11 ms·
Being open source is a very good idea, but it doesn't mean the software that's actually loaded into the machines isn't compromised. The way to minimize the ris
by WalterBright 4y ago
Being open source is a very good idea, but it doesn't mean the software that's actually loaded into the machines isn't compromised.
The way to minimize the risk of that is to have two voting machines, with independently developed software in each. Then see if the two produce the same result.
What's important for voting confidence is having the count be auditable, which is much more important than having the machines be secure. After all, banks learned how to do that with money long ago. Banking software has been compromised in the past, but the audit ability catches it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- drewbug01 4y ago> The way to minimize the risk of that is to have two voting machines, with independently developed software in each. Then see if the two produce the same result. How could this possibly work, without having the precise same votes entered into each machine (an impossible to guarantee prerequisite)?
- WalterBright 4y agoStart with a stack of ballots. Run the stack through one machine. Run the same stack through another machine. Check the tallies. If they differ, then the counts are discarded and the stack goes to perhaps a hand count. Each stack is handled by two people, one from each party. One feeds the machine, the other watches him.
- shagie 4y agoThat particular device pictured is a scanner. https://npr.brightspotcdn.com/dims4/default/9956d4f/2147483647/strip/true/crop/5000x3333+0+0/resize/1760x1174!/format/webp/quality/90/?url=http%3A%2F%2Fnpr-brightspot.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fad%2Fb5%2F4ec7e5b649ba9eafac8665527401%2Fps-new.jpg https://npr.brightspotcdn.com/dims4/default/9956d4f/21474836... It can scan a scantron sheet in which the page, side, column and row are used to generate a number. For example a bubble filled in on page 1, side 1, column 4, row 8 would generate 110408. There is some business logic here that says that "For page 1, side 1, only one of 0408, 0409, 0410 may be entered". At the end, however, you get a number counted that is then tallied for and then that is mapped back to Bob Smith for the votes. Note the alignment guides on the sides - https://www.amazon.com/Official-SCANTRON-Brand-Answer-Sheet/dp/B09X3L593T/ https://www.amazon.com/Official-SCANTRON-Brand-Answer-Sheet/... If the scanner detects a barcode page being entered (that was generated by a touch screen system), then one of the barcodes encodes the number 110408, and the barcode is read rather than trying to go from the scantron page guides. --- In the case, you've got the scanner here, you enter them into the scanner and get the vote counts "live". Then, you take them out of the secured spot and scan them all in to the other machine and compare the vote tallies. There is a paper ballot that is recording this. In the event that there is a recount, then the paper ballot is examined and the name next to the bubble is what the human auditor uses to count votes.
- jjeaff 4y agoThat's why almost all voting machines leave an auditable paper trail.
- theptip 4y agoI believe the generally accepted way of solving this problem is to do Risk Limiting Audits of the system; randomly sample districts, and then manually recount until you're confident to X sigma that the results are correct (or, if the audit diverges, you trigger a full manual recount). Citation: https://verifiedvoting.org/audits/whatisrla/ https://verifiedvoting.org/audits/whatisrla/ There's a recent report that goes into a lot of details on the various improvements that should be prioritized in the current system: https://nap.nationalacademies.org/catalog/25120/securing-the-vote-protecting-american-democracy https://nap.nationalacademies.org/catalog/25120/securing-the....
- WalterBright 4y agoBanks don't randomly apply banking controls to check for fraud, they do it for all the money flows. The original idea of double entry bookkeeping was to: 1. catch errors 2. make fraud much more difficult It's been in continuous use since the 13th century. It works. The reason it works is because an error, to remain undetected, requires a matching error somewhere else. That's what "balancing the books" means.
- teeray 4y agoRight, we’re not dealing with banks here. Ultimately we’re picking between N alternatives. The size of the gap between them doesn’t really matter, as long as it preserves the correct ordering of winners. Given that, using statistics to reduce your work is a completely reasonable efficiency here.
- WalterBright 4y agoBallots can be kept track of, just like dollar bills can be. It's not rocket science.
