3 ms·
I've had two fairly detailed, not low-effort, reviews not approved for publication on Amazon.co.uk recently. After the first I swore I'd never bother again (it
by OJFord 4y ago
I've had two fairly detailed, not low-effort, reviews not approved for publication on Amazon.co.uk recently. After the first I swore I'd never bother again (it was pretty high-effort to be honest, relatively) but something got the better of me.
Neither time has there been any indication of what the problem is (I guessed the first one was my reference to a 'knob', as in for turning, which the product had - but couldn't find any such similar Scunthorpe in the second) and even if they did give you some idea, they invite you to start again from scratch - not edit it, it's not saved, not even your photos. I'd love to see click-through metrics on that, does anyone bother?
- jersak 4y agoI had the same experience. Id say they just don't approve most of the reviews. I would think most (real) people only leave a good review when things go EXTREMELY WELL. Not the same for bad reviews though, which means real people will more often than not leave reviews pointing problems and shortcomings than praising a product. That, at least in my head, would result in less sales and so making the review workflow painful for the user is by design.
- sokoloff 4y agoI just checked on my account and I have 126 published reviews on Amazon. I can recall around 10 that were denied, about half of which seemed "OK, that's fair in retrospect" and a modest edit and resubmit got them published. The other half of the denies I couldn't really figure out and just ignored (some of which were solid product, 4 or 5 star reviews). I have several 1-star reviews among the published.
- heavyset_go 4y agoAmazon banned me from leaving reviews entirely after I left a couple of negative reviews for products I bought.
- xxs 4y agoI don't leave 1/2 star reviews in general, pretty much every single review has been approved. 5 stars almost never given, either. It was sort of surprising amazon rejects reviews - the more you know. Only 30% being fake seems like a very low estimate