2 ms·
I mean, does it matter? Even a lot of reviews that are clearly real are from people who have completely lost their minds, from people who give 1 star for no oth
by crazygringo 4y ago
I mean, does it matter? Even a lot of reviews that are clearly real are from people who have completely lost their minds, from people who give 1 star for no other reason than it was "made in China", to people who give 1 star because shipping was slow to people who give 1 star because the item is way too big/small even though they never looked at its dimensions. And there's always the top "most helpful" review that's scaremongering about how the product causes CANCER!! (Because they don't understand how California Prop 65 labels work.)
Even if we got rid of fake reviews, at least 75% of real reviews add no value. Like so many Amazon book reviews that are simply "arrived quickly, cover in good condition".
BUT... as long as you sort by "most helpful" and read the top ~30 reviews, it's generally pretty clear whether the product is reliable or breaks (and how/when), and whether it is as advertised or not. It's pretty easy to suss out the signal from the noise. Call it critical thinking, call it a having a bullshit detector, call it common sense. But I just don't see a problem here, as long as there's a "helpful" vote button and "sort by helpful".
- zulfazli 4y agoSo how does the prop 65 label supposed to work? Asking as a person who has never been to US and only heard about the label being ridiculed since it is applied on all/ most products sold there.
- JamesianP 4y agoFrom what I've read, Amazon deletes reviews that indicate the product is made in China. Your implication that it's some kind of racist basis for the review itself may explain why, but I doubt this is the primary reason. It's probably more that people are unhappy with the item first, then the identification as Chinese-made as about the only way to screen out these companies swamping Amazon with thousands of short-lived low-quality brands. Since the law requires them to at least indicate this much. I do see lots of 1-star reviews complaining that the package came damaged or something. I tended to consider them worthless. But recently I have gotten a couple items that looked like the box spent months in a dumpster or something, so maybe they had a point too.