3 ms·
> The affected model years are 2005 to 2010. Genuine question, how does it take 17 years to figure out the air bags are defective because they explode with too
by crazygringo 4y ago
> The affected model years are 2005 to 2010.
Genuine question, how does it take 17 years to figure out the air bags are defective because they explode with too much force?
I'm just surprised -- it makes sense to me when product recalls happen within a few weeks/months. But nearly two decades, I can't quite wrap my head around. What was observed now that wasn't being observed previously, and why only now?
- tablespoon 4y ago> I'm just surprised -- it makes sense to me when product recalls happen within a few weeks/months. But nearly two decades, I can't quite wrap my head around. What was observed now that wasn't being observed previously, and why only now? Have you ever worked on a system with a ten-year-old bug (determined by looking at source history to find when it was introduced), but that was only recently discovered? Lots of problems only manifest in very rare circumstances and/or are difficult to diagnose. Another possibility is the effects of aging weren't properly predicted. Maybe the airbags functioned properly when now, but after 10+ years, something changed causing some of them to malfunction.
- mrguyorama 4y agoTakata made the change that caused all these problems (switching to a less stable over time explosive compound) to save a few cents. Their chemical engineers noted that this was a likely issue, and they were ignored. Takata then learned this was happening, and continued to ignore, suppress, and claim that each time it happened was an isolated incident, and did not cooperate with investigators. Basically a company being a company.
- crazygringo 4y agoThanks, got it -- that's very helpful. So in other words, this wasn't an issue about it taking this long to discover -- it was an issue about being actively suppressed. That makes much more sense.
- ehzy 4y agoIt's not really even just that. It takes time for the compound in the airbag inflator to become unstable. Years, in fact. It's not a defect that's immediately apparent.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]