3 ms·
Figure 9 looks dire: 95% of mortgage (by total value, not count) are going to have their rates adjusted in the next three years; 56% in the next year. In the U
by hedora 4y ago
Figure 9 looks dire: 95% of mortgage (by total value, not count) are going to have their rates adjusted in the next three years; 56% in the next year.
In the US, that'd definitely lead to a housing crisis worse than 2008. Is there something different about how houses are purchased in NZ?
- twelvechairs 4y agoUS has 30 year mortgages backed by government. New Zealand and Australia do not so the overwhelming number are either floating/variable or fixed for 1-5 years.
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoThe US and Belgium are the only countries in the world with a government subsidized 30-year fixed rate AFAIK.
- voisin 4y agoHow are they backed by government differently than say in Canada where CMHC backs most mortgages?
- bombcar 4y agohttps://www.freddiemac.com/about https://www.freddiemac.com/about and friends buy mortgages that meet certain requirements (called "conforming" loans) and package and sell them to investors. Since they will buy 30 year fixed loans, banks are willing to sell them, and investors are willing to buy the subsequent bonds created out of them because they're (likely) almost as reliable as 30 year treasuries from the US government itself. If you try to get a 30 year fixed loan outside of the US mortgage market, it's hard to find with rates as low. CMHC may not buy fixed rate loans in the same way.
- jemmyw 4y agoMortgages in NZ are typically fixed for between 1 and 5 years, with most fixing around 3 years. So 95% of mortgages will always be rate adjusted in the next 3 years.
- voisin 4y agoSame as Canada. I assumed it was market forces but no, it is regulated this way! Seems like a bizarre plan to make your populace less resilient to rate fluctuations.
- bombcar 4y agoThe US weirdness of 30 year fixed-rate loans that the customer can call at anytime and the bank can never call except for non-performance is substantially subsidized by the US Government. Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae or whatever they are/were take those mortgages and basically convert them into government bonds that are then sold out. Otherwise getting 2% for 30 years would be nearly impossible (and it IS impossible in many countries).
- Negitivefrags 4y agoIt makes the banking system more resilient to rate fluctuations..
- michael1999 4y agoHow do you mean it is regulated this way? RBC lists a 25-year fixed right now - https://www.rbcroyalbank.com/mortgages/mortgage-rates.html#posted-rates https://www.rbcroyalbank.com/mortgages/mortgage-rates.html#p.... It isn't competitive (9.75% vs 6.2% on a 5 year), but it's there.
- voisin 4y agoWoah, that’s strange. I just bought a house and the mortgage guy I was dealing with said anything more than 7 years is prohibited in Canada unless you go to an unregulated B-lender. Clearly I stand corrected!
- michael1999 4y agoI don’t know if they actually sell a 25, or just post a rate for some other reason. But I know I locked in for 10 my first contract.
- throwaway788 4y agoThe banks are required to stress test those loans with somewhat stringent requirements. When the loans were granted they take the current retail interest and add around 3% and ensure that the loan recipient could still afford it. Last year there were stories in the NZ media around how banks were not writing loans because people were spending too much on Uber Eats etc. They were going over finances with a fine-toothed comb (there was a bit of backlash in the media, but turns out it was a good thing). NZ banks have quite a high capital reserve buffer requirement which was increased by the Reserve Bank of New Zealand a few years ago – with a lot of pushback from the banks at the time.
- vosper 4y agoThis is correct, and also wages are rising faster than inflation. Very very few households with mortgages are actually at risk of defaulting (so low the number is essentially zero), and both banks and households can sustain higher interest rates than we're seeing. Much more info (with numbers and charts) in Bernard Hickey's post from a few days ago. https://thekaka.substack.com/p/incomes-are-rising-faster-than-prices?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email#details https://thekaka.substack.com/p/incomes-are-rising-faster-tha...
- Atsuii 4y agoI know from family in NZ that the stress test banks apply is very similar to stress test we apply in Australia. As of the latest rate rise, rates are now above what banks were required to stress test for at the lowest rate loaned in 2021. I imagine New Zealand is reaching that number as well. For 90% of households this won’t matter as they purchased pre 2020/2021 so they were means test for higher rates but for households who took loans on during Covid they could theoretically really struggle when their fixed rates are up.
