5 ms·
> With the destruction of the Nordstream pipelines ... that mostly leaves > the USA as the primary supplier. Does that suggest motive for the destruction? Wh
by dotancohen 4y ago
> With the destruction of the Nordstream pipelines ... that mostly leaves
> the USA as the primary supplier.
Does that suggest motive for the destruction? Who else has both motive and means?
- pavlov 4y agoSelling more gas to Europe isn’t a massive windfall to USA. The Biden administration has bigger fish to fry and wouldn’t risk such an intervention in Swedish waters just as Sweden is joining NATO. My money is on Russian hardliner factions operating rogue without Putin’s approval. He can’t admit he doesn’t know who did it. The Russian state security apparatus is so large, we have no idea what kind of internal tensions exist. Putin may have unleashed something he doesn’t control anymore.
- aa-jv 4y ago>The Biden administration has bigger fish to fry and wouldn’t risk such an intervention in Swedish waters just as Sweden is joining NATO. This is a pretty naive perspective - Since when has Sweden ever stood up to the crimes and misdeeds of the USA? Sweden ranks up there with Australia in the "lackey-state underdog to the USA" rankings ..
- pavlov 4y agoIt's just not worth the Americans' time to be plotting such a thing now. Selling more natural gas is irrelevant to the Biden administration's survival. And there were general elections in both Sweden and Denmark within the past two months — terrible timing for such an offensive CIA operation in NATO waters because any information leak would have handed a potent electoral weapon to anti-American opposition parties. The Russians are already a very active presence in the Baltic Sea, and this attack fits with their general pattern of confusion and misdirection.
- aa-jv 4y agoThere is no evidence that the Russians were anywhere near the pipeline around the time it was destroyed. There is massive evidence that the US and its allies were operating in those waters, and up to something, leading up to the day of the attack. The idea that the US wouldn't jeapordize its relationship with the Baltic states in order to cut off a vital supply of economic resources to Europe is very, very naive. The US has done far worse to its so-called allies.
- actionfromafar 4y agoMy money is on Putin doing it, to dissuade any would be throne-pretenders in case of a coup. Any new government has fewer funding options, which would be good to negotiate with Europe, and to pay cooperating oligarchs. It would be cutting the nose to spite the face, except Putin is cutting Russia's nose, not his own. What matters is staying in power, not the good of the nation.
- MomoXenosaga 4y agoI agree. Scorched earth policy. Putin for whatever reason is going all in on Ukraine. Even if the war ended tomorrow it would take Russia decades to rebuild it's army.
- actionfromafar 4y agoTo rebuild to its previous apparent capability or to its actual capabilities? If Russia is given the means, it may take only a few years to rebuild to its actual capabilities of 2021. Which is bad enough to cause trouble.
- photochemsyn 4y agoThe means is an interesting question. Having done a little scuba diving, the depth of the pipelines (70-90 meters) put it out of range of any diver without a sophisticated mix of gases (Trimix diving). A remotely operated vehicle would also work. The pipelines were made of thick steel wrapped with concrete, so some kind of high-tech explosive was necessary, perhaps shaped charges (used in the oil industry for blowing holes in pipe casing to increase oil flow, for example). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Submarine_pipeline https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Submarine_pipeline https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trimix_(breathing_gas) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trimix_(breathing_gas) See the EPA for details. I guess it's okay to link to this, it's an official US government site. https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/documents/casingperforatedoverview.pdf https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/documents/casingperf... Perhaps locating both of the pipelines deep under the water would be difficult? Point being, the ability to do this might not be as exclusive to nation-states as it has been portrayed (note the ease with which the videographer found the pipelines with an ROV, although the big bubbles probably helped). So, who knows? As far as who benefited, well, Russia certainly seems to want to continue selling gas to Europe, and is pushing for repair of the pipelines. The USA wants to replace Russian gas with American LNG. Coming up with a reason for Russia to do it would require some mental gymnastics, I think. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2022/10/12/putin-offers-to-boost-gas-supplies-to-europe-via-nord-stream-2 https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2022/10/12/putin-offers-to-bo...
- ericmay 4y agoNot really. If Russia wanted to continue to sell gas to Europe it could end the war against Ukraine (or have never started it in the first place). Gas sales aren’t a high priority there. Putin doesn’t care one bit about those, and likely had the pipeline blown up as a “no way back” for those who might have wanted to negotiate behind his back. The US blowing up NS2 for a few billion dollars worth of gas sales is beyond stupid because it risks completely ruining all of the momentum the US has in isolating Russia and having its military completely implode. If your view is that the Russians are the enemy (as the US view is) why would you stop them from making a terrible mistake or put any of that at risk? You wouldn’t.
- 4y ago