14 ms·
Mild autumn weather has sent European gas prices plummeting
- 10u152 4y agoThe pictorial had me for a minute. Deeper red means closer to full which is a positive thing.
- bearmode 4y agoCould also be a bad thing; if a country's storage capacity is woeful (like the UK), it indicates we could be storing more.
- Moissanite 4y ago20/20 hindsight. In a less miserable timeline, the absence of hostilities with Russia makes gas storage a non-issue, and any government putting money into gas tanks rather than renewable energy would have been (rightly) lambasted. I'm willing to tear chunks out of our inept leaders over many things, but this isn't one of them.
- parkingrift 4y agoMy friend… Russia invaded Ukraine in 2014. Two different US presidents warned Europe about Russian energy dependency, publicly. Who knows how many times this was brought up in private conversations. This was so easy to predict that even Donald Trump managed to put two and two together and make four. He brought it up, publicly, and German leaders literally laughed at his face. European politicians deserve no benefit of the doubt here after 2014. They were told this was a huge risk and chose to do nothing.
- Moissanite 4y agoMeh; I take your point, but in 2017 there was definitely more emphasis on risks from climate than from Russia. Not saying that was a valid position, just that it isn't too surprising that politicians don't eagerly swim against the tide being set by the media and general public. The root of the problem is that those journalists and voters aren't capable of holding enough complexity in their minds to acknowledge both risks at the same time.
- hackandthink 4y agoGermany lost momentum in transitioning to renewable energy when Merkel/CDU gained power in 2005. Cheap gas was nice for people and politicians back then, in 2014 and would be nice now. I do/did not support joining the war against Russia but reducing fossil fuel usage is the right thing anyway.
- benj111 4y agoThe UK had relatively little dependence on russian gas though. So you'd have to basically predict what did happen. Russia turning off the taps to the whole of Europe / Europe refusing to buy, and Europe scrambling to find alternative sources. I don't think any of that was reasonably foreseeable.
- oezi 4y agoGermany gets a lot of flak for buying Russian gas cheaply the last 30 years in ever increasing volumes. But it seems strange to argue that Germany just should have bought gas from Qatar or the US for double the price from the start. How should Germany have done that? Import tax on Russian gas? Laws preventing importing cheap gas from the east? Sounds a bit aggressive towards our big neighbor to the east. Germans maybe were naive to think (up to until this summer) that Russia would need the money as much as we needed the gas. Still from the grand scheme of things (fossil fuels need to end anyway, gas is better than coal for climate, trade is better than no trade) the idea to partner with Russia made a lot of sense. Europe benefitted from cheap gas over the last decades and it will be somewhat affected by higher prices for this and next year, but it will accelerate the transition to renewables and strengthen nuclear in those countries in Europe where it is still an option. In the end it will push Europe in the right direction.
- parkingrift 4y ago>But it seems strange to argue that Germany just should have bought gas from Qatar or the US for double the price from the start. That was never on the table. The US doesn’t even have the export capacity to manage it. Germany should have pursued energy independence for the the European Union. It’s as simple as that.
- oezi 4y agoWhenever the Germany was critiqued on its Russian gas dependence by the US it was always brought up that Germany could rely more on US gas (from fracking if I recall). > Germany should have pursued energy independence for the European Union. It’s as simple as that. Nothing simple about that. Germany financed the first solar boom under the Green party before 2005 which cost German consumers a pretty penny (EEG Umlage). When Merkel got into power this renewables surcharge got so high that it was threatening consumers and industry. Merkel put on the brakes for renewables (which cost Germany pretty much all solar industry) and ushered in the Gas dependence. Only with expensive fossils do renewables have a chance in Europe. So the current prices do have at least one advantage and might eventually lead to the energy independence.
- bearmode 4y agoNot hindsight, reducing our storage capacity is something that was decried as it was happening. Anyone with sense saw this problem coming (not specifically a Russian war, just potential problems from a lack of gas storage). I personally have been complaining about it for years.
- thefz 4y agoOn the other hand, if we could stop considering only the economic aspect of everything and see that the downside of this is that we are destroying our water reserves that took thousands of years to accumulate...