- specialist 4y agoThis is a terrific idea. For voting in the USA to be like banking, with matching credits and debits, some changes must first be made. Every eligible voter must be issued a ballot. Prerequisite is automatic universal voter registration. Every ballot must be fully marked. No under votes. Every issued ballot must be cast. aka Compulsory voting. You have my full support for your "voting like banking" reform.
- matrix_overload 4y agoThe problem isn't in the technology, the problem is with people. The idea of voting is that 2 groups with opposing views agree on a compromise - a fair set of rules that determines which side won. So if the losing is convinced that they've lost fair and square, they will focus on a better campaign next time, rather than on starting a revolt. Except for the past half-a-decade the media is increasingly pitting people against each other. Each side considers their rivals evil or crazy and is not ready to respect their opinion, listen or compromise. This creates incentives to cheat and legitimate reasons to suspect cheating. No matter what algorithmical or organizational approach you take, there will be always human factor, and hence reason for doubt. And the only way to resolve it is to make sure that you can always recheck the results in a way that satisfies the losing party, rather than screaming "blasphemy" to shut them up.
- squarefoot 4y agoThe damage is done. Currently I don't think there are ways to convince people that vote results are legit, short of eliminating secrecy and have every single person put their preference on a record that can be accessed anytime from anywhere. That however has its pros and cons, and is considered anti democratic.
- luxuryballs 4y agoI think the only way to improve things is to have a representative based system. Local community picks a rep, sends them to a higher level meeting, all the chosen reps pick a rep from among them to send to the next level, repeat and scale the number of layers as needed. Then there’s no mystery because everyone at each level knows who they agreed to send to represent them. Your party should just be your literal party, your local community. This whole top-down thing where powerful established groups that already have their own agenda tell you and your neighbors that you can only choose between a few of their chosen people to represent you has got to go, the agenda should be your agenda, the rep should be your rep. This is totally doable, repeal the 17th amendment for starters. Add more meeting houses next, counties/districts can have their own house that each elect the state Congress, etc, micro-service distributed architecture!
- adlpz 4y agoAuditable is the key. However I actually advocate for fully manual, several-humans-in-the-loop counting as it's been done forever and is still done in many other first world countries. That and scrupulous chain-of-trust on the actual ballots is , in my opinion, the only truly safe way.
- jillesvangurp 4y agoExactly. The problems in the US run way deeper than just the technicalities of voting. Both sides have been trying to bend the processes and rules their way for decades. Gerrymandering, campaign financing, elaborate propaganda campaigns, special interest lobbying (including by companies making voting machines), foreign interference (e.g. https://www.themoscowtimes.com/2022/11/07/putin-linked-businessman-admits-us-elections-interference-in-statement-a79310 https://www.themoscowtimes.com/2022/11/07/putin-linked-busin...), etc. There is no basis for trust here that parties are even trying to play by the rules. They are actively using every trick known to them to gain an advantage and the financial stakes are high enough for people to look the other way given enough plausible deniability. So, start with making the voting process as transparent as possible and just go back to counting votes manually. It won't solve all the issues but it will reduce the endless bickering about who actually won the votes that were issued.
- 2Gkashmiri 4y agowhy can't voting happen on machine-online in realtime basis? we can do polls for thousands and millions on facebook for example and the results are instant. everyone gets one vote and there is no double spend problems so why is political voting living in dark ages? sure it has open source software now but in india for example, machines are transported physcially, they are tampered with in the interim, machines get lost on and on isn't this a solved issue for any online portal?
- josephcsible 4y agoThe difference between Facebook polls and elections is that there aren't severe consequences of a Facebook poll indicating the wrong winner.
- 2Gkashmiri 4y agono. that is not my point. wrong people get elected without any real consequences so that is not really an issue. the question is about using technology.
- Akronymus 4y agoIf you can somehow intercept the data, you can correlate when someone voted with that data and possibly find out who they voted for through that
- 34675904565 4y agoFacebook polls are neither secret nor verifiable. Facebook knows how everyone voted, and voters cannot verify that Facebook is reporting the correct result. Those problems can theoretically be solved with cryptography (assuming the voter has full control of the device used to cast their vote), but not in a way the average voter can understand and verify. Another problem with online voting is that malware can infect a voter's device to spy on how they vote and/or change their vote. I don't think there is a solution to that problem. Online voting is a terrible idea. The only way to have secure elections is to publicly count every ballot by hand. If you think that's too expensive, you think electoral democracy is too expensive.
