12 ms·
Exploring Mastodon
- ZanyProgrammer 4y ago> but the protocol they use to communicate (ActivityPub) I stopped reading here. Most people who aren't tech savvy (much less professionally famous engineers) aren't going to want to learn this nonsense, much less see cased words like this that reek of geekdom. Everything about Mastodon (and the Fediverse) seems like it's catered to people who are already are (or who think they are) mentally all in on the concept. I dunno, maybe things will change given enough time, money and new users, but right now Mastodon seems like something that people just post to with very little comments and interaction.
- zzzeek 4y agoyou should log in and see all the very non-tech people who have joined
- andsoitis 4y agoI don’t know much about Mastodon, so wondering: can I see chatter without logging in? Where do I go to see it (discovery)?
- zzzeek 4y agome neither, only been on for a few days. here's the public stream from the server I'm on server https://fosstodon.org/public https://fosstodon.org/public the "main" mastodon.social server is mostly unreachable, that would be at: https://mastodon.social/public https://mastodon.social/public
- mroche 4y agoYou can visit any available instance and view their public feeds. For example, I use Fosstodon, so you visit the site[0] and click on "See what's happening" to preview the local feed, or navigate to the /public page. It's up to the instance to expose the "Explore", "Local", and "Federated" feeds. Fosstodon only exposes the local one to unauthenticated users. [0] https://fosstodon.org https://fosstodon.org
- pwinnski 4y agoI clicked your link and found a "Why is Fosstodon currently down?" page.
- zzzeek 4y agothis is a tech website so I'm sure you can appreciate the need for urgent migrations given the sudden changes in userbase
- pwinnski 4y agoAbsolutely. Been there, lived through that myself. I'm sure you can appreciate that every one of these issues impacts the uptake of mastodon, of course.
- zzzeek 4y agofosstodon is not the server that non-technical people would be going towards in any case and it also isn't accepting new registrations right now. the main server mastodon.social, that's the big one that's getting killed also. despite all this, a lot of prominent people have joined (to be clear, left leaning journalists, attorneys and economists, but Paul Krugman did win a nobel prize)
- lern_too_spel 4y agoThis sentence is just explaining how he thinks Mastodon usage will evolve, comparing it to federated email instances and the protocol they use to communicate (SMTP). Most people who use email don't know that, and most people who use Mastodon don't know its federation protocol either. Most people who read Fowler's blog or HN are able to understand the difference between what users need to know and how a system is implemented.
- pcl 4y agoWell, Martin Fowler is a tech guy who writes largely for an audience of tech people. It’s that surprising that tech jargon would find its way into his musings about a piece of tech he’s learning about. And certainly doesn’t have any bearing on Mastodon itself.
- SoftTalker 4y agoI have worked in tech for 30 years. I agree 100%. Any twitter alternative needs to be as easy and seamless as Twitter itself. The first step being a decision on where to set up an account is a non-starter for a huge number of people. Haven't we all learned the UX lesson of reducing choices?
- Barrin92 4y ago>The first step being a decision on where to set up an account is a non-starter for a huge number of people then the should just stay on twitter. The entire differentiator between Mastodon and Twitter is choice. It's akin to complaining about the fact that there's 50 states in the US and you have multiple elections to take part in and decide where you wanna live. It's all very complicated. Any technology that empowers people by definition makes it so they need to make their own choices. If these decentralized systems are to have any purpose it needs to stay that way. If that means you lose 90% of users, fine so be it honestly.
- ZanyProgrammer 4y ago> then the should just stay on twitter. The entire differentiator between Mastodon and Twitter is choice There's that OSS elitism we all know and love so much.
- Barrin92 4y agoit's literally the opposite of elitism. Demanding of people that they need to take control of the tools that they use and making tools that empower them recognizes that they are at least in principle able to do just that.What's really elitist is thinking that every piece of software needs to spoon-feed content to its users and eliminate all their choices because they're really too infantile to be bothered to make any decisions at all. Crazy world we're in where recognizing the potential for, and asking people to take control of their own actions is considered to be a symptom of elitism
- earth_walker 4y agoI don't find twitter to be seamless nor easy. They have reduced my choices to the point where I can't actually see what I want to see without doing a bunch of research into how to 'game' the system. Looking at my home page right now, Elon is at the top saying that "Twitter needs to become by far the most accurate source of information about the world. That’s our mission." Followed by an advert from a company I didn't subscribe to, and then a bunch of meaningless personal tweets from people I don't know and I didn't subscribe to. One news item on the whole page. I get regular email notifications updating me on the latest paranoid rants from various right wing 'rebel' groups (that I definitely didn't subscribe to), and I cannot find any way to stop them because they only show up in my emails, not in my feed. There's no way I can see to block them. That's not seamless nor easy. The email notifications I do want cut off important headlines half way through the sentence, forcing me to log into the platform just to read what might have happened. No way to configure that either. Certainly not seamless nor easy.
