5 ms·
I don't think it was inevitable for Russia to end up so firmly in the anti-West camp. Back in 1993 - and, really, all the way until the end of 90s - it was very
by int_19h 4y ago
I don't think it was inevitable for Russia to end up so firmly in the anti-West camp. Back in 1993 - and, really, all the way until the end of 90s - it was very much at the crossroads.
The mistake is claiming that the path it ended up choosing, it chose because of something the West did or didn't do. It was all about choices that people made - and back then, elections in Russia still meant something - in response to concerns at the time. Which were mostly domestic: economy, crime, terrorism (in Caucasian regions).
- labster 4y agoNothing in history is truly inevitable, but it’s hard for me to see Russia — and particularly Muscovites — to abandon empire and corrupt oligarchy. Yeltsin let oligarchs emerge to help him consolidate power, but then was trapped in the system. He chose Putin as his successor so that he could retire safely. To keep stability, Russia plays to the idea of themselves as a great empire, despite the reality that many citizens of the “republics” have never seen indoor plumbing. If there was another choice, what was it? Not to be corrupt? Who would have made that choice?
- foverzar 4y ago> despite the reality that many citizens of the “republics” have never seen indoor plumbing. Oh please, where do you even find these kind of myths? I've been living and traveling Russia for years - I just can't wrap my head where people get these kinds of idiotic narratives. I mean srsly "never seen indoor plumbing" - do you actually really believe this? Where did you even get an image like that? I'm just really puzzled how people seem to be so "expertly" sure of something, which is verifiably untrue - I've visited so many wilder parts of Russia, including visiting relatives in national republics and I'm super puzzled - like where did you even find this plumbing problem? I mean, I'm sure someone somewhere might have some specific case, but I am pretty sure I would have noticed at least one habitable house without plumbing if that was really a kind of a substantial massive problem you describe it to be. > Muscovites ...on the other hand, I seem to suspect what kind of bubble had formed your outlook...
- ithkuil 4y agoYeah, it's sad how people intentionally misrepresent and mistranslate things because they want to believe in something. The real Rosstat statistic speak of "centralized sewage" not indoor plumbing. I live in Italy less than 10km outside a provincial capital and I also don't have access to centralized sewage. I assume the situation in rural Russia is no different. How is it in rural America? Low density areas often don't build that infrastructure and leave each house to build waste water management system. Old systems are basically just a hole in the ground but modern systems (like the one I had to install, because the Italian law mandates it) are active filters of various kinds.
- plasticchris 4y agoIt is the same in rural America, there are regulations but in many places people still use a lagoon. Central sewage is only in big developments or inside the city limits.
- hmm0101 4y agoHmm...you can get these facts just by reading the news: https://www.themoscowtimes.com/2019/04/02/indoor-plumbing-still-a-pipe-dream-for-20-of-russian-households-reports-say-a65049 https://www.themoscowtimes.com/2019/04/02/indoor-plumbing-st... Even pro-Kremlin sources: https://web.archive.org/web/20221004222830/https://www.rt.com/news/russia-city-utilities-hot-water-indoor-plumbing-251/ https://web.archive.org/web/20221004222830/https://www.rt.co... Funny that you have mention a bubble...
- foverzar 4y ago> you can get these facts just by reading the news C'mon, it's the 21st centrury. You can find pretty much any kind of narative, whatever ideology and whatever image "on the news". According to "the news" Russians eat babies and Democrats are spawns of antichrist that want to turn all children gay, you know how it is. Even your two links have only a theme in common, the substance is completely different. > Funny that you have mention a bubble... Why? When you don't have a consistent image of the subject and have to rely on an arbitrary proxy to provide you with some out of context piece of info - what is it, if not "bubble"? When talking of scope or magnitude and how things work IRL, I'd rather trust my own empirical evidence, obviously. So your comment on bubbles is kinda ironic to me. I mean, sure, some people don't have central heating (and use boiler), some don't have central sewerage (and direct their pipes to special underground pit, that gets emptied by a honeywagon every few years), some don't have centralized water, so they drill a deep hole and install a well pump - all this is very common in a countryside. But "never seen indoor plumbing"? For real? I mean, we all like our wild medieval uncivilised Russia jokes, but it seems to me that some people take this image just too seriously and seem to have trouble distinciting between a joke and a reality.
