3 ms·
I know the HN guidelines say not to criticize a website's presentation, but Substack's new Medium-like subscription popup has me thinking something else. With
by echelon 4y ago
I know the HN guidelines say not to criticize a website's presentation, but Substack's new Medium-like subscription popup has me thinking something else.
With the resurgence of desire for decentralization, I wonder if publishing too could leap into a p2p or widely-federated model.
I assume authors are the ones opting into this behavior because they want either tracked followers or monetary subscriptions. (VC-fueled platforms probably urge the authors to consider it.)
A system not tied down to a particular platform could reduce the friction. Micropayments + p2p / federation seem like they could work hand in hand. You'd see interesting content from all over the Internet bubble up into your feed, and you could opt to follow or subscribe (similar to Patreon or Github sponsorship).
We'd finally be able to tweak the algorithm directly. Tune it to our interests, the discovery coefficients we want, and filter out known uninteresting content or bad actors. No more BlogThatIHate.com or InsufferableProductFan5.
Bookmarking could exceed what any existing product can do. You could combine your feed/interest graph and bookmarks with your own personal approach to note taking and knowledge management. Instantly access quotes, data, and relevant materials. Your database would be portable, too.
The cooking blogs you follow would be locally or cloud searchable with a nice gallery interface, and you could harness the semantic information within them to build shopping lists. (This, but for all applications. Photography, art, sports, gaming, code, debate, ...)
Medium, Substack, Instagram, TikTok, etc. can't build that. It's too many products. That's why turning this into a shared protocol / data model and reusing the common pieces would allow more innovation and reuse than ever before. It's one of the original ambitions of the semantic web, but finally looks like something we understand enough to be able to model.
Nevermind the politics. This would be amazing from an innovation, shared rails, reuse, and remix perspective.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoThe vast majority of users don't want to pay a small amount to dozens of writers each, but a moderate amount once a month to a single entity.