4 ms·
One factual error that the article makes is that DRM'd content is harder to pirate. That is simply not the case; every piece of content ever released is easily
by jrockway 15y ago
One factual error that the article makes is that DRM'd content is harder to pirate. That is simply not the case; every piece of content ever released is easily pirate-able. The only thing that DRM does is hurt legitimate users.
Also, I was kind of upset by the "letter" that the person who uploaded the torrent wrote. "Art is meant to be shared"? Why bother justifying it with something that sounds stupid when you could just say nothing or say, "I thought people might want to get it this way, so here it is". Depressing.
And finally, I never realized that Louis C.K. was so mainstream. I thought his humor appealed to me and maybe three other people. Oh well :)
- yan 15y agore: DRM, I wouldn't call it a factual error. The article didn't imply that it's not possible, it just said it was harder. And I'd argue stripping DRM (no matter how easy it is) is, is in fact harder than not bothering. re: Popularity, I thought so too, until I had to wait on a long, long line to see him in Caroline's over two years ago. I was lucky enough to snag tickets to the Beacon theater show (that he's selling now) and it sold out in minutes. He also did 3 consecutive shows in Brooklyn, NY, tickets to which were announced the day of practically and not a single person I know got tickets (and many, many tried). I heard lines wrapping the block more than once. I've never seen this kind of commitment to a comedian.
- scythe 15y ago>And I'd argue stripping DRM (no matter how easy it is) is, is in fact harder than not bothering. But it's never, ever, necessary, not when gazillions of scene groups strip DRM from a work and upload it as soon as it hits the market, if not before; sometimes they just get hold of the studio version. It might make some obscure video games harder to pirate, since it's much harder to strip DRM from code than from data, but video? No way. DRM makes it harder for me to put legitimate content on a device I own, but it makes it no harder to pirate that same content.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- ColdSnickersBar 15y agoYou're not most people. I don't think you fully realize just how 'not-geeky' everyone else is. Almost every single internet user does NOT know how to torrent something at all. A lot of the people who are going to watch his performance would, basically, stop at trying to email a video to someone or copy it right to a DVD. If they can't do that, then they don't bother trying to distribute illegally at all. Having a DRM-free version basically means that the grandmas and middleschoolers and casual internet users of the world (almost everyone) are going to inevitably "pirate" it when they simply put it on a DVD or email it to a friend.
- danso 15y agoYou may be correct that DRM makes it "no harder to pirate that same content"...but it DOES make it harder for people to transfer files to each other through email/CDs/USB keys. To you, it may seem trivial to load up a torrent program and spend some of the day browsing the trackers, but this is not at all trivial to the average person. Think about it...DRM can be circumvented on iTunes music by burning it to a CD, giving someone the CD, and then ripping that CD. Or just burning to CD and ripping to your own computer and THEN distributing the files. Yet iTunes has been a huge success because people either do not realize this or because the few extra steps is not worth the effort. Small extra steps make a huge difference between what is theoretically doable and what people actually tolerate doing.
- kbutler 15y ago> Yet iTunes has been a huge success because people either do not realize this or because the few extra steps is not worth the effort. Please be careful attributing the success of iTunes to DRM. According to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FairPlay http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FairPlay: - Steve Jobs said that Apple didn't want to use DRM but was forced to by the music labels, who wouldn't provide the music w/o DRM. - Apple announced in Jan 2009 iTunes was moving to DRM-free music.
- chwahoo 15y ago"One factual error that the article makes is that DRM'd content is harder to pirate. That is simply not the case; every piece of content ever released is easily pirate-able. The only thing that DRM does is hurt legitimate users." That's hardly a "factual error". I can email an mp3 to my friend and have them play it. I can't do the same with a DRM'd song. Is that not harder? Instead I have to make extra efforts to strip the DRM or find a non-DRM'd version elsewhere. For non-technical users, it might actually be "hard" to pirate DRM'd content. While the article could/should have taken care to make the subtle point that you allude to, I find it's phrasing less disingenuous than yours.
- pyre 15y agoI think the point the parent was making is that all it takes it one person stripping the DRM and the content is on the Internet (torrents, usenet, private ftps, etc). It might not be easy to share person-to-person (for non-technical users), but if one just searches the Internet the content would be there somewhere.
- ColdSnickersBar 15y agoNon-technical users are almost every single user in the world. So, if DRM prevents just those people from being able to simply email a video to a friend, then it actually is preventing most "pirating".
- pyre 15y agoIt prevents person-to-person sharing for non-technical users of the original content. The real question is: How hard is it for a non-technical user to find and download a pirated version from the Internet? It's the difference between: Hey! This track is awesome lemme email it to you. and Hey! This track is awesome. Google for a pirated version of it!
- dmd 15y agoMost people I know outside of programming circles would find the latter to be WAY too much bother.
- ryandvm 15y ago> I never realized that Louis C.K. was so mainstream. I thought his humor appealed to me and maybe three other people. Well, he does have his own show on FX.
- smackfu 15y agoFX is the home of non-mainstream comedies.
- xer0 15y agoAnything on TV more widely available than public access is, almost by definition, mainstream. Even the non-mainstream shows are mainstream, their selling point being that they're "non-mainstream." If a show doesn't make big dollars for the network, it doesn't get on in the first place. Almost everything you see and touch today is mainstream, and if you think it isn't, it's because it's been marketed to you as non-mainstream.
- jrockway 15y agoI don't think that's quite fair. Some shows are more obscure than others. I'd use Parks & Recreation as an example of a "marketed as non-mainstream" show. It's not as popular as The Office, sure, but pretty much everyone has heard of it. Louie is a bit different. Most people haven't heard of FX, and of those that have, most people haven't watched Louie. So while not obscure like "one copy of this book was ever published", it's not "mainstream" like Seinfeld.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- liquidcool 15y agoActually, I think if you look at the ratings Comedy Central has more obscure comedies. I am assuming that "non-mainstream" translates to small audience. Keep in mind that while Sunny started out as a cult hit, it's about to become the longest running live action comedy on cable. In contrast, last Thursday The Daily Show did worse than Sunny, The League, and Beavis and Butthead. And if you compare to broadcast, all of cable looks non-mainstream.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- robotresearcher 15y ago> And finally, I never realized that Louis C.K. was so mainstream. I thought his humor appealed to me and maybe three other people. You've spotted his genius. Like 90s-era Nine Inch Nails or Metallica, he is the popular act that feels subversive. Reddit has this vibe too[1]. It's worth a fortune. [1] I know, you liked it before it jumped the shark, etc etc.
- MrJagil 15y ago"every piece of content ever released is easily pirate-able" Tell that to the guys trying to crack propellerheads Reason 6.
- waitwhat 15y agoTo save anyone else the googling: Reason 6 requires a dongle.
- mukyu 15y agoWhile it may be true that all DRM is pointless in an ideal world there are cases where it actually works. Good counter-examples are Autodesk's products (their DRM/dongles stand up for 6+ months) or the PS3 that took years for people to be able to play pirated games.