5 ms·
Meta’s Meltdown Shows How Big Tech’s Invincible Era Is Over
- davidkuennen 4y agoThis has nothing to do with tech. It's the ad business that's struggling, because of the economic situation and because more players want to have a piece of the cake (e.g. Apple, TikTok).
- throwaway29303 4y ago... (e.g. Apple, TikTok). Indeed and Big News too[0]. [0] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30177741 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30177741
- jsemrau 4y agoThis. Instead of a Meta/Google/Twitter world advertisers can now create deals with Amazon, Disney[1], Apple [2] Netflix [3], Mercado Libre, etc directly without the social media middlemen, without the political outrage, and without running the risk of offending a highly polarized group. What we have to realize is that (a) the era of social networks is over. There is no need to create content for social networks, because that's not where your audience is anymore. (b) EigenSocial sites like Lunchclub and Youtube will change the way we connect, learn, engage online. (c) Monetization is deeply embedded in these products which makes it much more interesting/safer/profitable to be on those sites. [1] https://deadline.com/2022/07/disney-record-9-billion-upfront-advertising-streaming-digital-1235071895/ https://deadline.com/2022/07/disney-record-9-billion-upfront... [2] https://www.reuters.com/technology/apple-expand-live-tv-advertising-around-new-soccer-deal-bloomberg-news-2022-11-04/ https://www.reuters.com/technology/apple-expand-live-tv-adve... [3] https://app.finclout.io/t/nvqDbev https://app.finclout.io/t/nvqDbev
- kylehotchkiss 4y agoMeta’s meltdown has a lot to do with terrible decision making at the top and too many yes-people blindly agreeing because the king set up the company where nobody can disagree with his decisions. Facebook could have pursued other social network ideas and found a way to keep things steady. Even a twitter competitor would have been interesting. More focus on competing with LinkedIn?
- notfromhere 4y agoFacebook’s problem is that it doesn’t matter what they do, the brand is very negative. LinkedIn would be an interesting competitor to go after, Microsoft bought it and has no idea what to do with it
- nicce 4y agoWell at least we have seen some ”funny” ads: https://www.theregister.com/AMP/2021/02/11/microsoft_azure_ubuntu_data_sharing/ https://www.theregister.com/AMP/2021/02/11/microsoft_azure_u...
- elforce002 4y agoThis. The damage is irreparable. When boomers start leaving this earth, fb will start going with them. I think their business model will change to something like acquire the hottest startups and exploiting them until they sucked them dry. At least Mark has WhatsApp and IG yet. LinkedIn on the other hand is just pride in a bottle. I doubt they'll change their strategy. If they try to appeal to other markets, they'll die just because their core premise is cv placement. That's it. Anything else won't work.
- JamesianP 4y agoThey did almost a hundred acquisitions, mostly thanks to their high-flying stock. Their eggs weren't all in one basket (though they sure did their best to act like they were). Maybe they just couldn't make any more hits out of the field because almost no one could?
- duud 4y agoThe only meltdown is the stock price. FB is still the most popular social network in the world. Insta is likely second. Quest has outsold Xbox and is on the way to outselling PlayStation. $27 billion in revenue from three billion daily active users last quarter. Bytedance by comparison lost $7 billion last year. Meta Reels are being shared one billion times and viewed 140 billion per day. As much as the biased media wants it to be true, Meta isn't going anywhere anytime soon. Consumers couldn't care less about the stock price.
- kumarvvr 4y agoThe question is what will replace the insatiable need for some section of the population to communicate to the masses. Youtube is useless and its audience is highly fragmented. Twitter is with Elon now, so who knows. Facebook is doomed. Its a cesspool of endless ads. Instagram perhaps. Pinterest and Snap are not that mainstream as Twitter was. Mastodon is a bunch of blumbs with some nerps that kerfufle with munk.