- Roark66 4y agoWell, the economic aspect of things is essential just as physical constrains. You can't wish away certain things like availability of other resources, or people behaving responsibly with no economic incentive. Talking about water reserves. I actually have my own well that I went through the approval and build process about a decade ago(in EU). I had to declare "maximum consumption per day". So my point is, there is some (at least theoretical) conservation of groundwater resources. However there is no real way to check factual use for which I don't think there is an acceptable solution.
- thefz 4y agoWells and groundwater pretty much work only for those living atop the water table. In the Alps we rely on water stored under the form of glaciers for drinking, sanitary and energy generation. The latest megasummer with the freezing point well above 5000mt decimated our storage which took thousands of years to accumulate.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sph 4y agoThe economic aspect is the social aspect. It does not have to be black and white, with or against us. People have not frozen to death because of a cold autumn and prices to the roof. Can we talk about that or shall we resort to fatalism?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dtech 4y agoCan you expand on this or provide sources? At least in my countries the gas storage is now-empty gas fields that used to contain natural gas anyway, I have a hard time seeing how that could contaminate water sources.
- discordance 4y agohttps://archive.ph/w5YqE https://archive.ph/w5YqE
- politelemon 4y ago> enjoyed the warmest October I abhor this kind of language that news sites use. It takes away from the seriousness of the underlying cause (and its effects), and associates hot/warm weather with "good". Public apathy towards climate change starts here.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hutzlibu 4y agoI did enjoy the warm and sunny october. Would anything have been any better, if I felt miserable about things, I cannot really change?
- throw827474737 4y agoThat's true.. but on the other hand: I'm fully aware of the climate crisis .. still the weather for the individual here was pure enjoyment.. it is not so much of a news language thing here, but even climate activists enjoyed the weather?
- dan-robertson 4y agoI don’t enjoy warm autumn weather because The Economist tells me to. I don’t think avoiding talking about the weather like a human is necessary or helpful for dealing with climate change. But perhaps part of this is that I generally don’t believe that fixing climate change has much to do with terrifying the public about it. Furthermore, it’s generally untrue that any particular warm October is due to climate change but rather the average October temperature over many years.
- VBprogrammer 4y agoYes, it feels like cherry picking when people say something like "climate change makes severe weather events more likely" in connection with a drought or unusually hot spell but ridicule anyone who tries to use a particularly cold winter as evidence that climate change is not happening. We should avoid the association between climate and short term weather phenomenon altogether. And yes, the COVID lockdowns showed the limits of individual action on climate change. Even if people can't leave their house (except for some limited purposes) the reduction in carbon emissions are relatively small. It's a problem for government and industry to solve in the main. The only difficulty is how to ensure that we elect governments who take it seriously without scaring some people?
- uri4 4y agoLets hope climate warming will kick in this winter. Or 30 million refugees from Ukraine will flood Europe...
- bertil 4y agoThere might be as many people from Pakistan, East Africa, or China who have to migrate because of global warming this winter too. Not sure whether they’ll go to Europe, but millions isn’t an exaggeration in those cases.
- uri4 4y ago
- cromka 4y agoChina is too big of a territory; if the Chinese needed to migrate because of global warming, they'd likely move within their own land. Probably the same case with Pakistan.
- throwaway2203 4y agoPakistan is already exploding at the seams due to population growth. It's not just a matter of moving, the country doesn't have enough resources to feed and clothe its population. The growth rate isn't abating and global warming is eating into water resources and desertifying land / reducing the arable area.
- eunos 4y ago>China D Folks from Dongbei moved to South even as far as Sanya because of the warm among other reasons. Warmer Dongbei might attract more people back.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- DocTomoe 4y agoUnfortunately, that does not translate to lower customer-end prices.
- schlepper 4y agoWhich makes sense given that gas storages have been filled almost to full capacity over the past weeks/months for prices much higher than they are now.
- DocTomoe 4y agoWhich would be a good argument if back in the day, when gas storages were filled cheaply in summer, that price would be given over to end customers in winter as well. But of course, that was not the way things went.
- hef19898 4y agoSimple reason for that: gas storage facilities are nearly full all over Europe, and because of the warm weather and general frugality they aren't emptied. If you can burn gas right now, and you can use enough of it to to be able to buy on the spot market, you could have a field day. Could, because even if all the above applies, there might be long-term hedging contracts in place that have been signed already limiting your flexibility.
