4 ms·
Even if mastodon takes off, it will be like any other protocol on the internet: A centralized free service will appear , like Gmail did, which most people will
by seydor 4y ago
Even if mastodon takes off, it will be like any other protocol on the internet: A centralized free service will appear , like Gmail did, which most people will be there . Twitter will probably convert its service to activityPub then. Slightly better than what we have today, but it wont be immune.
Also, does anyone remember the backlashes every time facebook made a major change to their website? Yeah , all those users went to friendster for sure ... Social networks have network lock-in. The more mad your users are, the more they talk about it, on the service, which ironically is good for the service.
- JW_00000 4y agoI didn't believe your point about Gmail, expecting many companies to still host their own mail servers or use other services, so I went looking for some data. Found [1], which says that Gmail has 34% market share and Microsoft Exchange 33%. GoDaddy is third with 15% and all others are < 2.5%. Contrary to my expectations, this does confirm that Google and Microsoft are quite close to a duopoly; I'd expected there to be many more providers still. Still, if Twitter would use ActivityPub I'd consider that a huge improvement. I can send a mail from my @outlook.com to your @gmail.com account, and I can send a text message from my Verizon phone number to your AT&T one; while apps like Twitter, Whatsapp, Messenger are all closed off. If Twitter would adopt an open protocol, IMO that would be a huge improvement, preventing lock-in, allowing users to choose between different UIs, having instances with slightly different features competing. (Also, regarding your last point, remember when Digg did a major redesign? Change can happen ;-) ) [1] https://www.datanyze.com/market-share/email-hosting--23 https://www.datanyze.com/market-share/email-hosting--23
- saurik 4y agoWhile it sucks that Gmail dominates e-mail, it is still important and useful that they don't control all of it and that essentially everyone continues to interoperate with the protocol enough that I can still run my own server even if most people don't. You don't have to have a fully distributed protocol with no large players to gain powerful benefits from decentralization.
- lucideer 4y agoGMail dominating email is mainly bad because their level of influence allows them to do things like cripple IMAP (their broken support heavily influences how clients must implement IMAP - usually wrongly on purpose) & push other major hurdles for clients like their "trusted apps" auth ux. However, all things considered, Gmail is still in a way better state than any popular social media service. I can talk to someone on gmail without having a google account. They can talk to me. I can migrate my data on and off it with relative ease. That's not possible with any major social network (gdpr has made the data out situation better but it's still inconsistent and high effort). So even if mastodon gets popular enough to become dominated by a large corp instance, the protocol still represents a massive improvement over the current twitter status quo.