4 ms·
This seems totally insane to me. The lawsuit is arguing that directors not only have a fiduciary responsibility to shareholders to increase the value of their M
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
This seems totally insane to me. The lawsuit is arguing that directors not only have a fiduciary responsibility to shareholders to increase the value of their Meta holdings, but also of other stocks they may own.
The consequences of that line of thinking are scary. I'm sure the vast majority of shareholders of most US companies own ICE cars. If a company decides to put a lot of effort into, for example, cheaper batteries, could shareholders sue because the company is devaluing an asset most of them own?
This totally smells like a lawyer trying a random, BS theory in the hope that something "sticks" in order to make their mark.
- taneq 4y agoIt's like a Lotto winner suing Lotto because their other ticket lost.
- kmeisthax 4y agoAlternatively it could be an argumentum ad absurdum against the concept of shareholder primacy.
- jbombadil 4y ago> This seems totally insane to me. The lawsuit is arguing that directors not only have a fiduciary responsibility to shareholders to increase the value of their Meta holdings, but also of other stocks they may own. This is my thinking as well. If I own stock of Coca Cola and Pepsi. Coca Cola comes up with a great product that eats a huge amount of market from Pepsi. According to this I sue Coca Cola for my losses on the Pepsi stock?
- Kranar 4y agoI don't think this lawsuit has much merit, but the lawsuit is arguing against damages to an overall portfolio. If a diversified portfolio consisting of Coca Cola and Pepsi was on the whole damaged due to the actions of Coca Cola against Pepsi, then the plaintiffs argue that Coca Cola would be liable for some part of that damage. If, however, Coca Cola's actions harmed Pepsi specifically but benefited the overall portfolio, then no damages would be pursued. So Coca Cola is welcome to take market share from Pepsi so long as doing so is a net benefit to a diversified portfolio, as opposed to doing so in a way that harms a diversified portfolio.
- syrrim 4y agoIt's an interesting perspective. There's probably a sense in which overall improving a diversified portfolio maps to improving society or the economy as a whole, rather than harming society to make a dollar. So whereas the lawsuit likely has no grounds, it might actually be a good thing if this was the way things worked.
- dpatterbee 4y agoI think equating (or even correlating) the market value of some stocks with "improving society" is a pretty big reach.
- syrrim 4y agoAt the very least, it maps a lot more closely than does the market value of a single stock.
- donmcronald 4y agoThat’s insane! Imagine if a small company invented a cure for cancer. Would they be liable for the losses of all the pharmaceutical companies? It would be the end of innovation.
- chowells 4y agoNo, because they would present massive gains to every industry that loses employees to cancer. That's all of them, by the way. There would be no net loss, and innovation would continue to be rewarded. What would no longer be rewarded is parasitism.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoIf companies were that concerned about loosing employees, companies like deliveroo and amazon would not be destroying their health. Coal minin conoanies would not need health and safety regulation - they used to literally kill their workers
- zeckalpha 4y agoIf the decrease in value to Pepsi is less than the gains in Coca Cola, then yes, by the logic of this suit. However, I'd Coca Cola gains more than the loss to Pepsi, then no need to sue.
- socialismisok 4y agoThis is where capitalism naturally goes. Growth is the most important thing. We start to codify the expectation of growth into board responsibilities. Then we all accept that as normal. Once we've built the mental model there, it's not really that far to say they shouldn't hurt other companies if it costs them nothing.
- gregw134 4y agoExcept, we should want companies to compete with each other and eat each other's profits. Wars between companies are good for consumers.
- contravariant 4y agoCompetition is good, wars are only good if they don't end up producing a victor.
- yarg 4y agoIt also sounds like an intractable optimisation problem.
- pevey 4y agoI think what they are really trying to do here is come up with a legal theory that internalizes what economists call "externalities." One economic actor, in doing what is in its individual best interest, creates negative effects that may be much, much larger than the positive effects. We're not talking about Coke taking market share from Pepsi, which is analogy I saw elsewhere. A better analogy would be Company A that doubles its own profit by, say, destroying the public shared water source 5 other companies rely on, with total profits 10x the extra profits for Company A. So the overall portfolio effect of the actions is very negative. For many years, economists have just sort of accepted that externalities are a thing, and are bad, and there is not much you can do about them. By definition, you can't hold companies accountable for these costs. If you could, they would not be externalities. This suit is trying a new legal theory to change that. IANAL
- civilized 4y agoIt's nice that the lawyer may have good intentions, but the legal theory is still crackpot. I don't cheer for silly legal theories to prevail just because of good intentions. The unintended consequences of silly legal theories prevailing are likely to be higher than any good achieved in this one instance.
- pevey 4y agoI haven't given it a lot of thought, but I tend to agree with you. The sister comment to your comment (about AAPL and it's tracking/privacy changes and the effects on other companies) is a good example why. Some externalities may be realized as effects on other companies that may be part of a portfolio, but some may not be. For example, what about how users value their privacy? It's a very interesting legal approach, but that doesn't make it right. Externalities are very tricky.
- sam345 4y agoNormally the lawyers in these cases have one of either 2 motives - 1) idealogical (will pursue theses cases to push a political point so as to influence/intimidate others and to develop a political policy down the line) or 2) Financial. And if all things go well they get both done. Whether or not these intentions are good probably depends on whether you think freer markets should be allowed or not. Or whether they should be governed by idealogy pushing the money to one side of the political spectrum or another.
- mlazos 4y agoWhat you’re saying makes sense but I actually agree with the intent. They’re basically saying don’t destroy the government/society in the name of shareholder value. I feel like there should be a way to say this without saying “because our portfolio value!” But that’s the justification they want to try.
- sam345 4y agoAgreed. Totally insane - you might as well have the stock exchanges fold up and go home. What's the point in raising money in the capital markets if you are going to be subject to such silly lawsuits. Hopefully this will be thrown out quickly in the courts.
- divbzero 4y agoThe alleged harm caused by Meta may have a lot of merit, but the portfolio argument seems insane to me too. This line of reasoning suggests that companies have a fiduciary responsibility to avoid competing too hard against competitors because they share common owners. Anticompetitive effects have already been a concern due to common ownership by index funds [1] and would be exacerbated if this portfolio argument becomes a legal standard. [1]: https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2019/03/11/the-strategies-of-anticompetitive-common-ownership/ https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2019/03/11/the-strategies-of...