- jonatron 4y agoI'm on a time of use electricity tariff, and last night it was around £0.02/kWh between 3AM-5AM. The standard price cap rate is £0.34/kWh
- pencilguin 4y ago
- brnt 4y agoPlaying panic football is a bad idea, either way. Diversification is a great insurance regardless of circumstances. Climate change predicts not just warmer winter, but also more variation on the mean, so for next winter, it'd still be great if those reactors are still operating (looks like they won't, but I hope 2023 will give rise to another Wende: towards more European energy independence).
- ema 4y agoWhether or not Germany's nuclear energy policies are sensible or not surely has nothing to do with how the weather turns out this year. Maybe one can take global warming into account for future energy needs but 2 degrees Celsius more on average won't change the fact that Germany occasionally has harsh winters and needs the infrastructure to cope with that.
- simion314 4y agoI would wait to gloat until winter is over, there is no rulle that if autumn is worm then the winter is the same, we could be hit with a super cold period of winter, add on top some sabotages from the Ruzzians and a lot of suffering might happen. I hope our countries are increasing the security checks on critical infrastructure.
- pencilguin 4y agoIt is anyway clear that, whatever the weather, Germany will not in fact freeze in the dark.
- simion314 4y agoI hope so, but is this true in the worst scenario too ? I read the news that reserves are full in EU but I did not seen anyone calculating how much would does work if there will be an exceptional cold winter. I know that Romania would have enough for a normal winter and probably enough for Moldova too, but with climate change we could get some very cold weeks ,so I prefer not to gloat until the winter is gone and we all figureout how to survive the next winter.
- pydry 4y agoMild autumn weather [ and not enough storage capacity to take advantage ] has sent European gas prices plummeting. 90% full in the UK means about a week's worth of gas. In Germany it's about 2.5 months.
- hef19898 4y agoShort term not to bad for the UK, you can now sign contracts for delivery in one to two weeks at significantly lower prices.
- rowanajmarshall 4y agoAlthough the UK has an appreciable percentage of Europe's LNG re-gasification capacity, while Germany has none, and imports LNG via Belgium and the Netherlands instead. The UK has storage, it's just sitting in ships off the coast.
- blibble 4y agoand a large chunk of UK supply is still domestically produced from the North Sea
- 7952 4y agoAnd the UK has relatively more secure sources in Norway and the North Sea.
- empedocles 4y agoNot sure I would bet on the pipeline from Norway remaining secure. They have increased their level of military alert for a reason.
- teknofobi 4y agoAn attack there is quite high risk, you would have to thread the hybrid warfare needle well to not trigger NATO Article 5.
- 4y ago
- rasz 4y agoJoke being Russian flagrant disregard for climate change contributed to warmer winter.
- Tade0 4y agoTo be completely fair they were mostly just the drug dealers, not the drug addicts. That being said my Russian friend who moved to the EU a few years ago was shocked with the prices of fuels around here and promptly sold her 20yo Camry, which was quite the gas guzzler by EU standards. Fuel is cheap in Russia and for Moscovites like her doubly so.
- alwayslikethis 4y agoOn another note, Russia is also among the least negatively affected countries by climate change. With the weather warming up, they may gain new arable land and even a few ports in the Arctic and Pacific.
- birracerveza 4y agoI'm surprised I haven't come across conspiracy theories that use this as confirmation that "they" control the weather...
- bheadmaster 4y agoI'll admit it has passed my mind several times. I never said it out loud (until now), but the coincidence that the very year EU loses its main gas supply we get sunny winter without snow at all... I know it's probably a coincidence, but my mind doesn't like coincidences. There's always this "what if" voice inside my head.
