7 ms·
Such an awesome accomplishment. Also, it’s interestingly a huge black eye to the CCP: news of this Indian accomplishment will be censored in China, because it
by mensetmanusman 4y ago
Such an awesome accomplishment.
Also, it’s interestingly a huge black eye to the CCP: news of this Indian accomplishment will be censored in China, because it proves that nations can progress without forced-sterilization/-abortion/-1-child-policy/authoritarianism/ etc.
- ardit33 4y agoI think this is a world wide trend as well. Humanity is progressing with every generation. (this is true even in Africa). Some countries progressing faster though, (China being one of them).
- Shoue 4y agoIn absolute terms, yes we are seeing advancements in tech/medicine and the like and that will always help more and more people, but in more relative economic terms it's questionable whether the gap between poorer nations and richer ones is actually closing, because there is economic evidence that the gap is actually widening: > Net Resource Transfers (NRT) for all developing countries have been mostly large and negative since the early 1980s, indicating sustained and significant outflows from the developing world (see graph below) https://gfintegrity.org/press-release/new-report-on-unrecorded-capital-flight-finds-developing-countries-are-net-creditors-to-the-rest-of-the-world/ https://gfintegrity.org/press-release/new-report-on-unrecord...
- richard___ 4y agoWhy do so many people on HN hate on China? What's your relationship with Chinese people in your personal life?
- FooBarWidget 4y agoAs a Chinese I want to say thank you for posting this. It's really ridiculous...
- oska 4y agoMore than ridiculous, it's often outright bigotry (the original comment here being firmly in that category).
- Gil-galad 4y agoIt's not the Chinese people, they are in general awesome people. It's the CCP.
- TotoHorner 4y agoHating the CCP != hating Chinese people. Amazing that this needs to be said...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- burntbridge 4y agoAnd when there is a war?
- iwillbenice 4y ago
- m4jor 4y agoBecause China is the number one threat to democracy and the US. They also are responsible for stealing hundreds of billions of dollars of IP from the US every single year. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allegations_of_intellectual_property_theft_by_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allegations_of_intellectual_pr... And masters at stealing R&D and tech from US companies for their own use https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Chinese_spy_cases_in_the_United_States_of_America https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Chinese_spy_cases_in_t... https://www.cbsnews.com/news/chinese-hackers-took-trillions-in-intellectual-property-from-about-30-multinational-companies/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/chinese-hackers-took-trillions-...
- paxys 4y agoUSA is the number one threat to democracy in the USA. There's no point continuing to blame China, Russia or whoever else for domestic problems.
- m4jor 4y agoNation-state hackers from Russia and China are certainly running active campaigns in US elections to disrupt or manipulate them. https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2022/10/17/chinese-hackers-are-scanning-state-political-party-headquarters-fbi-says/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2022/10/17/chinese-h... Best evidence of this is the previous 2020 elections.
- paxys 4y agoAnd the USA is doing the same to other countries. It is a given that this happens, and will continue to happen. You measure how strong a democracy is by how well they can resist such campaigns. If some random Russian bots can trigger a coup in the strongest and richest country in the world then, well, that's on us.
- e-clinton 4y ago“the US is doing the same to other countries” Source? “If some random Russian not can trigger a coup” It’s still an act of aggression regardless of whether the US is equipped to deal with it. While I agree that the US does lots of shitty things, we have way more checks and balances than our key enemies. For one, it is the people who elect those who represent us.
- socialdemocrat 4y agoI just have an issue with the CCP and their apologists. That is primarily who people refer to when they say China. It is pretty common speech. Same when talking about America doing something, we refer to the US government primarily, not its people.
- boxed 4y agoThe heros in the story of Chinas amazing numbers of people lifted out of poverty is Deng Xiaoping and his successors. They've been basically thrown out with Xi. So modern China is unfortunately on the totally wrong trajectory. It's ok to say "China was going the right direction between years X and Y" without being an "apologist".
- ohiovr 4y agoDeng was a heck of alot better than the guy before him.