- chipotle_coyote 4y agoMost people who aren’t tech savvy aren’t reading Martin Fowler’s blog. It’s okay for bloggers to write for their expected audience, rather than having to think “how will what I am writing be interpreted by all possible readers, e.g., literally everyone who can access this web site.” As for Mastodon itself, yeah, it would be nice if it got better about its terminology and “marketing” to people who aren’t nerds, although one can argue this is endemic to open source culture at this point (cue unceasing arguments about Calibre’s wacky UI choices, The Gimp’s arguably offensive name, and so on). Those are trivially solvable problems, though. If Mastodon is “something that people just post to with very little comments and interaction,” I would suggest that it’s long been a network effect issue; it’s very hard to get any new system that depends on user-constructed social graphs off the ground, until or unless that graph exceeds some hard-to-define node count level for a sufficient number of users. Anecdotally, I have seen a lot more activity on Mastodon over the last week; whether enough will stick to push it over that magic number remains to be seen.
- ZanyProgrammer 4y agoSimilarly I saw a lot of activity there in the spring when Musk made his first attempt, and it didn't last.
- rakoo 4y agoThe author explains a bit of how things work, but no one ever said you need to read the full spec to use it. Just like it's better to know your car has an engine, but you don't need to know the details of how the engine works to drive your car. Sharing knowledge, and the reader can decide what level of detail they want to keep.
- kawfey 4y agoI've played around with mastodon for a few years; it never has had the the dopaminergic algorithm-fueled bite to keep me coming back like twitter does. But that's the good part, I guess. I think my #1 issue with it is it's fundamental feature - that spaces/servers/communities/domains (whatever the name is) are self-hosted by anyone. That means if they get disinterested, or the power goes out, or they get frustrated, the plug is pulled. They also set the rules, which are too often on two extremes - extremely nit-picky (like cursing or off-topic toots aren't allowed) or a free-for-all.
- senthil_rajasek 4y ago>That means if they get disinterested, or the power goes out, or they get frustrated, the plug is pulled. This is addressed in the fedi.tips FAQ, https://fedi.tips/how-to-use-mastodon-and-the-fediverse-basic-tips/#WhatIfAServerClosesDown https://fedi.tips/how-to-use-mastodon-and-the-fediverse-basi...
- delfinom 4y ago>However, all of the servers listed at JoinMastodon.org ⧉ are required to give at least three months notice if this happens. Ah yes, because that's totally going to be legally enforced or something.
- mxuribe 4y agoNo one should be forced to join any instance, so you are right to think of concerns...But, there are things that can be done to help keep an admin incentivized. For example, if the instance is expected to be run as a community projec,t then admins should committ in a manner that is accepted by the instance community (i guess not so different from open source projects)...Or, maybe have more than a single admin to fend off any single person losing interest...Or, you know, leverage the capitalist mechanism of paying some small fee to a group to help cover hosting, admin fees, etc. I'm sure there are other mechanisms that can be used...Anbd, there's of course the tools to move your stuyff to another instanace anyway...But, yeah, you shoiuld go into this stuff with eyes open - muich like other things on the internet. :-)
- riffic 4y agoThoughtworks runs their own instance. They adopted Mastodon a very long time ago. https://toot.thoughtworks.com/about https://toot.thoughtworks.com/about
- petepete 4y ago12,000 Thoughtworkers and only 78 active users on their instance though.
- thesuitonym 4y agoActive in this instance means online in the last month.
- nr2x 4y agoOk, so the DAU is likely worse.
- dewey 4y agoGetting a 502 Bad Gateway from that.
- riffic 4y agowell when you throw a ton of HN traffic at it it'll probably cook the underlying components.
- nr2x 4y agoThe fact that one has to pick from many different places to set up an account is a massive barrier to entry. Let alone the complexity of moving an account from one host to another is also woefully complex, so if you choose wrong, you’re in for more pain. I don’t see this platform being able to benefit from the Twitter exodus. I’m putting my hopes on blue sky/AT which appears to solve the above pain points: https://blueskyweb.org/ https://blueskyweb.org/
- KindAndFriendly 4y agoI politely disagree: you just pick an "entry node", similar to picking an ISP or an email provider. You can interact with everyone in the Fediverse just fine. Having a newsfeed for your chosen "entry node" is an additional nice-to-have imho but not the defining criteria.