- robbiep 4y agoThe mind boggles
- theCrowing 4y agoI admit it I am working at a secret European agency with the purpose of climate control. We can only make it warmer right now but there is a commit open that could fix our issues with the overheating. They fired the guy who wrote it for cost saving measures, his LOC over year was a bit low but I bet the junior refactoring some legacy code can do it. His LOCs are of the fucking chart. /s
- birracerveza 4y agoIt's actually the opposite, you have a pattern-seeking brain that likes coincidences. It's why we notice patterns, because some are not coincidences but outright consequences, however indirect they may be! But there's a lot of coincidences in the world, some being so unlikely and so unfortunate, our mind can refuse to accept that, well.. it can be just a coincidence. The longest-reigning UK monarch dies at the start of the shortest term PM's tenure ... it's incredibly unlikely, yet it happened. Should there be an explanation behind it? Or maybe it's just a coincidence? You decide.
- bheadmaster 4y agoFrom a deeply cynical perspective, everything in the world is a coincidence, it's just that some coincidences happen so often that betting on them becomes useful, so we give them a name: "cause-effect relationship".
- paganel 4y agoLooking at this chart [1] they're still 6 or 7 times more expensive compared to two years ago and further back, i.e. ~15 EUR/Mwh compared to the present ~100 EUR/Mwh. No energy-intensive industry can sustain a 6 or 7 times price increase of its core input. [1] https://tradingeconomics.com/commodity/eu-natural-gas https://tradingeconomics.com/commodity/eu-natural-gas
- dotancohen 4y agoThat's going to shut down a lot of aluminium in countries that use petrochemicals to process it. Iceland is going to see its industry boom, as they use geothermal to process aluminium. I'd once heard the argument that Iceland exports energy in the form of aluminium billets. That's becoming more and more apparent now.
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoIt already has, multiple aluminium smelters have suspended operations for the winter. Other companies affected are e.g. bakeries and a food cannery, which will affect prices of basic foodstuffs - which are already up due to various factors, including the Russian invasion. Bird flu is also a thing, causing chicken and egg prices to soar.
- euroderf 4y ago"Welcome to Bauxite Island"
- badpun 4y agoThese are the month-ahead contracts prices. The day ahead are at around 10% of that (the gas is almost free, compared to what it costed just couple months ago). It's probably just temporary curiosity though.
- photochemsyn 4y agoOne major theme in the ongoing US-Russia conflict over the past decade-plus (dating back to at least 2008) is a fight over who gets to sell oil and gas to Europe. With the destruction of the Nordstream pipelines, and with countries like Qatar refusing to alter long-term energy contracts to increase supplies to Europe, and with Iran still under the Trump-era sanctions (which Biden continued), that mostly leaves the USA as the primary supplier. See this from past summer: https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/us-lng-exports-europe-track-surpass-biden-promise-2022-07-26/ https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/us-lng-exports-europ... > "...the United States has already sent more gas to Europe during the first six months of 2022 than it did in all 12 months of 2021. If exports to Europe continue at the same pace through the second half of 2022, the total increase over 2021 would be around 45 bcm [billion cubic meters]." > "Benchmark gas prices in Europe have averaged $34.06 per million British thermal units (mmBtu) so far in 2022 compared with $29.99 in Asia and $6.12 in the United States. That compares with average 2021 prices of $16.04 in Europe, $18.00 in Asia and $3.73 in the United States, data showed." This also results in U.S. electricity ratepayers having much larger bills, driving across-the-board inflation - but fossil fuel shareholders and executives are certainly raking in the profits. Mission accomplished? https://energynews.us/2022/10/12/natural-gas-prices-are-rising-thats-worse-news-for-ratepayers-than-utilities/ https://energynews.us/2022/10/12/natural-gas-prices-are-risi...
- dotancohen 4y ago> With the destruction of the Nordstream pipelines ... that mostly leaves > the USA as the primary supplier. Does that suggest motive for the destruction? Who else has both motive and means?
- pavlov 4y agoSelling more gas to Europe isn’t a massive windfall to USA. The Biden administration has bigger fish to fry and wouldn’t risk such an intervention in Swedish waters just as Sweden is joining NATO. My money is on Russian hardliner factions operating rogue without Putin’s approval. He can’t admit he doesn’t know who did it. The Russian state security apparatus is so large, we have no idea what kind of internal tensions exist. Putin may have unleashed something he doesn’t control anymore.
- m000 4y agoGas prices plummeting, energy bills soaring. The market will regulate itself. /s
- empedocles 4y agoThis is because companies buy long term contracts, which are still priced higher than the spot price on the, IMO reasonable, assumption that gas prices will rise again next year as the war continues (and Russia has more options to escalate e.g. cutting TurkStream).
