13 ms·
A crash dummy aimed at protecting women drivers
- cumshitpiss 4y agoCool, crazy this wasn't done sooner
- mythhouse 4y ago> but the currently available test dummies don’t reflect the average female body Do they reflect average american body though, male or female. > Their dummy is 5-foot-3 and weighs about 137 pounds, per the publication. "The average American woman weighs 170.6 pounds and stands at 63.7 inches (almost 5 feet, 4 inches) tall. And the average waist circumference? It's 38.6 inches." Per google. Looks like the male dummy actually reflects average American woman in weight at 171.
- ilyt 4y agoStats on car accident injury rate vs BMI would be interesting but I'd imagine something like "the fatter the safer" (up to some level) would be the conclusion and so testing on skinnier model is harsher and will result in better safety.
- klyrs 4y agoThe heavier a person is, the more kinetic energy they have. Moreover, seatbelts don't really stop a person until flesh is sufficiently compressed against bone. From that, I'd reason that skinny people should have a higher survival rate. Intuition be damned, data is important. It shouldn't be hard to spec and built crash test dummies with simulated fat.
- PartiallyTyped 4y agoLower momentum one way or the other sounds like the best predictor.
- Xamayon 4y agoJust 'spitballing', but if the restraints are adequate, the compression of flesh may act to slow down and spread out the force of the accident to a certain degree. Bruising may be more likely, and the increased overall force might break ribs and such, but increased weight may have some benefits at some speeds/in some scenarios. Some possible downsides would be overwhelming the airbags capacity, and larger overall volume of space which needs to be protected from intrusion/crushing/etc. I Wonder how much this has been studied, hard rubber and steel dummies probably don't reflect conditions at the extremes very well...
- tjoff 4y agoThat is exactly what the crumple zone in the car is for though. You only have X meters of margin before you need to be at full stop. Assuming (dangerous to assume, yes) it does its job perfectly the most important factor becomes to react, that is to start the slow down as quickly as possible so you can utilize the crumple zone to max effect. I feel like flesh compression will mostly delay the impact rather than properly slowing you down (fast enough), which would be a bad thing. That is in part also why it is so important to have a properly tightened seat belt and why we have explosives to tighten it up further when a collision is detected.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoFit people also recover faster, which probably gives them a better survival rate over all. Fit people are probably less likely to linger with persistent injuries before perishing. Consider particularly the difficulty diabetics have with infection.
- ilyt 4y agoRight but we're not talking about energy of the homogenous object. The brain or heart or lungs of fat person won't be that much heavier, but the fat around it might work as cushion to spread the spike of deceleration over longer period (less G's over longer period of time basically). Then again, the fat on the other (back) side of the person might compress squishy stuff inside more so I dunno how well that can be simulated in a dummy
- voxic11 4y agoUsing only averages can lead to pretty misleading results. https://www.thestar.com/news/insight/2016/01/16/when-us-air-force-discovered-the-flaw-of-averages.html https://www.thestar.com/news/insight/2016/01/16/when-us-air-...
- hirundo 4y agoWhich is a good argument for using a range of test values, not for using less representative values.
- kolbe 4y agoCars aren't cheap
- thfuran 4y agoCompared to the cost of designing a car then manufacturing hundreds of thousands or millions of them, a handful of cars are pretty cheap.
- kolbe 4y agoDepends on how far down you want to go with all the people sizes in all the various combinations of positions. I imagine the cost-benefit is based on the marginal change of information you get by changing the dummy size/shape, and based on their revealed behavior, they don't think more sizes add more information.
- sgtnoodle 4y agoWhen I worked at Toyota, they used "number of Highlanders" equivalence when shaming people for not picking up their large format paper schematic prints.
- Tade0 4y agoAccording to this: https://dqydj.com/weight-percentile-calculator-men-women/ https://dqydj.com/weight-percentile-calculator-men-women/ That female dummy would have been in the 24th weight percentile, while the male in the 57th female weight percentile.
