3 ms·
Data caps existing to prevent network congestion is a myth. Otherwise Xfinity would go down on the 1st of every month when all their users had fresh data allotm
by paxys 4y ago
Data caps existing to prevent network congestion is a myth. Otherwise Xfinity would go down on the 1st of every month when all their users had fresh data allotments and were using the service without any restrictions.
This model is simply an additional revenue stream for ISPs.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- wmf 4y agoI think the cap is intended to drive heavy users to change their behavior or switch to other ISPs.
- bombcar 4y agoThat would assume everyone hits the caps - I daresay they're high enough that 90% or so of users never hit them (I'm not capped so I don't know) - or they'd offer a good/better/best allocation. In the end you're trying to find a fair algorithm for "sharing" and any one you pick is going to have some ways in which it's unfair.
- joecool1029 4y ago> In the end you're trying to find a fair algorithm for "sharing" and any one you pick is going to have some ways in which it's unfair. This is already done for almost every other wireless carrier with QoS (QCI in this context). No need to cap the heavy users, just de-prioritize them if the spots are too congested. [1][2] (QCI parameters may vary by carrier and region equipment vendor.) I spend most of my month at QCI 9 but I live in a semi-rural area with a high capacity cell pointed at me, so deprioritization doesn't matter for me, I'm harming literally nobody using >1TB/mo. If my town threw some festival and I bogged down, I have the choice of either switching to a deprioritized line or driving to a non-congested cell. If they really have to hard cap it suggests they are either: 1. assholes or 2. built a poorly designed system that congests at more than the transponder spots. [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/NoContract/comments/tn4733/qci_level_explained_2022_march_lower_qci_is_better/ https://www.reddit.com/r/NoContract/comments/tn4733/qci_leve... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/QoS_Class_Identifier https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/QoS_Class_Identifier
- bombcar 4y agoOh you can bog down the uplinks for sure - even after you’re off the cell and on the landlines. Interconnects are getting better and better so fewer and fewer people run into it (and how much video bandwidth never even leaves the carriers local network with Netflix cache servers, etc).
- joecool1029 4y agoI forgot to mention but it is possible to saturate tower backhaul as well, this is the main secondary point of congestion. It usually sets the max physical throughput for the wireless spectrum on midband and mmwave deployments, however it is still a factor on some rural sites.
- pdappollonio 4y agoI provided consulting for a mobile carrier before. The reason why this doesn't happen is because once you do apply data caps, users often try to "not eat their entire allocation the first day" because otherwise they would lose internet halfway through the month. The same reason as to why you don't use your entire paycheque at the beginning of each month when it drops. Granted though, in terms of internet, this is not a detriment (at least not enough) to think you won't have internet by the end of the month. But that'd the thinking behind caps, that people would even out their usage through the month.
- supertrope 4y agoVerizon switched from low cap cellular plans (2 GB) to unlimited*. The network is much more congested now that people don't think twice about streaming video. *The normal plan gets deprioritized after a threshold. The cheap plan is always low priority. The super duper plan is never deprioritized but video throughput is capped.
- bombcar 4y agoAs a note that type of prioritization would have been prohibited by most net neutrality rules.
- Whatarethese 4y agoMaybe with the 22 billion in net income they raked in in 2021 they could upgrade their gear and give customers what they want.
- windexh8er 4y agoVery little of the streaming video you describe is off-net for any of the carriers. They run caching servers within their network at major POPs. The network isn't congested because of said video because it's already downsampled content specifically for mobile streaming. Video streaming on any of these carrier networks consumed by your phone or tablet is curated for mobile devices and doesn't impact their Internet connectivity at all. Very little of that traffic will ever egress the carrier's network. Ultimately the congestion is all oversubscription of the spectrum allocated to the tower you're connecting to.
- Bilal_io 4y agoWhile I agree with you. It's important to point out not every customer's plan starts at the 1st of the month.