3 ms·
I do know how legal discovery generally works, there just wasn't much point getting into specifics when it doesn't change my point. Fundamentally, the court is
by mindslight 15y ago
I do know how legal discovery generally works, there just wasn't much point getting into specifics when it doesn't change my point. Fundamentally, the court is what has the power to make requests, even though those requests originate from opposing counsel.
> What do you think insurance actuaries do all day, other than study insurable risk?
This is precisely what I meant by 'much effort'.
Let's make this concrete: If you frequented a lot of bars as a designated driver and the insurance companies gained access to your location data, what do you think would happen to your rates? How do you think this change compares to the change that would occur if they could somehow perfectly predict your expected payout?
And actually, yes, I am paranoid and proud of it. The corner cases of systems are the important ones; expected behavior is dead easy.
- anigbrowl 15y agoIf you frequented a lot of bars as a designated driver and the insurance companies gained access to your location data, what do you think would happen to your rates? Nothing, because my location data doesn't tell you whether I'm a driver or a passenger. Even if the insurance companies do have that information, your example depends on their being oblivious to the existence of designated drivers. I might, for example, be operating a taxi or limousine service, where my job is to drive drunken people around while they have a good time. I'm all about corner cases, but it does not follow that paranoia is the sensible position to take. I can just as easily suggest corner cases where insurance companies decide to skip the analysis, increase premiums on everyone evenly, and blame inflation, because it considerably lowers their overhead and the administrative savings offset a good deal of the increased payouts, so that the premiums don't rise too much. Unsustainable over any period but the very short term, of course, but many would argue that something very similar happened at AIG in the runup to the financial crisis. Not performing proper diligence on the financial instruments whose risk they were insuring against (via credit default swaps) looked like financial genius until the claims suddenly exceeded the value of the premiums. That's why it's cheaper to pay actuaries than to place your faith in people's common sense. There are different interests to be balanced here, but it seems to me you are complaining about the existence of the scales (ie the court).
- mindslight 15y agoThe location data of the insured vehicle certainly indicates the context that it operates in. The commercial vehicles you cite have different insurance policies. And letting your friend drive your car home from the bar is presumably an even higher risk behavior! If you honestly think that an insurance company wouldn't raise the rates for something that correlates so strongly with drunk driving, you're really going to need some solid justification. And as to the scales, one must recognize that they're imperfect. One is in a much worse position with a log of habitual speeding - having to then prove (from a presumption of guilt) that their speed was indeed prudent.
- anigbrowl 15y agoNow you're just using a 'no true scotsman' fallacy to exclude cases that don't fit your argument.