4 ms·
> I know there are Marxists who claim that the USSR wasn’t even properly socialist, You don't have to be a Marxist to claim that the USSR wasn't properly "soci
by pessimizer 4y ago
> I know there are Marxists who claim that the USSR wasn’t even properly socialist,
You don't have to be a Marxist to claim that the USSR wasn't properly "socialist." You just have to read whoever you think lays out a clear definition of socialism, and compare it to the government of the USSR as observed.
When your analysis of the facts of the situation values the power dynamics of differing groups of adherents to fringe radical movements over simple observation and checking of requirements off of a list, you're caught up in political drama, not ideological drama.
- philwelch 4y agoIt's a semantic argument and I'm not attached to any particular definition of socialism. Also, I find that most arguments that "the Soviet Union wasn't actually socialist" are disingenuous attempts by socialists to deflect from the fact that their ideas have never actually worked in practice, but that's beside the point somewhat.