3 ms·
I've proposed on HN multiple times that home HVAC systems could have a "battery" that consisted of an insulated box of rocks. It could be heated or cooled durin
by WalterBright 4y ago
I've proposed on HN multiple times that home HVAC systems could have a "battery" that consisted of an insulated box of rocks. It could be heated or cooled during periods when renewable energy is cheap, and used as a heat source/sink the rest of the time. This idea was regularly ridiculed.
I'm glad to see someone thinks it isn't so stupid :-)
- bilsbie 4y agoThere’s low hanging fruit like that everywhere. In this case I think new home builders are really conservative with trying new things due to the high price of houses and strict building codes. And even though it’s a simple idea it’s the kind of thing HVAC companies would be happy to Charge you 20K for. Just like geothermal.
- crazygringo 4y agoJudging from other comments here, it seems like that's not an economic solution for storing electricity -- only for storing heat. And I suppose it's really not so different from simply having a hot water heater like so many homes do? That you could program to only add more water to when electricity is cheapest? (And in-floor heating uses hot water pipes.) But hot water tanks are very safe, they're only 60°C. I would think that 600°C sand (or rocks) is the kind of thing that's not particularly safe to have inside your home. That's really, really hot. Have you done the math and figured out how many rocks a home would need, how much insulation, and so whether it's even viable in theory, setting aside practical engineering/safety concerns?
- WalterBright 4y agoIt's for storing heat (and cold). > Have you done the math and figured out how many rocks a home would need, how much insulation, and so whether it's even viable in theory, setting aside practical engineering/safety concerns? No. But why wouldn't it be viable? And what could be cheaper than a box of rocks? No moving parts, other than a fan your HVAC system has anyway.
- crazygringo 4y agoGood luck storing much cold. While you can add 580°C to get the rocks to 600°C... I'd like see you subtract even 300°C. ;) > But why wouldn't it be viable? Because it would take up too much space at non-dangerous temperatures? Or would set your house on fire if compactly sized?
- Schroedingersat 4y agoWater is much better by mass, and your heat pump will only work well at temperatures where it's a liquid. With a 30 degree delta in a system that uses 1MWh/month you could store 2 months of heat/cold in a 5mx5mx2m tank.
- kwhitefoot 4y agoYou can already use a ground source heat pump to do this.
- hedora 4y agoCheck out slab on grade foundations. They do what you are describing, by moving the air in your house towards the average temperature (cooling during the day, warming at night, usually). Sadly, they use a lot of concrete, so they have high embedded carbon.
- tuatoru 4y agoThis basic idea (thermal mass energy storage) is perfectly sensible, and has a long history. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trombe_wall https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trombe_wall Coupled with a well designed ventilation system, a Trombé wall can also be used for cooling.
- philjohn 4y agoI mean, that's just a more advanced version of storage heaters in the UK that "charge" on Economy 7 tarrif (late evening and overnight, cheaper per kwh) then radiate heat the next day.
- simon_000666 4y agoCheck out these guys : https://sunamp.com/hot-water-thermino-overview/ https://sunamp.com/hot-water-thermino-overview/ Basically commercial version of a box of rocks.