- vxNsr 4y agoAsking about avg isn’t a great idea, you really want the modal, which might be near the avg but may not be. This was an issue that came up when they tried to design the optimal fighter cockpit in WWII, they designed a cockpit that fit no one well.
- KarlKode 4y agoI think you mean the median.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- MichaelCollins 4y agoIf there's no average male pilot, there's certainly no average driver, male or female. If tests with dummies are to be useful, they have to be interpreted as abstract results, not assumed to correspond 1:1 with what any individual human body would do. This "female" test dummy won't actually be representative of most drivers, just as the "male" test dummy isn't. Neither for men nor for women. I'm sure the people who interpret the test results understand this already of course.
- prydwen 4y agoA woman is not just 'a smaller male'. Male dummies do not take into account female's different weight distribution, muscle mass etc. This is one of the reasons why women are much more likely than men to die or be seriously injured in a car crash. The book 'Invisible women' by Caroline Criado Perez has a section about this, I highly recommend it.
- treis 4y agoDummies don't take muscles or weight distribution into account. They're metal skeletons with rubber bodies over them. This is one of those discrimination situations where the truth is actually the exact opposite of what is reported. The dummies tested are 4'11 95 pounds and 5'9" 171 pounds. If the extremes pass then it's likely everyone in between is fine. The people who aren't covered are those above 5'9" or 171 pounds which skews heavily male.
- watwut 4y agoThe dummy in video seems to be way closer to woman then just size. For example, it has breasts. Those matter for seat belt position. So yeah, it seems that dummy is more then just smaller. But honestly, dont see issue. Men are loosing nothing in this. Male dummies will continue to be used too.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoThe dummy's breasts don't seem to move in the video despite the impacts, I think they're probably made out of steel, or a very stiff rubber. I doubt they accurately simulate real breasts, I think they're on the dummy to convey femaleness.
- watwut 4y agoThey don't need to move much. The issue I noticed is that when my breasts grew, some safety belts went through throat (previously did not). They push the belt to the side.
- anotherman554 4y agoI don't how they chose the dummy size and weight but they seem to do crash dummies based on median bodies, not "average" bodies, and the researchers who made the female dummy were Swedish so presumably wouldn't care about American sizes.
- mythhouse 4y agoNHTSA uses the word average not median.
- ryeights 4y agoMedian is an average.
- lukeschlather 4y agoNHTSA says 50th percentile: https://www.nhtsa.gov/nhtsas-crash-test-dummies https://www.nhtsa.gov/nhtsas-crash-test-dummies
- mythhouse 4y agoAh Thanks. I was going off the image in the linked article https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-62877930 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-62877930
- 988747 4y agoSo the average American woman looks like a ball chair, basically? Something is wrong with your data here :)
- alistairSH 4y agoThe average women's clothing size is now 16 or 18 (up from 12 or 14 in 2010). It corresponds to about a 38" waist. Average height is around 5'4", which has been mostly consistent over the last 20 years. That's shockingly large to me. I knew Americans were obese, but wow.
- adrianN 4y agoI wonder how useful averages are since you can be (almost) arbitrarily fat, but die very quickly when you're even a little underweight. I guess the minimum waist size for an adult female is still double-digit inches, but I wouldn't dare guess the maximum waist size.
- alistairSH 4y agoOh yeah, as noted in parallel comments, averages are terrible for things like designing airplane cockpits, and I imagine crash dummies as well. Even if there's an unexpected distribution, that's no way around there being a massive number of very obese women to pull the average to 38". I thought my wife was pretty normal/average-ish at 5'4" and size 6/8, which is a full 10" smaller waist than the web is claiming as the average.
- bombcar 4y agoNote that a 10" shorter waist is only about 1.5" on a side (diameter of 9 inches vs 12) which is noticeable but not as much as "10 inches" would make you think.
- Blahah 4y agoThat difference is visually absolutely vast - for the same height, in most sizing charts, it's approximating a 50% increase in body mass.
- starkd 4y ago
- nharada 4y agoYour comment is supposed to be sarcastic, but it is still pretty limiting to try and cover the entire statistical distribution of human bodies with just two crash test dummies.