- renewiltord 4y agoWhy even bother with that? Could just release instant results and always do a manual count of the paper ballots in the background.
- h4kor 4y agoThe way to minimize the risk is to not use voting machines.
- eastbound 4y agoThe insistence of pro-machines is tiring. There is no argument in favor, in France with <5% voting machines, we know who’s the president with 95% certainty at 20:00:02 through television (through surveys, of course). So the argument “but it’s a big country!” doesn’t stand - France is already 67m. OTOH, if I were a foreign power intent on falsifying an american election, I’d push as hard as I can for voting machines.
- h4kor 4y agoSame in situation in Germany. Polls close at 18:00 and 18:01 everybody knows the general results. It will only change by ~0.1% over the next 1-2 days and only really matters if a party is close to the 5% hurdle.
- kaba0 4y agoTechnology strangely enough doesn’t solve voting — if there are publicly available machines, you can’t verify what is actually ran there, if they are some decentralized crypto-based “smart contract” you lose the ability to refrain from voting (e.g. an agressive husband can make her wife vote as he pleases, while with the traditional approach she can just go inside and say that she voted, while it’s truly up to her what she does. I think paper votes with people who count votes (getting representation from every party, as well as volunteers) is a fair and okay system — it’s not like it will scale. The problem is parties (their very limited number, and tendency to find small, often unimportant differences and use “us vs them” against us), electorates and that humans are dumb as a whole. Not sure how to solve these.
- simonh 4y agoPaper voting has scaled for many decades, in many countries just fine by being decentralised.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> What's important for voting confidence is having the count be auditable, which is much more important than having the machines be secure. After all, banks learned how to do that with money long ago. Having the count be auditable doesn't really help you. If you have a pile of ballots, and you can prove with certainty that you've correctly counted what they say, you've made zero steps toward legitimacy. Where did the ballots come from? This is a huge problem for secret ballots, where the goal of the system is that ballots can't be audited. It is not a problem for cash counting machines, because the only problem they're trying to solve is determining how much cash you have.
- cm2187 4y agoThey need to be counted locally. In France the ballot boxes are translucide and counted at the voting station by members of the public.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> In France the ballot boxes are translucide Penn and Teller, in one of my favorite jokes of theirs, say that an unwritten rule of the cups and balls trick is that you must not ever perform the cups and balls trick with clear plastic cups. However, magicians do frequently make something about a trick of theirs transparent - figuratively or literally - as a way of making you more surprised when they pull the trick off anyway. You were looking in the wrong place, at the transparent part of the trick. That's not to say transparent boxes are a bad idea. They really do make some attacks harder.
- arlcode 4y agoSame in Germany. It's local volunteers counting their local votes and the public is welcome to witness it (if they manage to behave and not try to disrupt the count). Until the proceedings are done the ballots do not move more than a few meters from where they were distributed and filled out. Switzerland regularly manages large referendums on paper just fine and AFAIK they use a similar system. But then these countries all vote on Sundays and with a sufficient number of polling stations (and higher voter turnout) so it usually takes no more than a few minutes. The US has some serious operational problems regarding it's election system even before talking about the political side.
- specialist 4y agoThis is a novel take on the problem of election integrity. Auditing in elections is called a full manual recount. Verification in elections is the phrase for inspecting the hardware, software, processes, results. Which is probably why election integrity focused orgs have names like Election Verification Network and Verified Voting. You did say "confidence", which is the correct framing, rather than "trust". Much like our Constitution, confidence in our elections are built on "an orgy of mistrust", eg I watch you and you watch me, and when ultimately all the participants abide by the final results. Which is moot when one party's platform is to reject the results, regardless of objective reality. I don't have a clue how to address the cultural, sociological, and realpolitick parts of our country's current discord wrt election integrity. Though I do know there's no technical fix. Perhaps someday that party's voters will stop rewarding such belligerence.