3 ms·
> It's true that there are certain typographical requirements that must be met in certain court filings, but I have also seen lawyers bikeshed in Word by obsess
by rayiner 4y ago
> It's true that there are certain typographical requirements that must be met in certain court filings, but I have also seen lawyers bikeshed in Word by obsessing over things as menial as left vs. justified text alignment (and then even decide how to rephrase language after changing to justified alignment because they don't like the rivers[1] they are now seeing)
Lawyers fight over this stuff for the same reason programs fight over 4 spaces versus 8 spaces indentation. Judges have to read hundreds if not thousands of pages of briefing a week. Making it a little easier for the judge to follow your point does make a difference.
And will it win or lose cases? Probably not. But how often do appellate briefs argue that the trial judge “overlooked” or “misapprehended” some argument? Stuff gets lost in the shuffle and sometimes not putting the best version of your argument out there leads to bad rulings.
And just as in software, spending a little time up front to learn a standardized style and best practices means that in practice it should be muscle memory and take very little time to churn out briefs that look nice and are easy to read typographically.
(Also, ragged justification is a crutch for people who don’t know how to use soft hyphens. There’s a reason you never see a magazine or book with ragged justification.)