- dmkirwan 4y agoIf you were shocked that this is only happening now, I'd highly recommend reading or listening to the book "Invisible Women" by Caroline Criado-Perez. She highlights instances of this across many industries. I think that it's particularly relevant to software engineers, or anybody else who has a chance of unintentionally introducing bias into a system.
- prydwen 4y ago+1, this book was an eye opener and a bit of a slap in the face
- chroma 4y agoI disagree. If you get to a part of the book where you have some knowledge of the industry she's criticizing, it's clear how mistaken is. For example, her bit about phone sizes was glaringly bad. She thinks that every phone manufacturer is sexist and builds large phones which don't work as well with women's smaller hands. While the hand size thing is obviously true, women prefer larger phones because larger phones have better battery life, better hardware specs, and better cameras. And since most women carry purses, their phone choice isn't constrained by pocket sizes. If women really did want smaller phones, then the iPhone Mini would have sold far more than it did. But phone size is a tradeoff, and smaller phones are a niche product due to their worse specs. It's as simple as that. No industry-wide sexism is involved.
- fallingfrog 4y agoI'm pretty much floored that they haven't been using female measured test dummies for years now. Are women's lives really valued so cheaply?
- shuntress 4y agoAs another comment put it, it is assumed that women are the same as "smaller men". So it is more like they are not thought of rather than "cheaply valued".
- guerrilla 4y agoOkay, but you'd think if they were equally valued that they'd check, no?
- shuntress 4y agoIt's the difference between: "We will run 10 clinical trials testing the efficacy of this drug in men and 5 clinical trials testing its efficacy in women" and "We will run 10 clinical trials testing the efficacy of this drug in men and suggest women take a lower dose"
- maerF0x0 4y agoYeah, so much so that they live something like 7 years longer on average. /s
- Sakos 4y agoI think in many aspects of life, sure, but here it could simply be something akin to how the US air force realized that the idea of "average" seating in jet planes was dangerous and completely divorced from reality, driving their push for individually customizable seating. I think it's still ubiquitous that we measure things that aren't clearly generalizable across a wider population, but we think they are.
- Beltalowda 4y agoIf we look at ~100 years of history with cars, I think it's fairly safe to say that no one's lives are especially valued. Leaded gasoline was introduced even though the dangers were already well understood, it had to take a massive public outcry campaign to get car manufacturers to do anything about driver safety ("Unsafe at any speed" and such), pedestrian and cyclist safety is still under-prioritized in designs, etc.
- maerF0x0 4y ago> women are 17 percent more likely to die in a car crash and 73 percent more likely to sustain serious injuries in a front-end collision. It makes sense to at least measure the differences and hopefully we can find ways to improve overall safety. However I am automatically wondering a gender disparity in outcomes is a simple issue about genetics? Average women are far less muscular and are less robust than men, it makes sense given the same forces they'd be more damaged than men. Thats going to be something you cannot fix (if you distribute the forces more evenly then both genders will still have disparate outcomes due to structural differences) One thing that these kinds of articles never seem to address is what is an acceptable rate? To illustrate the point with arbitrary numbers is a 1% improvement worth $10B ? IDK, but that's more of the kind of effort I'd like to see from writers.
- Sander_Marechal 4y agoIIRC a similar study was done in Europe. The conclusion was that women are indeed more likely to die or sustain serious injuries, but that the cause of that was that woman, on average, drive smaller cars. So, they are more vulnerable in a collision. Just look around you. How often do you see families where the man is driving the big fancy SUV and the woman is driving the smaller "second" car?
- yamtaddle 4y ago> Just look around you. How often do you see families where the man is driving the big fancy SUV and the woman is driving the smaller "second" car? Maybe it's a regional thing, but around here the big SUV replaced the minivan as a "women's car". I hear safety (i.e. wanting to "win" in a crash, often phrased exactly like that) as a common reason for the choice. Their husband will drive a similarly-huge truck, usually.
- walthamstow 4y agoI have heard exactly the same sentiment from women here in the UK. Not a single one of the women I have spoken to about this realise they are participating in an arms race. The husband in the UK will more likely drive a fast, sexy coupe/hatchback/saloon with a large engine, rather than a truck.
