3 ms·
We use Asana. I prefer it over other things I've used such as Pivotal Tracker and Jira. From my experience, Jira is geared at large silo-ed companies, where yo
by malandrew 15y ago
We use Asana. I prefer it over other things I've used such as Pivotal Tracker and Jira.
From my experience, Jira is geared at large silo-ed companies, where you need to spend time defining processes. It's very inorganic.
I liked Pivotal Tracker, but the whole agile thing proved to be a bit too inflexible at the startup I founded with some friends. It did work well at a larger startup of about 30-40 people, where a bit of process rigidity was kind of useful. It would be interesting if I had Asana available to have tried at that company.
Jira was used at the first tech company I worked at. Waaaaay too process focused. Detracted from those who actually do work. That being said, I can see how it would be an asset at a large company with A people to C people and high turnover.
These days I'm mulling a "pull request" based approach for certain types of programming tasks and everything else in Asana.
- dlf 15y agoHow do you find Asana fits in with the other tools you use in your development process?
- malandrew 15y agoThe only thing I miss is integration into something like Campfire. I would like to see integration with Github pull requests. I think that Github is far better environment to discuss development issues, because comments/discussions are inlined with the code and Github Flavored Markdown makes communicating easier.
- petervandijck 15y agoWe used Jira in an agile environment and it worked fine? You're not obliged to use every dropdown they give you :)
- X4 15y agoWe used ASANA for several months and it turned out that it god better by the time, it's still not efficient collaboration and the emails send out, kill a lot of useful time. -1 for ASANA from an early adopter.
- malandrew 15y agoYou can turn off the emails if they don't work for you. I find that the emails make sure stuff gets checked and handled in a timely manner. Most other tools require self-discipline from the rest of the team. They need to check whatever tool to keep on top of things. Most tools that don't have a "pull" approach have a higher chance of failing to be adopted.