2 ms·
To your point, at least with Condorcet, you can say that the winner was preferred to every other candidate by a majority of people. That isn't a specification o
by mindslight 4y ago
To your point, at least with Condorcet, you can say that the winner was preferred to every other candidate by a majority of people. That isn't a specification of the counting process, but it seems like a pretty straightforward definition of a winner that most everyone can understand.
Runoff voting seems to completely fall to your criticism, in that the outcome can be non-intuitive and really does depend on the counting process. Heck I understand the algorithm and can still foresee examples where it would feel completely unfair.
The real criticism of Condorcet is the possibility of ties. But really that seems like more of a feature, compared to a greedy algorithm that produces non-intuitive outputs. If there is a Condorcet tie, then that should be considered exceptional and a winner should be chosen some other way. Or heck, maybe the winners should be the whole group of 3+ tied candidates, who'd then need a quorum amongst themselves for every action in office.