- yafinder 4y agoNow I wonder what about children? Do they have different dummies for different ages and different car seat sizes? If not, what's the equivalent of > women are 17 percent more likely to die in a car crash > and 73 percent more likely to sustain serious injuries for children?
- consp 4y agoThere is an average child test for 6 and 10 year dummies at NCAP AFAIK. Car seat sizes should not be relevant as all children should have some form of riser/child seat to be properly protected (and never front facing on the front seat).
- michaelt 4y agoAccording to [1] there are crash test dummies used to represent newborn, 12-month, 3-year-old, 6-year-old and 10-year-old children. They also have a 5th-percentile adult female dummy, which is closer in height and weight to the 10-year-old dummy than to the 50th-percentile-male dummy. [1] https://www.nhtsa.gov/nhtsas-crash-test-dummies https://www.nhtsa.gov/nhtsas-crash-test-dummies
- justferlafs 4y ago
- snshn 4y ago
- sgt 4y agoSexist would be to imply the female dummies come with builtin airbags.
- watwut 4y agoHow would female crash dummy implied anything about driving?
- golemiprague 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Traubenfuchs 4y ago
- a3w 4y agoLooking for any mark of sarkasm here.
- drc500free 4y agoAnything to do with gender on HN runs into Poe's Law basically instantly.
- Traubenfuchs 4y ago
- enragedcacti 4y agoHow many women's lives are a fair trade for one man's life?
- Traubenfuchs 4y ago
- enragedcacti 4y agoI'm not sure what answer I expected but extinguishing all humanity was definitely not it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- londons_explore 4y agoI am worried that cars are designed to pass a few really specific tests well, for example 'head on at 40 mph', 'side impact at 30 mph', but then perform much worse in a 'typical' crash, for example '37 degrees, offset by 6 inches, at 38 mph'. I'd like to see the test methodology changed to correct this. Car manufacturers should be required to simulate what would happen in say 10,000 crash cases - with a wide variety of angles, loads, speeds, passenger types, offsets, etc. The car manufacturer should then present all those results to the NHTSA, who will then pick a few at random to test on a real car to validate the simulations. The safety rating would be some average of performance of all the 10,000 simulated test cases, with a scaling penalty applied if the simulations didn't accurately reflect reality.
- bombcar 4y ago> I am worried that cars are designed to pass a few really specific tests well, for example 'head on at 40 mph', 'side impact at 30 mph', but then perform much worse in a 'typical' crash, for example '37 degrees, offset by 6 inches, at 38 mph This is literally the case: https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a40824939/iihs-side-impact-crash-test-sedans-wagons-results/ https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a40824939/iihs-side-impact... (and an earlier one that was added and IIRC only Volvo did well, because Volvo was testing it before it was required: https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a18737558/iihs-adds-new-frontal-crash-test-most-cars-expected-to-perform-poorly/ https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a18737558/iihs-adds-new-fr... ) I agree that digital simulation should become an important part - including aftermath simulation from actual wrecks.
- dont__panic 4y agoI wish companies had to test new cars in collisions against the smallest, most vulnerable vehicles on the road. Cars exist in a shared environment; if Ford creates a new, taller, heavier F-250, it shouldn't be allowed on the road unless there's a reasonable chance that it won't brutally crush anyone driving, say, a 2005 Honda Civic sedan around in the event of a collision.
- lamontcg 4y agoThis was my first thought about the sex differences in accidents which is that they might reflect the average vehicle weight being driven.
- andrewmcwatters 4y agoSpecifications are important, but it's funny how you arrive at them and what defining them over time reveals even if it's obvious on its face. When I was doing work on default player mass on Planimeter Game Engine 2D, we would reference the average male weight to serve as the specification for player characters' mass so we would have some reasonable metric defined for physics calculations. The team also did work on the Quake family of engines and so from time to time we would reference Source, and QuakeWorld. It turned out that between the time that Valve's Source Engine had been written and the time that Planimeter Game Engine 2D was written, the average male weight had went up by a fair amount, because they too used an average male weight for the default player mass for their physics calculations as well.