- DiogenesKynikos 4y agoThe problem is that many people who say, "I just hate the CCP" go on to say things like, * "China steals everything" (which essentially labels Chinese people as thieves). * "Chinese scientists created CoVID-19 and then lied about it" (alleging that Chinese scientists have no integrity). * "China only copies" (implying that Chinese people aren't creative). * "Chinese numbers are all fake" (implying that millions of Chinese people are in on some conspiracy to fake everything). In other words, in my experience, many people who say they just hate the CCP actually hold a huge number of negative stereotypes about Chinese people, and have a very conspiratorial view of the country. One fact that everyone here should take into consideration is that the Communist Party has a very broad base of support in China, and is fairly popular. Most people actually approve of the central government, not in everything, but in general. If the Communist Party were as comically evil as people in the West tend to think, it wouldn't have this level of support, and it would lose power pretty quickly. And one can't explain its popularity by claiming that Chinese people don't know what's going on - they tend to be far better informed about happenings in China than 99% of commenters in your average English-language internet forum. If you can't imagine why people in China would support the government, just consider the fundamental transformation that hundreds of millions of people have gone through in the last few decades. People who did not even have running hot water in their homes or reliable electricity are now wealthy enough to fly to Paris for a week. I'm not trying to paint a rosy picture of the Chinese government or the Party, but I'm just pointing out that things are significantly more nuanced than most people here think.
- dabernathy89 4y ago"Why do so many people hate brutal, authoritarian governments?"
- roflc0ptic 4y agoMy relationship with Chinese people is great. I have a chinese ex, whose mom is hyper critical of the CCP and hates communism. They’re not Han chinese, they’re one of the less desirable ethnicities, and they didn’t feel well treated. Anyways. Authoritarian regimes are bad. The fact that this authoritarian regime has mongoloid/asiatic facial features is irrelevant. I hated GWB’s expansion of the security state and two senseless middle eastern wars, I hated Obama killing American citizens without trial, and I hated Trump’s… everything, basically, but admittedly withdrawing from Afghanistan was p cool. Stopped clocks etc. Anyways it’s totally consistent with wanting a just world to also hate the largest authoritarian regime in that world. This “but what if it’s because you’re racist?!?!” line is an absurdity
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bergenty 4y agoIt’s the exact opposite. I don’t think anyone hates the Chinese people, just the CCP and primarily because it’s authoritarian and fast becoming the US’ main rival.
- _zamorano_ 4y agoIt's the double standards, you know. Not being able to vote, and so... While the US and its war machine has lost track of destroyed countries in this last decades in an Orwellian permanent conflict. But the bad guys are the chinese, who hasn't been involved in a war in 40 years.
- richard___ 4y agoRaise your hand if you hate the CCP and you have a Chinese ex. There is already one guy who said as much in this thread.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoThe CCP is not China, they have actively destroyed ancient Chinese culture bulldozing over historical sites to build strip malls…
- endisneigh 4y agoWhy would it be a black eye to the ccp when they’ve lifted twice as many from poverty as India? And far higher growth, gdp per capita, etc. weird comment https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/2022/04/01/lifting-800-million-people-out-of-poverty-new-report-looks-at-lessons-from-china-s-experience https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/2022/04/01/l...
- artificialLimbs 4y agoAre those numbers from China? Is there a reason to trust them if so, considering they would be coming from a brutal, authoritarian dictator?
- mc32 4y agoI wouldn’t doubt that they are roughly accurate. The question is is the growth worth the pound of flesh the CCP takes as its right in return for that growth and social stability? Another fair question is could it not have been achieved through a more humane system of governance?
- scaramanga 4y agoWhat is interesting to me is that these questions never arise of eg. South Korea.
- wahnfrieden 4y agoYou’ve just met with cognitive dissonance
- rhaway84773 4y agoBecause the CCP’s (more specifically Xi Jinping’s) entire thesis is that democracies are incapable of producing good outcomes. A lot of the move towards authoritarianism that we’ve been seeing in the world has been driven by the success of the “China model”. If India is successful to a similar degree as China, that shatters this belief, especially since there are very significant questions about the Chinese economy and how stable it is. A lot of the numbers appear to be made up in a way India simply cannot do. And if Democracies can achieve success, Chinese citizens themselves may consider it as the better alternative as it might indicate that China’s economic success was less the result of the CCP and more because the Chinese government chose to move towards a Western capitalist economic system a couple of decades before India.