- _ph_ 4y agoPicking an ISP should be transparent - my usage of internet services, like with whom I communicate - isn't influenced by it. I can change my ISP any time and no one will even notice, no one will have to be informed about a changed address. Picking an email provider is quite critical - if you change your email address, you can be only reached if everyone knows your new address, lets not even get started about where the email is used to identify you with other serviced. I think your choice of a a mastodon server falls in the middle ground between those examples, at minimum, there needs to be a bit more education of users to overcome (perceived?) hurdles there. I can confirm that while I noticed mastodon before, earlier attempts to use it stopped at the question on how to select the proper node and what consequences that has. That might be a perceived problem, but one that needs to be overcome if mastodon should be a popular Twitter alternative.
- stewbrew 4y agoNo, it's more like picking your community. Compare an account on mastodon.social vs an instance localated in your hometown to see the difference.
- 4y ago
- chris_st 4y agoI'm on a discord server with a lot of non-nerds, and various ones are interested in Mastodon, due to Twitter issues. It's amazing to see how much trouble they're having... "Do I have to create a log in on every Mastodon?" ("No, and it's pretty much impossible"), "Can I follow someone on another server?" ("Yes, but it's incredibly hard -- try to follow them on whatever server you're on, maybe someone else is following them already in which case you'll be able to, otherwise here are directions that sometimes work") kind of things. It's just not ready for prime-time, even (IMHO) among nerds, but wow, are normal folks having a hard time.
- vegai_ 4y agoHow is following someone on another server with Mastodon difficult? Or is that some sort of a meme now?
- roywiggins 4y agoIt's confusing if someone posts a Mastodon handle on eg Twitter. If it's a link to their profile, you can't follow them on that page. You have to go to your own instance and paste their handle into the search box and follow them that way.
- dredmorbius 4y agoThat is a legit UX annoyance, yes. Similarly, local-to-your-instance links to a specific toot, vs. globally-accessible / canonical toot URLs. Both can be resolved through the Search dialogue on Mastodon, but it took me a while to work that out myself.
- roywiggins 4y agoOh, and I should add, it doesn't work if you ended up on an instance that doesn't federate with the one that your followee is on. And the UI for that is "it just doesn't show up in search."
- taylodl 4y agoI stopped using Twitter years ago - the signal to noise ratio is quite low and you have to spend a lot of time curating to even achieve that! Honestly, HN satisfies my needs for geek news and Reddit has me covered for my hobbies. I really don't see a need for these kinds of social networks any longer. At least not for me.
- T3RMINATED 4y ago
- shrikant 4y agoI'm quite a bit unimpressed by (actual and armchair) UX and product experts' commentary jumping on Mastodon's rough edges -- yes, a lot of us know it's a bit clunky and the onboarding hasn't been A/B tested to death, and the UI/UX hasn't been hyper-optimised for LE EPIC ENGAGEMENT and that's perfectly fine! It's arguably not ready for full mainstream adoption right now, but hopefully that'll continue to change as the tech crowd uptake increases and the contributions to the core/protocol/apps goes up as well. I like the community feel of the somewhat smaller instance that I moved my presenec over to (from mastodon.technology, which is shutting down), and there's a frisson of the original excitement I felt when exploring early communications services on the interwebs like IRC.
- notacoward 4y agoI'm a lot less concerned about UX/onboarding issues than about the fact that the simplistic federation model is going to fall apart long before they even reach 1/10 of Twitter's scale. Now, if you're OK with having a lot of smaller communities that only communicate sporadically, forcing people to have ten identities and ten tabs open to participate effectively in each one, that's not a problem. However, if you want to have a single identity fully participating in multiple communities, then the federation model needs to improve a lot. The current ad hoc relays are just the first step on a long road toward a network/proxy/cache layer that can reduce the unnecessary latency and load on the servers themselves, to provide a federated experience beyond the old FIDOnet level. There are lessons to be learned from IRC, Usenet, and P2P file sharing that can help with this.
- parasubvert 4y agoThe web itself has a proxy/cache layer, what more is needed? I don’t think it’s inherently unavailable as it is, no more than RSS readers were.
