3 ms·
It depends on the TCP stacks on each side; some crappy TCP stacks let you forge connections rather easily. I don't think Bittorrent works over UDP, but if it d
by jrockway 15y ago
It depends on the TCP stacks on each side; some crappy TCP stacks let you forge connections rather easily. I don't think Bittorrent works over UDP, but if it does, that's very easy to forge in theory (assuming your ISP doesn't do egress filtering).
The best excuse is probably, "I installed some malware and I guess it turned my box into a torrent gateway".
- VMG 15y agoThe best excuse is probably, "I installed some malware and I guess it turned my box into a torrent gateway". Unless the law says that you are responsible for everything that happens on your internet connection. I don't know if or where this is the case, but it seems realistic and even reasonable.
- babebridou 15y agoIt is the case in France. You could see it the same way as a car insurance, you're responsible for any damage it does, except your car can be safely locked in your garage when someone else wrecks it into a porcelain store, and you can't possibly prevent it from happening nor prove that it wasn't yours.
- darksaga 15y agoWhich would be easy to dump off on the provider. "I have a firewall and anti-virus, what more can I be responsible for if my provider isn't securing THEIR network?" Ignorance of the law isn't a plausible defense in the eyes of the law, but you when you have so many parties besides yourself involved, I would think it would be easier to claim it was something on their end.
- jrockway 15y agoIn the US, you aren't responsible for crimes you didn't commit. That means if someone uses your computer to commit a crime, and you didn't intend to help them, you didn't do anything wrong.
- tbrownaw 15y agoDoesn't that not allow for "strict liability" rules?
- tedunangst 15y agoattractive nuisance.
- tptacek 15y agoSpoofing IP addresses is wildly more difficult than this, and implausible in the BitTorrent scenario. * There are no mainstream TCP stacks that have the vulnerability you're alluding to (poorly randomized sequence numbers). * Even during the Mitnick/Shimomura days, the attack only got you the transmit side, not the receive side; it was sufficient to push an RSH command, but not to dump a file. * There are network-level controls that make this attack more difficult; for instance, ISPs increasingly do reverse path filtering to ensure they're only egressing traffic from their own ISP space (we'd watch this happen while monitoring DDoS attacks at Arbor, seeing "randomized" source addresses constrained to prefixes from specific ASNs). There is still IP spoofing, but it's got dollar signs attached to it, significant enough to merit BGP tampering. When laypersons claim to be victims of spoofing, they are overwhelmingly likely to be full of it. I couldn't possibly be less interested in the politics of Bittorrent and labels ("Movie theater employees caught sneaking into shows without tickets --- FILM AT 11") and admit to reading this thread only out of masochism, but my nerd brain can't get past 'jrockway talking about IP spoofing; if it was anyone else, sure, but 'jrockway should know what he's talking about here. :)
- jrockway 15y agoAgree completely. Quite implausible, especially since it's not 1990 anymore.
- cookiecaper 15y agoIn many cases the term "spoofed" is probably used loosely to mean "they stole our wifi". I understand that that's not what the press release claimed, but such excuses still benefit filesharers because all of the industry's lawsuits heretofore have been based on matching IP address to registered ISP user and holding that user accountable for the activity that occurred on their network. Making this excuse, then, only seems to serve the little people that are next on their "to sue" list.
- xtacy 15y agoSome versions of BitTorrent use uTP, which is a delay based congestion control algorithm implemented on top of UDP. It is extremely TCP friendly and in fact succumbs to ongoing long TCP flows, which tend to fill up buffers at your access point.