3 ms·
To be fair, what the Poles broke was early Enigma, same idea but not so close to the late-war Enigma that these machines need to target. The M4 Enigma on a late
by tialaramex 4y ago
To be fair, what the Poles broke was early Enigma, same idea but not so close to the late-war Enigma that these machines need to target. The M4 Enigma on a late war U-boat is too sophisticated to be practically attacked with the pencil and paper approach the Poles were taking just prior to and then during initial periods of the War.
On the one hand a museum of flight which doesn't mention the Wright Brothers is stupid, but on the other hand if they act as though from the Wright Flyer to an A320 or an F35 is just trivial refinements that's not telling an accurate story either, you want to mention e.g. Frank Whittle and ideally the larger context (Ohain in Germany also invents this engine, before Whittle, but by the time he gets it actually working Germany is losing the war anyway)
Edited to add: It's actually razor thin the difference between what would have been enough to defeat Allied cryptanalysis and what Enigma actually does. If tradecraft by German military groups had been 100% there's every chance Ultra would have gone nowhere, and we'd see Bletchley Park, if it was remembered at all, as a failure. "Why did the British think they had any chance?"
Fortunately Germans are human and they screwed up. They'd send similar messages with the same encryption, they'd forget to choose random keys and then remember and begin again with the new keys, they'd be lazy and use the simplest change rather than fully randomising. All things you'd expect humans to get wrong, but it's nice that they did or things might have turned out very differently.