- int_19h 4y agoI grew up in Russia in the 90s. The country was corrupt as hell under Yeltsin, but it was still a democracy, and there were different parties with genuinely different platforms then. Yeltsin couldn't just choose his successor - he had to actually sell him to the public. And mass media wasn't all controlled by the state, so there was plenty of very sharp criticism of Putin as he was still working his way to the top. At the end of the day, the people still willingly voted for "the strong hand", and so, here we are.
- pydry 4y ago>The mistake is claiming that the path it ended up choosing, it chose because of something the West did or didn't do. This isn't a mistake either. Putin was open towards pursuing a deeper partnership with the west in the early 2000s. He asked to join NATO (as equals) and rather than leaping on the opportunity NATO told him to join the back of the queue. In subsequent years we launched an unprovoked invasion of Iraq and "upgraded" a UN resolution from protecting civilians to planting a bayonet in Khafaffi's rectum. It was a little hard not to view us as a dangerous and unpredictable threat, and a little hard not to take what happened to Khadaffi personally. This was all made worse by the actions of the National Endowment for "Democracy" who essentially prosecute a more effective mirror image of the type of election meddling Putin attempted in America, albeit along Russia's border (& once in Kaliningrad in the 90s). This has continued unabated since the 90s - fomenting and fostering ethnic/cultural divisions everywhere it can along Russia's exposed borders that mirror the one we see in America today.
- int_19h 4y agoI wasn't talking about Putin's choices, but rather about the choices of people that led to Putin gaining power. But also - Putin always fancied himself the restorer of imperial glory, so joining NATO was never seriously on the table without also asserting claim to all the "lost lands".
- pydry 4y ago>Putin always fancied himself the restorer of imperial glory This is certainly how western media has tried to depict him. Our media is more a reflection of our own imperial neuroses than it is a window into his subconscious though. Occam's razor suggests that when he asked to join NATO it was because he wanted to be a member.
- int_19h 4y agoAs it happens, I'm Russian, and at the time when all this was happening, I lived in Russia, so my perspective is very much not based on "how Western media tried to depict him".
- roenxi 4y agoWhile the actions of Russia are ultimately the responsibility of the Russians, the end of the 90s is also around the time NATO started picking up ex-Soviet states [0]. It is underplaying the West's power here to ignore the effect of marching our anti-Russia alliance towards Russia. It is unreasonable to expect good relations while preparing that sort of military threat. The strategy here - driven by the US - fosters poor relations. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enlargement_of_NATO https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enlargement_of_NATO
- ribit 4y agoThis rhetorics misses two crucial facts: first, that the eastern slavic states were eager to join NATO simply because they were worried about the Russian threat. Russian chauvinism towards ex-soviet nations is not a recent thing and Russia's attempts to coerce and pressure neighbours into submission and dependence started immediately after the dissolution of the Soviet Union. For someone like me who grew up in Ukraine where the Russian threat was an everyday topic, the narrative of "aggressive NATO expansion" is a great illustration how people pushing it are far from understanding the post-Soviet reality. And second, in the 90ties there were negotiations about Russia joining NATO as well, which ultimately broke down in the early 2000s as Russia embraced state terrorism as a regular political instrument. The point is very simple: NATO or not NATO, Russian fascism and Russian imperialism would still be there. Without the NATO expansion however the Baltic states would have probably been annexed a decade ago.
- Scharkenberg 4y agoYour reply removes all agency from individual countries who independently decided to join NATO. Reminds me of certain whataboutist, bothsidist discourse in circles outside YN too.
- Izkata 4y agoIt's not one-sided, existing NATO members have to approve new membership. They could have said no.
- 4y ago