- diordiderot 4y agoAnd all the Chinese got was 2.5x GDP per capita
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoThey also have 300% debt to GDP compared to 84% for India. We'll never know how much more advanced India would be if they invested as much in infrastructure.
- dirtyid 4y agoYou're comparing national debt with total debt. PRC national debt gdp is ~70%, LOWER than India ~90%. Also PRC has 5.5x the GDP / per capita vs India.
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoThat's including debt held by "private" corporations that are extensions of the state. All the mega banks in China are indistinguishable from the state - you're looking at 100% of debt to GDP on their balance sheets alone.
- Aunche 4y ago> They also have 300% debt to GDP compared to 84% for India. You're comparing the total debt of China with the national debt of India.
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoIndia doesn't have "private" corporations which are just an extension of the state. All the mega banks in China are indistinguishable from the state - you're looking at 100% of debt to GDP on their balance sheets alone.
- scarmig 4y agoI think the relevant figures here would be how much of each countries' banks' balance sheets are de facto liabilities to the state. I can buy that Chinese banks incur more liability for their government than Indian banks do for theirs; I don't buy the idea that China is 100% liable for its banks' balance sheets while India is 0% liable for its banks' balance sheets.
- dirtyid 4y agoWut, India started from a better state, took same amount of time, to progress 1/5th as much, while still having north korean tier food insecurity. Dooming generations and hundreds of millions of avoidable deaths due to being stuck in poverty for longer than need be. There's nothing to be envious about. Also eliminating rural poverty + building rural infra is the actual hard part that takes time and resources. We'll have to see if India has the resources to even get there, PRC didn't until $6000 gdp per capita. India and by extention relying on democracies to develop still a case of what not to do. Also India did their own sterilization / family planning campaign.
- keepquestioning 4y agoThe truth hurts...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- scarmig 4y ago1) At this point, the CCP internally considers the 1 child policy a mistake. I'm sure this news won't be widely published within China, but mentioning it is not going to get anyone into trouble. Plenty of people complain about the one child policy, and so long as you don't call for the downfall of the CCP because of it, you're fine. 2) India has its own sordid history with coercive sterilization. During the Emergency, millions of people were sterilized, under varying levels of compulsion.
- odysseus 4y agoRegarding 1), the documentary "One Child Nation" (currently included with Amazon Prime) goes into China's history with their one child policy in detail - from people who lived through it. It is fascinating how they went from "One Child" to their current policy without admitting any mistake at all. --- As for India, not only have they had problems with forced sterilization, they've also had problems with parents wanting a son at any cost: https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2021/dec/27/families-want-a-son-at-any-cost-the-women-forced-to-abort-female-foetuses-in-india https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2021/dec/27/f...
- yorwba 4y agoThe United Nations Development Programme announced it 20 days ago on their official WeChat account and the post is still up: https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/JAY6_fef5htRqbnOQwnoFg https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/JAY6_fef5htRqbnOQwnoFg Also, re: "without forced-sterilization" https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-30040790 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-30040790
- burntbridge 4y agoForced sterilization is something India did do.
- pxue 4y agosure, no forced sterilization. just nation level apathy on child mortality in lower class citizens.
- vkou 4y ago32 years ago, GDP per capita in China and India was $300. Today, GDP per capita in India is $2,200. It is $12,500 in China. I'm not sure that 'Six times faster growth, and eight years of life expectancy, and seven times fewer people facing hunger and food insecurity' is as much of a black eye as you think. I could think of quite a few Americans who would happily embrace a one-party state, if it meant that they wouldn't lose five sixths of their wealth and income, and eight years of their life, and have a one-in-seven chance of having to seriously face starvation. Most of them, actually.
- ohiovr 4y agoLife under a king can be great but it always depends on the king.
- FooBarWidget 4y agoThis makes absolutely no sense given how everybody in China knows that western countries are richer. China is not North Korea, there is no information blackout. The average Chinese knows a lot more about, say, the US than the average American about China. Chinese policies are meant to solve Chinese problems (whether they are successful is a different discussion). The government is in the business of producing results, ideology is secondary.
- dang 4y ago"Eschew flamebait. Avoid generic tangents." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html