2 ms·
No. I'm thinking that a BitTorrent client, in my naive understanding, should share the file while it downloads it. Otherwise it's just a client/server system, i
by palata 4y ago
No. I'm thinking that a BitTorrent client, in my naive understanding, should share the file while it downloads it. Otherwise it's just a client/server system, isn't it?
That code is only downloading, as far as I can tell. Never sharing the file. I was just asking if that's tolerated in BitTorrent. My guess was that it is not.
- mdaniel 4y agoIt is a client/server system, but pulling from $n hosts instead of just 1, spreading out the load and also downtime risk across all $n hosts. And the reason I mentioned the "ratio currency" is your use of the word "tolerated" here: BitTorrent isn't the mafia, it's just a protocol that offers the ability to share pieces back to the Internet. As another concrete example, aria2c (https://github.com/aria2/aria2#readme https://github.com/aria2/aria2#readme) behaves similarly: using BT to download, but then exiting without attempting to seed anything
- palata 4y ago> It is a client/server system, but pulling from $n hosts instead of just 1, spreading out the load and also downtime risk across all $n hosts. Well the point of peer to peer is that peers share while they download. Otherwise, if everyone only downloads, then it doesn't really get distributed. Also I meant client/server in opposition to p2p. Many non-p2p systems "on the cloud" spread the load and downtime risk across machines, that is independent from the p2p part. > using BT to download, but then exiting without attempting to seed anything I am not saying that you should keep sharing after it is downloaded. But typically BT clients "force" you to share while downloading. > And the reason I mentioned the "ratio currency" is your use of the word "tolerated" here: BitTorrent isn't the mafia, it's just a protocol that offers the ability to share pieces back to the Internet. Sure, sorry for my english, not my mothertongue :-). I know it is not the mafia, and I know it is a protocol. I used the word "tolerated" to ask whether or not, in practice, that gets you banned.