charities, government, etc.
- bell-cot 4y agoSort-of yes...but looking at (say) the CIA's long indifference to a series of employees who effectively turned traitor against the CIA (by selling its hottest cold-war secrets to the U.S.S.R.), I don't think "loyal to the org itself" is a good description of the rot.
- banannaise 4y agoI had never heard this, and I'm immediately adding it to the big list of things that explain more about present reality than I'm necessarily comfortable with.