3 ms·
OK, on the face of it, this a people problem. But "distracted operator" issues have been known about for decades; how do other industries solve them? How can w
by HeyLaughingBoy 15y ago
OK, on the face of it, this a people problem. But "distracted operator" issues have been known about for decades; how do other industries solve them?
How can we apply technology to at least alleviate the problem? Some phones have a speech-to-text mode where you can have texts read to you or you can speak and have it turned into SMS.
What happens when the phone is more integrated with the car? It limits the driver's interaction with it and gives the "system" an opportunity to control when the phone rings (perhaps don't allow it to ring when the car detects it's in stop & go traffic).
Rather than bitching about how "idiots" use their cell phones perhaps we can be more productive in thinking about other solutions to the problem .
- mindslight 15y agoWell, the real problem is the drivers who have poor response times for whatever reason. There's no current good way to judge who is really at fault for an accident, so society devolves into witch hunts against drunk drivers, speeding, cell phones, etc. What about simply recording as much data as possible so driver behavior preceding/during an accident can be reconstructed after the fact? Such a system mandated by insurance/government (same thing) would clearly be an abomination of privacy/ownership issues, but if it was developed for end-users to help prove their innocence, it could be implemented properly (user-based crypto+open formats+local storage).
- anigbrowl 15y agoWait, what? Why do you argue that members of the public or of an insurance pool have no interest in minimizing the economic cost to them of reckless drivers' risky behavior? Sure, if you drive everywhere at 100 mph and we buy auto insurance from the same company, your direct impact on my premium is minimal, maybe a few cents extra annually, because your increased risk is spread out across a large pool of insureds. But risky drivers exist in quantity too, and collectively their impact on the cost of insurance is large, as is the drag they create on GDP or taxes. Certainly, I think that vehicle telemetry data should be available to defendants in driving-related criminal cases or litigation. And as a matter of fact, it is, via the legal procedure of discovery. You seem to think that this should only be available to the defendant, but never to prosecutors or plaintiffs. Why not? If you're driving on the public highway, then your driving behavior is a matter of public concern to the extent that it impacts others; and to the extent that other people are exposed to the risks arising from your operation of a vehicle, you cannot reasonably claim an expectation of privacy - unless you're willing to move to a regime of strict liability for accidents, and pay correspondingly higher insurance premiums.
- mindslight 15y agoMy second paragraph wasn't trying to be philosophical, just what I see as the practical outcomes. If developed for the end user before becoming de facto mandated, there's a much better chance that it would be a system with some notion of privacy between independent actors. A court would have to request the relevant records of the accident rather than getting weeks worth of data ripe with circumstantial evidence. (Whether a defendant can refuse this request is irrelevant, eventually withholding the data while the other party's data shows reasonable actions would be viewed in a negative light) What would such a system look like if developed by insurance companies? I'm guessing it would contain a cell modem that would continually upload as much data as possible to the insurance company. They'd then datamine that looking for 'dangerous' drivers and charge them more, even if they have less accidents. Who would you rather have in your insurance pool going forward - someone who speeds everywhere with no accidents, or someone who drives under the speed limit yet has managed to total their car twice in the past year? There's no answer to that - my point is that we just don't really know who the bigger risk is a priori despite much effort, so the game-changing goal should be better analysis after the fact.
- anigbrowl 15y agoMindlsight, I don't think you have even the haziest idea of how criminal prosecutions or lawsuits work. Courts rarely request anything; prosecutors or plaintiffs make requests through the court, which can be contested by the defense, and the defense can seek records in turn (like the disciplinary record of an arresting officer, for example, or the records of equipment calibration in a DUI case etc.). There's no answer to that - my point is that we just don't really know who the bigger risk is a priori despite much effort What do you think insurance actuaries do all day, other than study insurable risk? Read your insurance policy if you have one, they can and will raise your premium if you have a history of accidents. Honestly, you seem kind of paranoid. Insurers want to reduce risk, but still keep their product cheap enough for people to buy it.
- mindslight 15y agoI do know how legal discovery generally works, there just wasn't much point getting into specifics when it doesn't change my point. Fundamentally, the court is what has the power to make requests, even though those requests originate from opposing counsel. > What do you think insurance actuaries do all day, other than study insurable risk? This is precisely what I meant by 'much effort'. Let's make this concrete: If you frequented a lot of bars as a designated driver and the insurance companies gained access to your location data, what do you think would happen to your rates? How do you think this change compares to the change that would occur if they could somehow perfectly predict your expected payout? And actually, yes, I am paranoid and proud of it. The corner cases of systems are the important ones; expected behavior is dead easy.