- cpursley 4y agoWhy would they cut (I assume you mean turn off, not blow up) Turkstream? Did you see the recent dealings between Russia and Turkey to expand those gas transit routes via that direction?
- Am4TIfIsER0ppos 4y agoThe market is unable to function normally because of government interference. I expect there is a supplier and a contract somewhere that will give you the spot price. Furthermore the temperature has dropped so I expect demand has increased again so are you really sure you want that contract?
- sph 4y agoI am ambivalent on the idea of a completely free market. Because while I believe it would self-regulate, in a vacuum (or anarchic system), a free market paired with a government means interference, nepotism, laws that favour monopolies and kills competition. So when people like Liz Truss enter 10 Downing Street and claim they want to enact "free market policies", the result is just utter economic upheaval and chaos that hurts regular people further.
- sidewndr46 4y agoBusiness people and political leaders in the West are almost universally in favor of the free market. Until it turns out that said free market might mean they get the short end of the stick. That is to say less tax revenue or less profit. When that happens they suddenly insist there must be some of government intervention, otherwise they are too big to fail.
- jve 4y agoOn some Gas thread, someone posted a link where you could see full %, ingress and egress graphs of gas storages over time across europe. I can't find it. Could someone post it please? Thanks in advance.
- hdjjhhvvhga 4y agoDo you mean this one: https://agsi.gie.eu/ https://agsi.gie.eu/ ?
- jve 4y agoThis is it! Thank you.
- dariusj18 4y agoUkraine seems to be the odd one out, this is not a surprise of course, but it could at least be good, they have the opportunity to buy the gas at the bargain rates.
- kube-system 4y agoUkraine's reserves are probably that way because there's no way to get the gas there, no matter what the price is.
- hdjjhhvvhga 4y agoWhat do you mean? Ukraine produces a lot of gas and also receives gas from the EU via the eastern flow of the Yamal pipeline: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_gas_in_Ukraine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_gas_in_Ukraine
- kube-system 4y agoA lot of the replacement for Russian gas has been LNG imports. Ukraine doesn't have an LNG port as far as I'm aware, and if they did, I doubt it would be easy to get a ship safely there at the moment.
- hulitu 4y ago> Mild autumn weather has sent European gas prices plummeting Ok. So the gas prices are influenced by the weather ? That explains some things. /s
- HPsquared 4y agoThe weather affects the demand for gas which affects the price. How is this controversial?
- krobbn 4y ago"Gas costs €35 per mwh for delivery today, but €110 for a guaranteed shipment in December and €142 for one in February, once heaters turn on." The market is in contago, if you can find a way to store the gas you can make money buying today and delivering in Dec/Jan/Feb. You could even take delivery in December if you can find storage and sell in Feb and lock in a spread of $32 today. This is the reason you're seeing so many LNG ships outside the coast of western Europe.
- bombcar 4y agoIsn't storage just exactly the problem? From what I understand every single possible storage tank in Europe is filled to the brim, and most if not all of the LNG ships are already there or en-route.
- coldpie 4y agoI got some plastic bags hanging around, who do I ring to get in on this?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jimnotgym 4y agoLiz Truss, the short lived prime minister of the UK closed a major gas storage facility when she was energy secretary!
- gruez 4y agoI don't think this is correct. According to the coverage I've read, the facility in question is Rough[1] which closed in 2017. Around that time Truss was "Secretary of State for Justice" and "Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs". In case the latter sounds vaguely energy related, there's a separate cabinet post called "Secretary of State for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy". [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rough_(facility) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rough_(facility)
- 4y ago
- kristo 4y agoDon't discount the fact that many europeans are actively trying to conserve and refuse to heat their house until absolutely necessary. I have 65 yr old friends in amsterdam taking spongebaths because they don't want to support russia
- somedude895 4y agoIs that just an anecdote though? In Switzerland the govt has been running an energy conservation awareness campaign for about 6 weeks now and the stats say it's had zero effect so far.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Tarsul 4y agoI think it helps but it's hard to measure as long as the outside temparatures are not comparable to last years. I follow the diagrams for Germany and right now consumers use about 30% less than the average of 2018-2021[1]. I think many people reduce their heating not just to help Ukraine etc. but also because they (we) know that it's way too expensive and we certainly weren't looking for much cost savings before. I thought I did last year (remember: already 2021 there was news that russia was not delivering as much gas as they usually do) but I'm actually on track to use like 50% less than last year. But yeah, thats just anecdata. [1]https://www.spiegel.de/wirtschaft/erdgas-versorgung-europas-im-live-tracker-speicher-pipelines-lng-a-e2986967-51d2-4c8c-9607-f3ff3e333361 https://www.spiegel.de/wirtschaft/erdgas-versorgung-europas-...
