4 ms·
"Bashing new myths about digital nomads" with almost no actual evidence to counter those myths. The quote below is one of the "arguments" from the article. I ho
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
"Bashing new myths about digital nomads" with almost no actual evidence to counter those myths. The quote below is one of the "arguments" from the article. I hope the author can realize the extreme irony in this paragraph:
> What we need are real studies measuring the total economic, employment, housing and well-being effect of actual digital nomads on local communities. Such studies would show that digital nomads are very, very good for the communities where they live.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- withinboredom 4y agoI have very many doubts digital nomads are good for any community except a community they are prevalent in. Nomads, by definition, don’t meaningfully contribute to a community. They don’t create deep relationships, families, or traditions. Instead, they bring outside perceptions and traditions that may either invigorate or destroy the community they are visiting. Is it good for the community’s economy, probably. Is it good for anything else? Probably not unless the culture is at least adjacent to one you’ve lived in before. (IOW, if you come from one strong religious community to another one, or an artistic community to another one, you would be able to recognize what you’re experiencing and fit into your worldview; thus being able to more easily meaningfully contribute to the community)
- Timpy 4y agoI'm abroad right now working remotely, I've had nothing but extremely positive interactions with the culture here and it's about as distant as two cultures can get. The crusades are over, I can't say I've met a ton of other digital nomads but I never got the impression anyone is going around destroying communities they're visiting. Learning more about and experiencing other cultures has deeply enriched my life, I do my best to be a good guest in the country and a lot of people seem interested in learning more about life where I'm from too. I know my argument is anecdotal here, but at least anecdotes are better than your wild and unfounded speculation.
- bombcar 4y agoYou haven’t met many so it’s not destructive. Any community or ecosystem can withstand some external forces and pressure, but they can still get overwhelmed. There’s also the difference between a digital immigrant and a digital nomad - the first intends to stay and begins to care about where they are; the second may care but will be gone at a whim.
- xyzzy_plugh 4y agoCurious questions and of course don't answer if it's not safe: do you remit full local taxes? Are they equivalent to a native local worker? Are you paid or employed as a worker of where you are now, or where you're from?
- z9znz 4y agoIn most countries you are not technically allowed to work. They don't have a tax arrangement for you. You could not pay taxes if you wanted, because there is no system for you to be working. You are paying taxes to your home country if you're American. If you're from another country and living abroad for enough days per year (depends on the home country), then you won't be paying taxes to your home country. The place you're working remotely from still gets the benefit of you injecting revenue into their area, and you're not taking local jobs away.
- throwaway290 4y agoKeep in mind though that a lot of the infrastructure one would be using including public transport, roads, water is subsidized with tax one is not paying.
- z9znz 4y agoTrue, but DNs often pay a premium for many services which locals do not pay. And DNs often spend a lot more than locals do just by virtue of having more to spend. In places which thrive or depend on tourism, working DNs are a blessing. The broke backpackers are less so, as they live on the cheap (which is totally fine for them but offers less to the local community). Also, DNs are a tiny, tiny percentage of public transport riders in places that have public transportation. Likewise, I don't imagine DNs are using vast amounts of water... especially since we tend to buy bottled water for drinking, and we often don't cook at home (so whoever we are paying for food is getting water however they get it). As for roads and road maintenance costs, those should be covered in part by vehicle registrations. If we rent a car or a scooter, or we take a taxi, the costs are part of the fare. Aside from building a local dependency on foreign visitors who splash money around, I don't see much downsides to DNs existing in remote places (assuming of course that they behave like decent humans).
- heavyset_go 4y agoIt's like any type of immigration, there are plenty of people visiting and working in countries on short term visas. I don't think there's anything unique about "digital nomads" through that lens.
- bigDinosaur 4y agoThere isn't. It's a scapegoat, the failure is almost always with local authorities and governments (e.g. tolerating excessive Airbnb).
- miguelazo 4y agoThose local authorities are under extreme pressure by monied interests (including Airbnb) to accept the commoditization of their housing market for “digital nomads”. Even in places like Los Angeles where most people are renters the local authorities have barely begun to get the situation under control.
- heavyset_go 4y agoI'm definitely sympathetic to this argument, AirBnb ruined housing markets. I'm curious how much of the demand actually comes from "digital nomads", though.
- xbar 4y agoIt is a good thing to be curious about. We don't have good numbers and it really is only a question of numbers. Any community can tolerate a certain amount of tourism or immigration. My take is that most communities are small and have never had to deal with much growth. It would not surprise me if their little boats are getting swamped.
- miguelazo 4y agoFair point. I would estimate digital nomads are less than 10% of the total market. I do suspect they have an outsize effect, especially the ones who are “influencers”.
- tayo42 4y agoYour whole post can describe tourism too
- scarface74 4y ago> Nomads, by definition, don’t meaningfully contribute to a community. They don’t create deep relationships, families, or traditions. Guess how many of those things my wife and I were doing in the suburban neighborhood where we were living before we started our (domestic) digital nomad journey?
- xbar 4y agoWhat could have been a serious economic impact commentary on the impact of digital nomads is, in-fact, a fluff piece to help Computerworld readers justify their presence to the other parents at their kids' school winter pageant in the formerly-charming community they have ruined.