4 ms·
I will make it more technical: a cyclist doesn't have an windshield A-pillar blocking part of their view. When two vehicles approach an intersection, if they d
by kazinator 4y ago
I will make it more technical: a cyclist doesn't have an windshield A-pillar blocking part of their view.
When two vehicles approach an intersection, if they do so at the same speed (including same variation in speed, like both decelerating), the relative view angle from one vehicle to the other stays the same. It's possible for another road user to be entirely hidden behind a driver's A pillar during an approach to the intersection. In spite of several glances in that direction, it is possible to fail to spot the other vehicle. A proper stop is the only sure thing.
- CameronNemo 4y agoI once almost hit a pedestrian because of the pillar in my car. Luckily caught it at the last second, and was going at a slow speed, but yeah those blind spots are no joke.
- DoughnutHole 4y agoCyclists have pretty much universally better vision on the road, it's not just the front A-pillars. - The pillars of every pane of glass in a car create blind spots, not just the the front - there's a reason changing lanes safely requires both a mirror check and a physical turn of the head. - Drivers are set back relative to the front of the car, so they can't easily see cross traffic if there's any sort of obstructions. - If a driver is right at the front of the vehicle (see euro trucks) they're necessarily lifted atop the engine and so have a blind spot immediately in front of them. - Drivers have the advantage of being able to look behind without completely turning their head, but mirrors have their own blind spots and necessarily have to have either a restricted field of view or distort distances depending on their curvature. None of these are problems for cyclists because they can just move their body and head without obstruction. The only real vision advantage drivers have is being able to see over the tops of other vehicles if they're driving something tall - which of course comes with its own blind spots (and impedes the vision of everyone else on the road).
- kazinator 4y ago> The pillars of every pane of glass in a car create blind spots ... there's a reason changing lanes safely requires both a mirror check and a physical turn of the head True, but not relevant in the context of stopping or or rolling through a stop sign. I don't care about my B or C pillars when stopping, other than on the passenger side when making a right turn (check for cyclists, scooters). The A pillar has the unique problem that two drivers approaching the same intersection at constant speed, from a mile away, such that they will meet there at the same time, may fail to see each other almost the the entire time until the last few moments, because each vehicle maintains the same angle relative to the path of travel of the other vehicle.
- tga 4y agoFor a bit of pedantry, the driver _can_ be right at the front of the vehicle and low enough, see city buses.
- u801e 4y ago> I will make it more technical: a [pedal]cyclist doesn't have an windshield A-pillar blocking part of their view. Neither does a motorcyclist, but no one claims it's safer for motorcyclists to treat stop as yield compared to motorists.
- kazinator 4y ago> But no one claims it's safer for motorcyclists to treat stop as yield compared to motorists. OK, I will claim it now; there, someone does. > Neither does a motorcyclist Not true if the motorcyclist has a full helmet. Though it's true that it doesn't have pillars.
- u801e 4y agoNot all jurisdictions have helmet laws, nor does every motorcyclist wear a full helmet. Also, turning their head would mitigate the visbility issue, which isn't the case for a motorist.
- slenk 4y agoThat would certainly make riding easier