- uri4 4y ago
- dang 4y agoWe've banned this account for posting too many unsubstantive and/or flamebait comments. If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email hn@ycombinator.com and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future. They're here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
- SeanLuke 4y agoIf I may be pedantic: > Compared to men, women are 17 percent more likely to die in a car crash and 73 percent more likely to sustain serious injuries in a front-end collision. Yet despite these discrepancies, car companies are only required to test vehicle safety using crash dummies modeled after the average man. Guinea pigs are 2000% more likely to die in a car crash and 10000% more likely to sustain serious injuries in a front-end collision. We don't make crash dummies for guinea pigs. Since to objective is to reduce overall injury, the primary justification for a female crash dummy would be based not on the probabity of injury if you are a woman, but the probability of being a woman if you have received injury. This is of course also very high -- and it's great to see female crash dummies, long overdue. I'm just irritated at such sloppy writing.
- LordDragonfang 4y agoGuinea pigs don't drive cars, women do.
- SeanLuke 4y agoDid the paragraph say driver? Even so, when a guinea pig is driving, it is 100000% more likely to die in a car crash! The point is, I think, that the reporter needs a lesson in Bayes Law.
- habinero 4y agoThanks for valuing women as highly as guinea pigs.
- LordDragonfang 4y ago>A crash dummy aimed at protecting women drivers The title of the article that we are currently discussing. Please don't pretend your comment doesn't exist in the context of the discussion it's a reply to, that's somewhere between dishonest motte-and-bailey and blatantly bad comment etiquette. (And beyond that, you're not even using a proper application of Bayes Law anyway, since "probability of injury if you are a woman" is what you should be concerned with if you're building safety devices)
- runnerup 4y agoThis isn’t the first female crash test dummy at all. Dr. Mark Pearlman at University of Michigan invented a pregnant crash test dummy like 30 years ago. There are plenty of female crash test dummies. Edit: according to congressional inquiry the NHTSA isn’t necessarily currently using “female” crash test dummies[0]. Still, they had been invented before. 0: https://norton.house.gov/media-center/press-releases/norton-lawrence-castor-delauro-and-schakowsky-receive-response-from https://norton.house.gov/media-center/press-releases/norton-...
- taeric 4y agoThis got me to do a quick search, which yields https://www.nhtsa.gov/nhtsas-crash-test-dummies https://www.nhtsa.gov/nhtsas-crash-test-dummies. I'm curious how they pick which dummies to use, as they have 5th percentile for women there. That said, it does seem to contradict the notion in the headline, at least. Edit: I think being fair to the concept of the article, the claim is the dummies in my link are just scaled down versions of each other?
- bckygldstn 4y agoHere's the NHSTA report for a 2015 Ford Focus, the female model is used in the passenger seat [1]. In a quick look I couldn't find any tests with female drivers though. The male [2] and female [3] dummies look to be in different proportions. [1]: https://nrd-static.nhtsa.dot.gov/reports/vehdb/v00000/v09000/v09086R001.pdf https://nrd-static.nhtsa.dot.gov/reports/vehdb/v00000/v09000... [2] https://www.humaneticsgroup.com/products/anthropomorphic-test-devices/frontal-impact/hybrid-iii-50th-male/hybrid-iii-50th-male https://www.humaneticsgroup.com/products/anthropomorphic-tes... [3] https://www.humaneticsgroup.com/products/anthropomorphic-test-devices/frontal-impact/hybrid-iii-5th-female https://www.humaneticsgroup.com/products/anthropomorphic-tes...
- flaviut 4y agoThe article specifically mentions the 5th percentile dummy you pointed out being inadequate: > The dummy that is sometimes used as a proxy for women is a scaled-down version of the male one, roughly the size of a 12-year-old girl. > At 149cm tall (4ft 8ins) and weighing 48kg (7st 5lb), it represents the smallest 5% of women by the standards of the mid-1970s. > However, a team of Swedish engineers has finally developed the first dummy, or to use the more technical term - seat evaluation tool - designed on the body of the average woman. > Their dummy is 162cm (5ft 3ins) tall and weighs 62kg (9st 7lbs), more representative of the female population.