- notacoward 4y agoHTTP caching doesn't work as well as it could for ActivityPub data patterns as it does for popular single sites, and AFAICT the servers don't do the things necessary to make it even as effective as it could be. There's a reason big Mastodon instances need to devote so many resources to Sidekiq.
- bombcar 4y agoI saw a good quote - something along the lines that Mastodon replacing Twitter has serious "year of linux on the desktop vibes". I think there's value in Mastodon, but it's not a drop-in twitter replacement. Perhaps a valuable thing would be helping set it up as a POSSE tool: https://indieweb.org/POSSE https://indieweb.org/POSSE - post to your Mastodon and it automatically posts to Twitter for you.
- bioemerl 4y agoI bricked my Linux system while trying to uninstall python, on one of the most "user friendly" systems, and they had no way to restore like Windows does with system restore. I'm still using it because Windows requires accounts now and screw that, but man, Linux has tried hard to get me to go do something else. I do not understand how these projects are just so consistently bad at UX. It takes effort, but UX should be priority number one, even over new functionality.
- cmh89 4y agoI've always found modern Linux systems to have a great UX. I'm mildly tech orientated but not super into customization or anything, and never had any problems after Ubuntu got the application center done. Of course trying to install drivers for a 56k modem while not having internet access was a different experience 25 years ago.
- bombcar 4y agoLinuxes are getting good at "the normal path, plus a bit" - Ubuntu is quite usable for basic things these days. Where they fall off the rails is when you try to do something you're "not supposed to do" (like removing python) - then you're often better off with the weird distros like Gentoo or Mint; at least someone likely broke it the same way before.
- valeness 4y agoThis is solved on windows by simply not allowing you to install python because an automated first party windows update already bricked your system...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tr3ntg 4y agoI too decided to try Mastodon recently. But I didn't try it out because of Twitter's recent news, I tried it out because I haven't enjoyed Twitter for a long while. Mastodon is providing for many people what they haven't seen in Twitter for quite some time. A social site that seems to have a soul. Also, many of the people I've found on Mastodon still use Twitter. The two serve different purposes. Just like you don't talk about "Instagram OR Twitter," it's not about "Twitter OR Mastodon." We have choices now. And Mastodon is more on the radar now than ever. Happy that new people are hearing about it and finding value there.
- radarsat1 4y agoThe thing that surprised me a bit about federation is that it puts instances front and center. You have an account at your "home instance", and that's the first thing you see. When I first read about federation I had thought that the idea was to have one big network of independent but equal instances that just transparently share data under common topics. But instead I discovered that you are identified with your instance and can follow topics per instance, with local topics being the default, and you have to explicitly reach out to see the "rest of the world". With Lemmy communities too. It seems that you can subscribe to a community on a given instance, but there is no such thing as cross-instance communities. I found this disappointing because it means that for there to be a critical mass of content in a particular community so that it gains in popularity, then that particular community in that particular instance has to become popular on its own, instead of all instances contributing to one big community. Add to this that the default view is "local communities" and you've guaranteed you'll never build something as popular as reddit, sadly. Example, someone from mylemmy.eg cannot post together with someone from hislemmy.com in one big Programming forum. Instead they both have to agree to post in Programming@commonlemmy.net and not Programming@worselemmy.org which, imho, is unlikely to be a successful as there being one centralized place where everyone knows to post. If they'd just remove the domain names and pool everything I think it would have a lot more chance of success.
- moelf 4y agobecause that's way too expensive? if you follow every Programming@ on every public instance and nobody is doing the centralized data distribution, you have a all-to-all situation?
- jmathai 4y agoI think the opportunity is to foster a new kind of social interaction and smaller niche groups seems like a really interesting angle that centralized services gravitate away from. I haven't used Mastadon but I could see this being a positive if you replace "home instance" with "local community" or "interest group foo". The truth is that you only need to find a small group of people with similar interests. You don't need access to the entire world.
- unpopularopp 4y agoI don't know why the server choice is so downplayed when instances can block each other and if you end up on a "wrong one" (the peer pressure to avoid guilt by association is really really strong if you look around) then you have to move around, your name changes etc. Feels like the single user self-hosting is the only way to go but I'm not sure most people would do that (let alone realize how the whole system works) And personally whole thing feels like a weird combination of reddit and Discord where you choose your sub/server then Twitter tbh
- chatterhead 4y agoMastodon is a Confediverse. After looking at what Jack built; it seems he's actually created a Fediverse.
