4 ms·
"The claim that diversity trumps ability is defeated in nearly every real world test." Completely false. C.f. The Wisdom of Crowds. The reasons why this is tru
by Alex3917 18y ago
"The claim that diversity trumps ability is defeated in nearly every real world test."
Completely false. C.f. The Wisdom of Crowds. The reasons why this is true aren't entirely clear, but empirical studies show that is true.
- AlexeyMK 18y agoDidn't like it, personally. The book cherry-picked examples to suit its thesis from the first page. Not that there isn't Wisdom in Crowds, but J.S didn't do himself any favors by picking and choosing facts. What would be interesting, would be to see some empirical research on a fascinating topic like this.
- Alex3917 18y agoI agree the book itself was pretty half baked, but I suspect the thesis is correct. He's not claiming that crowds are smarter than individuals all the time, only when four specific conditions are met. He relies too much on anecdotal evidence and not enough on the academic research, but in the end I found the core of the argument convincing, if not particularly well expressed. Maybe I'm not skeptical enough, I dunno.
- anamax 18y agoCrowds are wise when they go in multiple directions. When they do and someone stumbles upon something good, everyone gets to take advantage. And, if they don't agree, there's typically no penalty. And, there's usually no cost to folks wandering off. Organizations don't work like that.
- thras 18y agoReally? Read about the New York Police "Class of '39". It was the tail end of the depression, and the New York Police had 30,000 applicants for 300 positions. They decided to choose them based on an intelligence test. As a body, the 300 people chosen attained far higher status than average police officers. Four became police chiefs, four deputy commissioners, two chiefs of personnel, one chief inspector, and one commissioner of the New York Police Department. They had far few disciplinary penalties than average. But you are no doubt right, had NYC chosen them on the basis of "diversity" instead, things would have been much better.
- Alex3917 18y agoYou obviously haven't read the book since your example in no way relates to its argument...