2 ms·
I'm assuming you're asking because the electricity required to generate the hydrogen to power the car would be (much) more efficiently used to directly power th
by BLKNSLVR 4y ago
I'm assuming you're asking because the electricity required to generate the hydrogen to power the car would be (much) more efficiently used to directly power the car. ie. electricity is being used as a process mid-point rather than end-result.
I hear a bit of cynicism about hydrogen being touted by traditional automotive and fossil fuel companies because the business case around it is essentially the same as fossil fuels, where re-charging an electric car can be done at home "for free" (pending a number of dependencies being met), and I agree that it could be a half-step forwards rather than a full-step. But I also believe that it's best to have more than one option, and there are likely to be wildly varying use cases in which each option can an obvious stand-out for different use cases.
What other trade-offs are there in hydrogen vs electric engines? (dependence on rare-earths being one negative on the electric side, but are there also rare-earths required for hydrogen engines or the generation of hydrogen?)
What are the use cases? city driving, country driving, buses, trucks, towing, rail, light aircraft, passenger aircraft, military.
- MegaDeKay 4y agoHere's another trade-off: performance in cold weather. This coming from someone expecting a low of -18C tonight, and winter doesn't officially start for over another month. "The manager also points to another advantage that will save costs in the manufacture of vehicles: the fuel cell generates heat that can be used both to replace the car’s heating and air conditioning, which would also mean greater energy savings" Cold weather is really hard on batteries and can significantly impact range. On top of that is the extra draw on the batteries to run the heater necessary to keep the occupants from freezing. The one upside of the gasoline engine's inefficiency is harnessing the heat it gives off to keep the interior warm. The amount of heat that requires at highway speeds on a -35C day is... substantial.