3 ms·
The scroll bar is a surprisingly large component. It's bigger than any button. It's bigger than most text boxes. And most of the time, you're not looking at it.
by jfengel 4y ago
The scroll bar is a surprisingly large component. It's bigger than any button. It's bigger than most text boxes. And most of the time, you're not looking at it.
That's why designers don't like it. It's just an unbalanced use of pixels. It's visual clutter.
Unfortunately, none of the alternatives are great, either. The thin ones are hard to use when you do want them. Making them appear and disappear is distracting. Some applications make use of the space (letters in a long alphabetical list suggesting where to scroll, error indicators in an editor), but it's nonstandard and not always applicable.
So designers keep looking for better alternatives. Ideally, you do away with scrolling, but that's not always feasible.
- marginalia_nu 4y ago> The scroll bar is a surprisingly large component. It's bigger than any button. It's bigger than most text boxes. And most of the time, you're not looking at it. That's why designers don't like it. It's just an unbalanced use of pixels. It's visual clutter. Is there really a shortage of screen space? Scroll bars were introduced on like 14" monitors with a 640x480 resolution. Wasn't a problem then. Why is it we're running out of pixels on a 42" 4K monitor? I just don't understand why interfaces must be invisible. If anything, a scroll bar provides contextual clues as to what sort of an interface you are looking at. It's something that can be scrolled. It also lets you know where it begins and ends, neither pieces of information are rarely obvious with contemporary GUIs. Don't underestimate the power of design conventions in making an interface intuitive.