4 ms·
I think you have the causality all backwards. Colleges with quality gain prestige, which makes people willing to borrow extra money to go there, which creates
by kragen 4y ago
I think you have the causality all backwards. Colleges with quality gain prestige, which makes people willing to borrow extra money to go there, which creates windfall profits administrators can use to increase their personal standing by hiring more headcount and do things like paint the dorms and buy fancier food. That doesn't mean people's priorities in college choice are primarily or even significantly determined by dorm quality or cafeteria food, much less administrative headcount that harms the educational experience if it has any effect at all on it.
If you want what colleges used to be like 50 years ago — more power in the faculty senate, greater academic freedom, more focus on doing research and less on grantwriting, greater freedom to research moonshots, very few adjuncts — you aren't going to find it at small private or public schools that are barely staying afloat.
- bumby 4y ago>Colleges with quality gain prestige How do you define quality in this sense?
- kragen 4y agoTeaching and research. But mostly research.
- bumby 4y agoWhat would you advocate as the best metrics across those domains?
- kragen 4y agoWhat would you advocate as the best metrics across the domains of literary merit and moral fiber? It sounds like you need to read Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance.
- bumby 4y agoHa! As a matter of fact I’m re-reading it at the moment. But as a former reliability engineer, i bristle as Persig’s claim that quality can’t be defined.
- kragen 4y agoquality generally has a broader meaning than conformance to product requirement specifications ;)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bumby 4y ago:-) eh, it always came across to me as a repackaging of the already-existing concept of non-dualism. But i fail to see it’s pragmatic application here. Prestige implies hierarchy, and hierarchy implies ranked measurement. But we can’t define what we’re measuring in terms of quality research or teaching. Apparently, like porn, we’re suppose to just know it when we see it. Like a lot of Pirsigs dialog, it feels a little too precious, without necessarily adding much.
- kragen 4y agoyou don't have to reject cartesian dualism to doubt that you can reduce the quality of artworks or research to 'metrics' or 'ranked measurement'. you just have to not be a complete idiot. hierarchy definitely does not imply ranked measurement
- bumby 4y agoHow would you create a hierarchy without ranking? How would you create ranking without measurement? If it’s just biased ranking, there’s nothing to substantiate it and I can just refute it with my own contrived ranking. That seems to just be a reduction to subjective relativism, which is often the last refuge of people who don’t know what they’re talking about but still want to feel smart. (Or, alternatively, hiding behind rhetorical gimmicks like the “no true Scotsman” fallacy). If they know what they were talking about, I would suspect they could define it. To paraphrase Feynman, if you can’t explain it to a first year student, you don’t really understand.
- exmadscientist 4y agoYes. The other side to the problem that most commenters here are missing is something that is much easier to see if you are employed by the school (as I used to be). There are dozens of layers of bloat and positions that exist only to make Doing Stuff (for values of Stuff that include both Research and Teaching) as slow as possible. Even getting a door fixed -- to stop the door stuck open alarm going off -- took multiple days and multiple people, and not because we had trouble getting a hold of someone. I got decent at navigating this stuff and acquired a reputation as a fixer, which I was all too pleased to move on from, but I sure did become aware of all the people I had to keep happy. There were a lot of them. I firmly believe that at least half of those staff positions (not people, but positions) could have been eliminated with nothing of value lost. It was kind of ridiculous, and it's one of the reasons I don't work for a tier 1 research university anymore. (These jobs also tend to be excellent sinecures and attract the difficult sort of person, often by virtue of who your coworkers are going to be, but that's another story.)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pas 4y agowow, this sounds like a very extreme case study. could you detail why it took many days to fix that door?
- javajosh 4y agoNot precisely the same mechanisms, I'm sure, but the A plot in this Community episode is illustrative: https://community-sitcom.fandom.com/wiki/Analysis_of_Cork-Based_Networking https://community-sitcom.fandom.com/wiki/Analysis_of_Cork-Ba...
- exmadscientist 4y agoNot easily. I wasn't the lead (this one was tackled by the official Lab Manager with the Lab Manager Title, which does matter to some people) so I don't recollect everything that went on. The alarm was intermittent and directly related to use of that door, so it wasn't like it was squawking at 2 am and annoying Security or anything. We did have to do Special Things to that door because we actually needed to prop it open for some Research Stuff, so that added headaches of its own. (I seem to recall the solution to that was a magnet in the right place. Which we had to remove should any official maintenance staff come calling because they hated such quick fixes.) But, honestly, what sticks out in my mind with the Door Saga, what I remember years later, is what the union maintenance guy did. He showed up at 11:55, set up his ladder, then "noticed" it was noon, and left to go on break because that was The Rule. I don't remember what he did with the ladder, but it sure did piss the next guy off... so he left too, because he needed the first guy to do his job. Fun all around! I have union blood in my veins. I don't cross picket lines. UFCW scholarships helped put me through college. So I don't say this lightly: Fuck. That. Union. Utterly destructive leeches. Unions have so much more to offer our workers and our society, and instead they do... this bullshit. Thanks for giving everyone a reason to hate you, you greedy assholes.
- etempleton 4y agoI respectfully disagree. It is true—prestige grants price flexibility for the college. They can charge more equivalent to their relative standing. But what leads to that reputation? How do you measure quality of education?What makes Harvard better than any other college at educating students? How much better? What percentage? Okay now prove it. At least in a succinct explainable way. No, prestige is based on awareness and reputation. That can be gained a lot of ways. Recently a lot of schools have gained reputation through athletics. If you are good at one thing people think you are good at everything and so that reputation becomes overall reputation. Three repeatable anecdotes regarding college enrollments: 1. When a college builds a new fancy building they see an enrollment spike. Almost every time. Especially if it is student quality of life focused. 2. Colleges that have lowered tuition to increase price transparency have consistently seen enrollment drops. 3. When a college or University makes it to March Madness they see an enrollment bump. Reputation is tied to many things. Academic quality is hard to quantify or measure and so any reputation based on academics is apocryphal and based in word of mouth.
- bumby 4y agoI looked up US World News ranking methodology and, to your point, at least 40% is squishy measures like “peer assessment surveys” and “reputation”. Others, like selectivity, are known to be gamed by encouraging students to apply even when they have no chance of getting in (which carries the additional income of the application fee).
- etempleton 4y agoBonus point: What are the highest regarded colleges in the US? The Ivies(with some notable outliers). What is it that ties them together? An athletic conference.
- kragen 4y agoYeah, when you hear of someone who's been accepted to Duke deciding to pursue their studies in the NFL instead, give me a call.
- 4y ago