- mertd 4y ago> Today, even though the five stocks still make up over 13% of the market value of the S&P 500, the FAANG narrative seems like it’s over for good. Let me save you ten minutes. It is a zero information article. Gives no backing for this central claim, instead randomly rambles about Meta without saying anything that hasn't been said a million times before.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoAgreed. If anything, I think the separate fortunes of Meta and Netflix vs Google, Amazon, Apple and Microsoft show how much "platform control" matters and why Zuckerberg is spending so much to "make the metaverse happen". I think the best way to define "platform control" is to think about how disruptive it would be, not just to consumers, but also to an integrated web of other businesses (and governments for that matter) if a business all of a sudden disappeared. If any of Google, Amazon, Apple or Microsoft stopped existing tomorrow, it would be a major international disaster. Think of all the businesses that sell on Amazon, all of the internet companies that depend on AWS, Azure and GCP, all the phones that run Android, all the computers that run Windows, all of the apps that depend on iOS, etc. etc. If Meta and Netflix disappeared tomorrow, would people care that much? Heck, many folks would cheer. And yes, while I'm minimizing some of the follow on effects (e.g. to all the organizations whose sole web presence is on a Facebook page, to all the users across the globe who depend on WhatsApp, to all the shows and movies that are Netflix exclusives, etc.), switching to alternatives wouldn't really be that disruptive - in many cases it's already happening. The worsening fortunes of Meta and Netflix are because the stock market has concluded that their "moats" aren't as deep and wide as envisioned a couple years ago.
- jen20 4y agoAnother minimisation is people who make use of Facebook as an OAuth provider for third party things. Your analysis seems pretty good to me though.
- YeBanKo 4y agoLots of bussiness use Facebook and Instagram for ads and reaching clients. I know few people who run shops selling clothing exclusively on Instagram and Facebook. They got rid of their websites and even communicate with client through IG messaging, etc. Not sure what impact disappearance of Meta would have, but I think there are many niche areas for which it wouldn’t be negligible.
- jaflo 4y agohttps://archive.ph/qDh86 https://archive.ph/qDh86
- zeruch 4y agoEvery 'era' has some set of folk who think whatever hot thing is "invincible" and all of them are wrong, every time. Even in cases like Apple (which was very vincible for a long time) and IBM (which is the only major firm to pivot multiple times over a century and still roam about as a major player) had to adapt hard, and they are outliers. The rest are just dead, assimilated into other players, etc. The industry has always been dynamic and most aspects, very very fungible.
- abraxas 4y agoTo your point, I remember growing up in the mid eighties to early nineties there were a handful of "invincible" companies that we were sure weren't going ANYWHERE within our lifetimes: * Sun Microsystems * Silicon Graphics * Cisco * Hewlett Packard * Digital * Compaq * Intel * Motorola * Atari plus some "invincible" Japanese power houses (especially in the eighties): * Sony * Panasonic * Hitachi * Sanyo * TDK If anyone in the late nineties told me that there would be a pocket computer built in 2008 that would be owned or aspired to by everyone on the planet from teenagers to CEOs my investment would likely go to Palm, Handspring or Motorola. Certainly NOT Apple or Google (the latter of which wasn't even around until the late nineties). That any of the above would be dead or shadows of their former selves within 30 years was simply unthinkable
- delta_p_delta_x 4y agoI’m not sure this list is particularly accurate. Many American companies are still most certainly alive and kicking (HP/HPE; Intel; Cisco; Motorola), and the Japanese ones manufacture plenty of other things besides just computer hardware. Hitachi, for instance, sold its HGST hard drive business to WD, but it also makes a lot of heavy-industry and defence equipment, including tanks, APCs, rolling-stock, lifts, and construction equipment. Sony is by far the biggest manufacturer of CMOS sensors (almost every single smartphone uses a Sony sensor), and not even including its music, film, video game, camera, and smartphone divisions. Sure, they don’t make VAIO notebooks and Walkmans any more, but they almost certainly have a massive monopoly/duopoly over many of their other divisions. It’s just survival of the fittest. You could’ve said the same thing about aeroplane companies throughout the ‘50s to ‘90s. Almost every other American company has been subsumed into Boeing or Lockheed-Martin; the same goes for many other British companies that are now BAE Systems, and European companies that are now Airbus.
- notacoward 4y agoSeems like it's big internet tech that's foundering. Here are some tech companies that are holding up quite well relative to S&P overall: Oracle, Cisco, Texas Instruments, IBM. None of these have "daily average users" as a primary growth metric. Nuts-and-bolts tech is still doing OK. It's more like 2000 than I think most people (especially here) would like to admit.
- varelse 4y ago
- klyrs 4y agoGod, this headline is a blast from the past. They said the same exact shit when the dot com bubble popped.
- bergenty 4y agoWhat meltdown?
- barbariangrunge 4y agoIf big techs era is over, I encourage them to sell all their stocks in big tech as proof of their beliefs. No? I think this is just rhetoric for clicks
- jjtheblunt 4y ago> Meta’s Meltdown Shows How Big Tech’s Invincible Era Is Over or does it show Meta lost touch with userbase realities?
- simne 4y agoI see nothing new, nothing special. Just another big boss didn't live up to the expectations of the crowd. Such things happen many times before with large companies on free market, some survive, others not.