3 ms·
> I dunno about dumb, but voters' views are rather less connected to reality than one might hope. What voters say is disconnected from reality, because the ave
by roenxi 4y ago
> I dunno about dumb, but voters' views are rather less connected to reality than one might hope.
What voters say is disconnected from reality, because the average voter has average skill at articulating their thoughts and usually only knows how to navigate their own social context. That voter is much more connected to reality than the typical academic, politician or professional though. Because they actually go out and do things in the real world.
You can tell by looking at what the polity does, it is often turns out in hindsight that it is quite an intelligent and practical beast. It is really hard to outdo a democracy when it comes to having a finger on the pulse of what is really going on.
It is a gross unfairness in politics that people so often deal with sound bite caricatures of their opponents rather than being forthright about what motivates their position.
- areoform 4y ago> That voter is much more connected to reality than the typical academic, politician or professional though. Because they actually go out and do things in the real world. I might be off-base here, but I am unsure if you have thought through the ramifications of your statements. What your statement seems to be implicitly saying is that, (a few examples) - Surgeons who stitch up gunshot wounds in ERs - Doctors & nurse practitioners who deliver care to communities across the US - Developers who write the critical code that runs airplanes - Scientists & engineers who do nanoscale fabrication - Environmental scientists embedded inside local communities, studying long-term environmental changes e.g. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/07/climate/climate-change-marine-science.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/07/climate/climate-change-ma... - Embedded anthropologists studying populations & subcultures in Iraq & Afghanistan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_Terrain_System https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_Terrain_System - Poets and artists living in these communities - Social scientists who study how rural Americans are used as a cheap workforce https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/people/mlg/ https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/people/mlg/ - Developers at Google & DDG writing the code that allows billions of people to do work every day - Scientists managing the US food supply and researching new ways to protect it, https://www.darpa.mil/news-events/2016-10-19 https://www.darpa.mil/news-events/2016-10-19 - Devs at companies like Stripe that power significant parts of the US economy Your text suggests that all of these people (and the millions more who aren't on the list) are less in tune with "reality" by default as compared to a random plumber or electrician. (I assume that you are referring to working class professions when you say "average voter") The text also says that they don't "go out and do things in the real world." It would be deeply wrong to assume that a random plumber or electrician is somehow lesser or incorrect by default. But it's also deeply wrong to say that the people who make important contributions that keep the lights of civilization on aren't somehow connected to reality by default.
- roenxi 4y agoThose are roughly the categories of people I was thinking of when I commented. You've put together a list of people who, by and large, are insulated from scarcity - people who either aren't going to have to do without, or are sufficiently confident in their position (academics and poets) that they don't think they need to work a conventional job. Frequently extreme specialists in a specific field that doesn't translate well into broad life experience. They don't have to live their lives in line with the resource constraints that the world works under. I'm an engineer, I know the perspective well. I'm part of the group of people keeping the lights on. And therefore there is nearly nothing out there that poses any sort of threat to my comfort, because society was built by and for people like me. That isn't an experience that matches up well with the typical experience and it would be very hard to spin as being exposed to 'reality'. I have access to disproportionate resources to solve my problems. And so do all the people you're listing.
- hackyhacky 4y agoI'm having some trouble understanding your perspective. Your original comment said: > That [average] voter is much more connected to reality than the typical academic, politician or professional though. Because they actually go out and do things in the real world. Now you're being more specific, saying those people who work outside "the real world," are those who are: > Frequently extreme specialists in a specific field that doesn't translate well into broad life experience. Why do you think that a fry cook or janitor has more "broad life experience" than a professor or a doctor? Do you think that there is something more "real" and "authentic" about manual labor, that intellectual labor lacks? Is scarcity the only source of authenticity? In my experience, most people a born into, and live their entire lives, in a single social stratum. Maybe it's abject poverty, maybe it's menial labor, maybe it's middle-class, or maybe it's educated and professional. The classes live in constant fear and envy of each other, but very few people get to experience more than of them first-hand. There's insulation, as you point out, between the strata, but that doesn't mean that the uneducated and the poor are experiencing more reality, just that they're experiencing it differently.
- 4y ago
- selestify 4y ago> You can tell by looking at what the polity does, it is often turns out in hindsight that it is quite an intelligent and practical beast. Could you provide any specific examples of that?
- roenxi 4y agoCompare the Chinese response to COVID to democracies like the US. In the US, the COVID pandemic response is basically history. In China, they are still locking places down and you can find videos of people literally fleeing the authorities [0]. This is the difference between a country where official policy is a bit behind the times vs a public that isn't particularly panicked and (correctly) identifies that the threat is minor and they need to get on with life. [0] https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-china-62547503 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-china-62547503