- sdiacom 4y agoWell, if it has arrived, then clearly it isn't a great crash dummy. (I know this forum doesn't take kindly to jokes, but at least now there's one that isn't sexist)
- flumpcakes 4y agoThis is obviously a good thing - we should use crash dummies of all shapes and sizes, as people come in all shapes and sizes too. I wonder though if the statistics about male vs female injuries are down to personal choice of car rather than testing methodology. It would be good to see a break down of the statistics based on car model etc. For example, it is much more likely that a woman would own certain types of cars, at least in the EU. Some models are even referred to as "girly" in media. These typically are the more compact, city style cars like the Fiat 500. Likewise, it is much more likely for a man to be driving a larger white van, or any types of trades vehicle. This hasn't got much to do with the article itself, I just often see statistics used with very tenuous causal relationships. This does matter if the goal is to reduce the % of women's injuries as we need to change marketing and society as a whole, rather than just using a more feminine crash dummy.
- mberning 4y agoIt’s not practical. Crashing cars is expensive and you need consistent data. You cannot use a different dummy on each test and expect to make sense of the data. The best we could do is come up with an acceptable model and use that for all/most tests. If we could accurately model crashes in software then there would be no limitation on doing thousands of crashes with all different dummy types.
- faebi 4y agoI assume the numbers are even worse for very obese people and exceptionally tall people. Are obese dummies in use?
- bhelkey 4y agoThe tallest NHTSA crash dummy currently in service is 5'9" and 171 pounds [1]. [1] https://www.nhtsa.gov/nhtsas-crash-test-dummies https://www.nhtsa.gov/nhtsas-crash-test-dummies
- necovek 4y agoTall people (I am 195cm/6'5") generally require bigger cars to fit in (European D segment vehicles like BMW 3 series or Honda Accord are basically a small city car with barely usable rear seats when I am driving), and bigger cars have bigger mass. Hopefully electric cars with large cabins like IONIQ 5 are a start of fixing this :) Which is only to point out that types of vehicles would be correlated for people on extremes, and certainly a type of vehicle matters for crash survivability on average.
- dzink 4y agoA lot of injuries are happening from bottom belts cutting into bellies, because people don't know how to position the belt properly or the belt doesn't position well for people who have bellies (many women over middle age, pregnant women, etc). It's not just average height and weight that matters. Soft tissue positioning matters a lot. Women tend to accumulate weight in hips (pear shape), while men usually do it in the belly, so elevated thigh diameter in women when seated pushes the bottom belt up onto the belly/soft tissue which then gets cut during an accident. Regulators need to surface and approve belt adjusters that make seat-belts safer for pregnant and overweight people.
- xchip 4y agoI think people that don't look exactly like crash test dummies are more likely to get injuries
- dang 4y agoUrl changed from https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/the-first-female-crash-dummy-has-arrived-180981072/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/the-first-female-c..., which points to this.
- traceroute66 4y agoI have had the pleasure of meeting Dr Astrid Linder on a couple of occasions in the semi-distant past. Thoroughly impressive woman and this field of work (occupant diversity in crash testing) is very much her core area of expertise. Its been a while, but I believe the point here is that the American model is, as others have said, 30 years old. There are lots of problems with these 30 year old American models. Crash testing is one. Xray dosage another. Nuclear exposure another. The list goes on. So much of the world still refers back to these ancient models and people, mostly Europeans like Astrid Linder are working hard to modernise these. Astrid Linder's body of work that culminates in this present dummy takes into account real world data relating to size selection, anthropometry, modern knowledge of response corridors, more advanced assessment criteria, more suitable assessment thresholds, takes into account modern seat design. If you want to read more detail, you can start by looking up her work on the ADSEAT project (2009–2013) which incorporated work on EvaRID. For example, recording of presentation from 7 years ago: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AE51KAnukcg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AE51KAnukcg