6 ms·
> For whatever reason with C there’s this huge emotional component to it. Frankly getting your knickers in a knot is emotional - the people using C are doing s
by lelanthran 4y ago
> For whatever reason with C there’s this huge emotional component to it.
Frankly getting your knickers in a knot is emotional - the people using C are doing so for pragmatic reasons, not emotion.
I do see comments like yours a lot - there's an emotional attachment and/or ego attached to the comment, so the argument against is very vociferous and, honestly, ugly[1].
[1] C and asbestos have almost nothing in common in terms of negative impact on the world. Maybe people are still using C because hyperbole is simply not a persuasive argument.
- meltyness 4y agoYou don't seem to address the "pragmatic reasons" expressly, so I'll go ahead and do it: 1. "Don't rewrite code" a fundamental precept of software that has been "engineered" - This is more about development lifecycles than something that contributes usefully to software quality in the long term. Corporations, and people haven't been treating these things like bridges or overpasses 2. Outsourcing is believed cheaper than the solution. - Again, paying low-wage junior SEs to patch uncovered bugs is obviously cheaper than proactively finding them all. 3. You can sell the New Coke too! - If you have a good rewrite, sell it at a fat markup, and keep selling the old crap too, it's not your risk. - Obviously don't rewrite unless your horrid monolithic source leaks, and you're certain that it's a problem, those disgruntled workers you wrongfully laid off know too much. 4. If your tech references are a security risk, sell those too! - Don't include pesky manuals where people can uncover issues with your development processes, outsource a minimum blackbox of guess work to Singapore and let that double as QA. - It's not a manual, it's 'training' -- supporting education of hopeful workers! Wow! I won't name any names.
- zamalek 4y ago> I do see comments like yours a lot - there's an emotional attachment and/or ego attached to the comment Could you explain how it's emotional? It comes across as a pretty logical analogy to me - the author isn't suggesting that they don't like C (which would be categorically emotional), they are comparing it to phasing out something unsafe in another industry.
- ectospheno 4y agoA truth stated passionately doesn’t become false. A falsehood stated calmly doesn’t become true. This is at the heart of why emotion is always a logical fallacy. Everyone would be better served by using and hearing it less. Focus on the actual argument.
- zamalek 4y agoI am neurodivergent, so I may be missing something here. The argument seems pretty passionless. Excluding the assumption that C is unsafe, it contains purely facts. Your reply doesn't point out the passionate component of it either, and doesn't answer my question.
- ulfbert_inc 4y agoAnalogy is not an argument.
- zamalek 4y agoThat still doesn't point out the emotion in the comment. Your reply here would work as a reply to the root comment, but doesn't address what I am asking at all. Where is the passion?
- ulfbert_inc 4y agoFine, but that leaves us with passionless non-argument. How is it helpful?
- Jtsummers 4y agoAsbestos is an emotionally charged topic for many people, especially the many who have (primarily) older relatives who have died or are dying from cancers caused by it. The analogy is resting primarily on the appeal to that kind of emotion without actually establishing a strong logical similarity between C and asbestos.
- bpye 4y ago> Frankly getting your knickers in a knot is emotional - the people using C are doing so for pragmatic reasons, not emotion. I think a lot of us using C would like to move away, but for whatever reason can’t. One example is that we hotpatch our binaries, but that sort of infrastructure doesn’t exist for Rust. Beyond tooling issues, that certainly can be fixed, it’s also non trivial to move a large codebase to a safer language. Maybe incremental use of languages like Rust is still better?