2 ms·
I realize this is an emotional topic for some people but think about what this is really doing: the government isn't asking anyone to open anything up but rathe
by acdha 4y ago
I realize this is an emotional topic for some people but think about what this is really doing: the government isn't asking anyone to open anything up but rather scanning what they've already exposed to the entire internet. If there's something there you want to keep private, you should be closing it to everyone except the authenticated users you want to have access to it. You are not better off in any meaningful way if you block a public vulnerability scanner but leave yourself wide open to everyone else.
Consider, for example, the possibility that the government might have technical people at least as adept as the average teenager looking to pirate movies. If they were trying to something you consider malicious, would they a) put up a public web page telling you how to detect their traffic and stop it[1] or b) scan it from IPs which are not easily attributed? Using cheap commercial hosting for that would cost a fraction of what they pay a single employee per month and it's not exactly a technically-daunting task — and if it were, they'd toss a few thousand at Shodan.io to do it for them, an amount which could be buried in the printer supply budget of any national government.
1. https://www.ncsc.gov.uk/information/ncsc-scanning-information https://www.ncsc.gov.uk/information/ncsc-scanning-informatio...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nmeagent 4y ago> You are not better off in any meaningful way if you block a public vulnerability scanner but leave yourself wide open to everyone else. That is a value judgment better made by the server owner, don't you think? It is their private (perhaps leased) property we're talking about after all. Perhaps the government should ask first before periodically scanning someone's property?
- acdha 4y agoIt’s privately owned but publicly accessible and there’s a strong public interest in shutting down insecure servers before they’re compromised by malicious actors. To me this seems more like the government having an inspector walking down the street and observing whether your building has broken windows, rats, and smells of gas. Any information they get is something you’re giving away to the entire internet anyway. Again, I’m not saying you don’t have the right to block them - they even give you an easy way to opt-out - but that it seems misdirected to worry about the people asking nicely when the internet is full of actually malicious people who don’t ask.