- halfbrite 4y agoWhat I'm looking for is effectively a fidonet style federation. I understand Lemmy is bordering on that, but it's not quite there from my observation, and I'm yet to see a suitable implementation that would entice an old fart like me.
- yborg 4y agoThere is nothing to prevent a set of instances from agreeing on a common set of operating rules or even common high-level management a la Fidonet or the way IRC networks are managed. If the Fediverse continues to grow, I would expect that something like that would naturally evolve.
- halfbrite 4y agoThere's some subtle technical differences that would need to be overcome, and I cannot see the existing encumbents agreeing to those differences. First, take private messaging - on Mastodon, if @alice and @dave talk about @mallory, @mallory will be pulled into the conversation. With Fidonet, in it's simplest terms, private messaging was private. Second, if there is a forum / discussion board for / called Java on ProgrammerWoes.fiction and a forum / discussion board for / called Java on ProgrammerSuccess.fiction then with the existing solutions a person comes along and they are unsure which is better, and one eventually dies, or a third springs up, etc. With Fidonet, there was one forum per topic - the contents of which was federated, so you didn't end up with two Java forums. Yes, we have hundreds of programming forums - but there's a reason people flock to Twitter or more specifically Reddit to discuss a topic that goes beyond simply signal to noise - it's that they aren't flooded with a confusing choice.
- parasubvert 4y agoThis feels like a return to BBS culture and FIDOnet. Which was good mix of local and federated discussion. I don’t think it is as much of a barrier to entry as people expect.
- insane_dreamer 4y ago> The most important arbiter of content moderation is the reader. My decisions on who I follow should indicate what content I want to see. That control is undermined by commercial services that maximize engagement to sell attention to advertisers. This is why ad-based social networks are inherently problematic unless/until they switch to an ad-free model, which means paywalled, but I would pay $2/month for a Twitter-like service that wasn't ad-based.
- pwinnski 4y agoI am not sure I can express this enough: the onboarding experience is overwhelmingly confusing. I've already ended up dumped on a page with a long list of servers, and it's not clear whether this choice matters or not. Half the comments here say it does, half say it doesn't! But let's see my choices today: ruby.social, todon.eu, hostux.social, Glasgow.social, metalhead.net, socel.net, machteburch.social, activism.openworlds.info, eldritch.cafe, toot.wales, tooting.ch, sfba.social, indieweb.social, tech.lgbt, lor.sh "Yet another server," tilde.zone, ieji.de, is.nota.live, libretooth.gr, mastodonapp.uk, ravenation.club, climatejustice.social, noc.social, maly.io, mastodon.nz, qoto.org, mastodon.ie, and I'm tired of pasting, but literally NONE OF THE ABOVE seem to be for me! And again, I don't know how much this matters, but it feels overwhelming. Also, a startlingly high percentage of socialist and otherwise left-leaning servers in that initial list, which might be intended, or might just be coincidentally arrayed to drive away people who are offended by such things. The worst part about this is, I'm pretty sure I signed up with mastodon back when it was first launched, but I can't remember the server, so...
- metacritic12 4y agoI'm reminded of something that Yishan said, which is that the #1 problem with social networks isn't free speech. Rather it's spam, which passes every "free speech" test to be undangerous yet unpleasant. Good luck with that Mastodon. I too would like a Twitter+, but in aiming for the + you're actually losing a ton of base features that users in fact care about, like antispam and "one big universe" with good signal to noise.
- aorth 4y agoRegarding profile verification, Mastadon suggests doing it by putting an anchor tag with a link to your profile on a website. In this article the author suggests you can do it with a `<link>` tag instead. I prefer the link tag to an anchor tag so I'm going to try that right now...
- rickette 4y agoCan't think of a name worse than "mastodon" for a consumer app. A name like that won't help.
- notacoward 4y agoI don't see anything wrong with "mastodon" but "toot" bothers me even more than "tweet" did.
- jrnichols 4y agoI've had an account on 2 instances (was 3, but 1 vanished) for a couple years now and the biggest thing that I personally run into as a roadblock - ages. Fediverse users are way younger than me. I'm in my late 40s and grew up with usenet/etc, so the tech hurdle wasn't that steep but finding people that I connect with at all has just not happened. I follow a few folks here and there but that's really about it. It's amazing how the little silos of content can be so isolating.
- cratermoon 4y agoHonestly, I feel like Mastodon just reinvented FidoNet, but over TCP/IP.
- adultSwim 4y agoAre there any servers with transparent open governance? Debian provides a great example