4 ms·
Who do Mastodon's boosters believe is going to be installing and running Mastodon servers?
by cratermoon 4y ago
Who do Mastodon's boosters believe is going to be installing and running Mastodon servers?
- lostfocus 4y agoNerds
- Ygg2 4y agoBefore they are bought by bigwigs with cash.
- zikduruqe 4y agoThen we'll move to Yddgrasil. https://yggdrasil-network.github.io https://yggdrasil-network.github.io https://letsdecentralize.org https://letsdecentralize.org
- remram 4y agoThis appears to be a transport layer... It is not a social network, and would still require people to run always-on "instances" of software to be usable as one.
- r721 4y agoWho is running current 5k servers? Same kind of people. http://demo.fedilist.com/instance?q=&ip=&software=mastodon®istrations=&sort=mau http://demo.fedilist.com/instance?q=&ip=&software=mastodon&r...
- dmitriid 4y agoAnd most of those servers stopped registrations when the exodus from Twitter began. One reason, so that communities wouldn't get diluted. The other, it's expensive to run this.
- cratermoon 4y agoI wouldn't say "most". According to that site, of the 4880 instances list, 1909 are close and another ~300 are invite-only. > it's expensive to run this As the hype about Mastodon spiked after Musk bought twitter, I looked at it to see if I could set up an instance, just to experiment. I'm an experienced programmer and systems administrator. After perusing the requirements and installation process, I decided that it was too much work for a little one-person experiment. This is why I ask about who is running instances. Yes, I had a strong hunch it would be all nerds, but I didn't expect it to be require so much sophistication and outlay. One very dedicated person could certainly set up and run an instance, but most likely any instance of moderate popularity is going to require a team.
- r721 4y agoOn the topic of costs I saw this today in my Mastodon feed: >The costs were already ~$35/month even with reserved instances; back-of-the-envelope is that the new costs would be in the ballpark of ~$50/month. https://toot.cafe/@nolan/109295574721909717 https://toot.cafe/@nolan/109295574721909717 toot.cafe is #216 (by MAU) in the list above, MAU=315 - there's a data point.
- zimpenfish 4y agoThey should migrate to Pleroma and reduce their monthly costs.
- zimpenfish 4y ago> After perusing the requirements and installation process Was that the original Mastodon? That does have a reputation of being faffy to install and resource-hungry. Pleroma is much easier and less resource-hungry. Even I managed to spin up a Pleroma server without any trouble. > most likely any instance of moderate popularity is going to require a team. It'll need a team for coverage of moderation, support, perhaps 24/7 ops - but then anything with a lot of users will, surely?
- 4y ago
- cratermoon 4y agoA list of the servers is data, but where does one go to find out about the people or organizations running them? How do we know that that a couple of thousand of them aren't all run by one group?
- paulgb 4y agoMastadon provides a way for servers to have an “about” page, which often has more details about who runs the server. In some cases they prefer to be pseudonymous, but in some it’s possible to attach the instance to a human.
- easrng 4y agoSome are on managed hosting from companies like https://masto.host/ https://masto.host/
- crocowhile 4y agoI am a scientist and I've setup a mastodon instance on my own server, with remote file hosting on S3. It was pretty painless and in a few days 200 non tech-savvy people have joined and started contributed. Some migrating from twitter, some joining social media for the first time. It is great.
- twmiller 4y agoThe same sort of people who decided it'd be interesting and/or fun to snag an extra phone line and set up a BBS back in the day, I suspect.
- Kye 4y agoSomeone is. Instance count is growing in proportion to user count.
- davoneus 4y agoYeah, it's a major issue (to some at least). Lots of fly by night servers, stood up by (probably well meaning) people that have no idea if how hard it is to run and administer a server like that. Point in fact the "Mastodon.technology"(MT) server If you read the heartfelt post from the MT owners/op on why it had to be shutdown. How much it took of his life to run it, and the choices he made. It doesn't matter that a new "like that" MT server is being stood up as a replacement. The MT server admins post shows the burden of running a server like that. For free (unless Patreon'ed I guess). Activity Pub is a well designed protocol, but to my eye it has some major warts(). Add in it's decentralized nature and it shows how hard it will be to institute major changes, even if the community supported it. I'd like to find a nice, professionally run Mastodon server, with clear rules and a believable investment in infrastructure and people. Absent that, I certainly can't see myself advocating for it, it recommending it to others. Shame too. () Lack of encryption, lack of non-server discovery, lack of consistent, user controled server migration.p