- loeg 4y ago> Is there something different about how houses are purchased in NZ? The US government subsidizes long term fixed-rate mortgages as a matter of policy. This is not true in most other countries, including, apparently, New Zealand.
- exhilaration 4y agoI've read comments on Hacker News that adjustable rate mortgages are the rule rather than the exception in many countries (outside of the U.S.). Here's a comment saying that Canada ONLY does ARMs https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15185052 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15185052 and another comment saying that they're very common in some European countries: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30339845 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30339845. I'm guessing this is how it is in New Zealand.
- mig39 4y agoCanada does both adjustable-rate and fixed-rate mortgages. Just that we tend to do it for shorter periods. Typically 5 or 10 years. I have two fixed-rate mortgages with really low rates. They won't come up for renewal until 4 years from now. Then I'll have to choose whether to do another 5 years with the current rate, or convert over to an adjustable rate.
- subarctic 4y agoCanada doesn't have the concept of fixed-rate mortgages like in the US though, which is where the rate is fixed for the entire life of the mortgage. What you are describing is an adjustable-rate mortgage with an initial 5 year fixed-rate term, which in the US would be called a 5/1 ARM.
- rufus_foreman 4y agoIn the US a mortgage with a rate that resets after 5 years would be considered an adjustable rate mortgage, although the rate would typically reset yearly after the initial 5 years (a 5/1 ARM). A mortgage that ends after 5 years and needs to be renewed would be considered a balloon mortgage, and they are rare in the US. They are "non-qualified" mortgages which means the government sponsored entities won't buy them, so there is a limited secondary market and they have much higher rates. I don't think I would sleep great at night knowing that every 5 years I would need to either get a new mortgage loan or lose my house.
- ameminator 4y ago
- robocat 4y agoIn New Zealand, all mortgages are approximately at a floating interest rate. You can lock in a rate for up to 5 years (with the majority choosing 1 or 2 years), but after that “fixed” period completes, you now renew your interest rate at whatever the current market is. Most mortgages are signed up for a term of decades (mine is 30 years, and I signed up at age 50), so although you might use “fixed” rates for a few years each, you end up with a stepwise approximation to the floating rate. My mortgage allows me to pay 20% more principal each month, which shortens to term to 20 years. You can renegotiate terms, and you can cancel a fixed 5 year rate early, but the bank charges a fee, and the fee depends on how valuable the current terms are to the bank (they cover any downside risk to them). If you change mortgage terms, and it turns out the bank is “in the money”, they don’t pay you (they just pocket the profit).
- AlgorithmicTime 4y ago
- r00fus 4y agoHere in the US we have ARMs (adjustable rate mortgages) - usually they are rated by (fixed period/stepping rate) - the most common being a 5/1 ARM = 5y fixed + adjustable rate reset every year. So is it the case that in NZ, if you refinance your mortgage, you typically get charged a significant fee?
- mdasen 4y agoWe do have ARMs in the US, but fixed mortgages are a lot more popular - presumably because they allow someone to know how much it's going to cost.
- Atsuii 4y agoI can’t speak exactly for NZ but I assume it’s similar to Australia; it is normal to get charged a discharge fee from the bank your leaving and there maybe an establishment fee at the bank your refinancing with, along with another small cost to change the official register of state government. This could all amount to a couple of thousand dollars every time you refinance.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- coliveira 4y agoThis is certainly bad, but if it will lead to a crisis like 2008 in the USA, depends on a number of factors. First, there was a lot of leverage and fraud in the US case. Then, there was lack of financial support for families that had no option other than default on their mortgages. The US government didn't anticipate the issues caused by ARMs and only dealt with the problem when it was already clear the total collapse of the mortgage industry.
- chrisco255 4y agoDid they even really do anything with ARMs? I thought they were just flushed out with all the foreclosures that happened after '08. And then they just fell out of favor.