3 ms·
I once ranted loudly that governments should be doing this for free. That governments should be assembling the best team of pentesters to pentest everything the
by Waterluvian 4y ago
I once ranted loudly that governments should be doing this for free. That governments should be assembling the best team of pentesters to pentest everything they can possibly find within their jurisdiction.
I love seeing this.
- godelski 4y agoI've also ranted about this, and how it should be one of the NSA's top priorities (including doing it for our allies). It's interesting because there are two main methods for what to do when you find a vulnerability: 1) hold onto it so you can later use it as a weapon or 2) disclose it and patch it. The offensive method has problems because as soon as you use it you are disclosing it. It also has the issue that your enemies may be able to (are likely to) find the same vulnerability and exploit it first. But the second method means you're losing your weapons but instead gaining a shield. As I see it, the shield is a lot bigger and has far higher utility. But part of that is that I see democracies as having differing vulnerabilities than autocracies. Attacking autocracies is more spear phishing, very directed attacks on the specific people that control power. But attacking democracies is in some sense easier (and in another sense harder) because more power is held by the average person. People who are more vulnerable to manipulation, especially at the large scale. But now we're edging into the data privacy domain and that's probably out of scope here. I really think there should be a very strong blue team effort by these organizations. I am okay holding on to a specific vulnerability if you're going to attack a specific person in the ,,immediate'' future, but these agencies should also be working with companies to patch these vulnerabilities. That is the government providing a social good. You know, the reason we have the social contract and government in the first place.
- Waterluvian 4y agoThis just made me think of something I need to look up now. Allied nations regularly perform war games for practice. What about cyber war games?
- godelski 4y agoLet me know the answer. Because I feel like that should definitely be part of it. Though there's some very concerning aspects of lack of defense for national infrastructure things like power grids. So I doubt it is being taken seriously, or as seriously as it should be. I really do think a country should be proactively red teaming its own infrastructure and repairing any holes it finds. But it doesn't seem like the best interest of people who are more focused on offensive techniques.
- YurgenJurgensen 4y agoThe "disclose or weaponise" question gets very easy when, say, all of your adversaries are using Chinese software and all of your allies are using American software.
- dannyw 4y agoIs OpenSSL Chinese or American?
- TheNewsIsHere 4y agoYes.
- godelski 4y agoIs Intel Chinese or American? iPhones? Android?
- RajT88 4y agoYes. Because when private individuals or companies do it unbidden, lawsuits fly in order to save face. When you are found out by the government, you're going to think really carefully about frivolous lawsuits to save face.