- oezi 4y agoMany German newspapers have data visualization on the topic: Frankfurter Allgemeine: https://m.faz.net/aktuell/wirtschaft/zahlen-zu-strom-und-gas-so-hart-trifft-die-krise-deutschland-18232227.html https://m.faz.net/aktuell/wirtschaft/zahlen-zu-strom-und-gas... Zeit Online: https://www.zeit.de/wirtschaft/energiemonitor-deutschland-gaspreis-spritpreis-energieversorgung https://www.zeit.de/wirtschaft/energiemonitor-deutschland-ga... It seems clear to me that German are trying to save energy both in private households and in industry. This seem quite reasonable given that gas prices for many end customers are double of last year's prices.
- GaylordTuring 4y ago> Before Russia invaded Ukraine, it provided close to 40% of Europe’s gas. I’ve never understood why people say things like this when referring to the operations started in 2022. Wasn’t what they did in Crimea in 2014 an invasion?
- sharikous 4y agoYou are perfectly right. And yet the swiftness of that move made that a fait accompli pretty quickly so people forget that. A better line would be "before the 2022 invasion ..."
- TremendousJudge 4y agoIt's probably what the Russian government expected this time around as well -- if they had taken Ukraine in less than a week (as they apparently expected to), the negative European reaction probably wouldn't have happened, same as in 2014.
- neuronic 4y agoYes, but Europe chose to ignore the 2014 invasion to keep the cheap fossil fuels running and to prevent any major escalation with a nuclear power over a mere peninsula. The hope also was 'Handel durch Wandel' - 'Change through trade'. I can only speak for Germany, but the political discussions about Crimea and Eastern Ukraine did exist for years. However, the government and opposition parties were somewhat in Russias pockets - at the very least their election was dependend on many jobs in industries across different federal states which required cheap Russian gas. Also, the German East is still fairly connected to Russia on a cultural level and this is where you would find most German opponents against NATO these days. Communities directly affected include Lubmin in Mecklenburg-Vorpommern where Nord Stream 2 is landing as well as Schwedt/Oder with the decades old PCK oil refinery that is specialized to process Russian oil (not all oil is the same) and supplied most of the German North East with fuel. Russia has certainly funded a lot of online trolling, political actors (AfD) and disinformation to achieve their goals. For example, they tried to actively prevent Germans from switching to American LNG / fracking gas. German Angst [1] is a pretty fertile ground for disinformation. It's also what drives opposition against nuclear power, more so than the more reasonable arguments regarding economics and prices. Regarding gas, it's mostly about heat generation for industry and NOT electricity where it is a minor player [2]. Natural gas is mostly used for manufacturing and to a lesser scale for quick up/down scaling of electricity generation as support to the baseline. [1] https://www.dw.com/en/germans-and-why-they-worry-about-german-angst/a-16425161 https://www.dw.com/en/germans-and-why-they-worry-about-germa... [2] https://app.electricitymaps.com/zone/DE https://app.electricitymaps.com/zone/DE
- tebbers 4y agoI still haven't turned on my gas central heating yet once in London. This week is set to peak at 16/17 degrees too which is pretty warm for me.
- MomoXenosaga 4y agoNo it hasn't I'm still paying quadruple compared to last year. Sixty euro for 19m3. Do the math. Thank god this country is rich enough to write a 22 billion cheque I have no idea how the less fortunate countries will pull through.
- lencastre 4y agoFor sure not the crazy buying spree,… and it’s not yet winter. Prepare for the worst hope for the best, damn the gas prices. Health is priceless, confort is subjective.