3 ms·
Fake reviews are not the only problem. It's the fact that most reviews are going to either be from someone who loved the product enough to take the time to writ
by insane_dreamer 4y ago
Fake reviews are not the only problem. It's the fact that most reviews are going to either be from someone who loved the product enough to take the time to write about, or had such a bad experience (which could be anything and maybe not related to the problem) that they feel compelled to write about. So you wind up with 5-stars and 1-stars and not much inbetween.
- hcurtiss 4y agoIt seems like this is a thesis that could be tested empirically. It makes intuitive sense to me, but if I’m honest, that kind of inverted bell is not what I actually see very often on Amazon.
- r00fus 4y agoAmazon has a lot of paid-for reviews, so you would likely see it if you remove the paid entries. In some cases on very bad products, you see tons of 5 star reviews and a lot of 1 star reviews - and if it's high on the fakespot list, I can only conclude it's a bad product. I've mostly given up on Amazon except where I can't find the product elsewhere (or on time).
- tracker1 4y agoI still use amazon a lot.. but not always reviews... often I know the product I'm looking for. I'll also tend to look at the negative reviews.. are the reviewers just not knowledgeable about what they bought, broke in shipping, or actually a bad product/seller. It will vary a bit. What sucks, is competitors will pay for bad reviews too.
- insane_dreamer 4y agoI have not done any systematic check, but I often see this type of inverted curve in product reviews. -- Though either the 5-star side or the 1-star side will be significantly higher than the other.
- taeric 4y agoI'd go farther with this thought experiment. As long as the reviews are done by consumers that are not trained or practiced at the art of reviewing, you will expect a lot of "worked for me" and "I paid enough that I am compelled to like this" style reviews. It is literally the idea behind luxury pricing. Turns out, objective reviewing of items is difficult. And will almost certainly lead to a gaming of the reviews if the companies are able to do so.
- tracker1 4y agoI'm more inclined to review if it's a technical product and there aren't already (many) quality reviews, good or bad. It's really hard picking certain items from the pack, and sometimes unless you already know, you have no idea.
- bluGill 4y agoMost people don't try all the alternatives and so they have no idea if this is good or not. You buy something, it seems to work so cognitive dissonance won't let you give it less than 5 stars as that implies you didn't choose the best. I really want someone try independently try then all, but that is expensive and a lot of work so few do.