3 ms·
It comes across very arrogant to me, including this statement "VC funded yadayada". Given that other people here are saying that only YC funded companies can p
by Mz 15y ago
It comes across very arrogant to me, including this statement "VC funded yadayada".
Given that other people here are saying that only YC funded companies can post a job ad here, maybe it's a "yeah, you knew that already, let's not waste any more time on that stuff" type sentiment. Of course, there are other people saying they didn't know that, so perhaps the main sin they are committing is assuming that the audience is as "in the know" as they are -- ie they are assuming everyone on HN is as aware as they are of how all this ties back to YC, only that's not an accurate assumption.
It's often really tough to figure out how to make sure you are including enough information to inform your audience without including so much as to insult their intelligence. This becomes more complicated as audience size and diversity grows and HN is quite heavily trafficked these days. Perhaps it is better for this company to write the ad so as to not insult the intelligence of the more in-the-know types who realize the ads here are only from YC funded companies than to over-explain. It may be better to offend and alienate the relatively "clueless" than to insult the intelligence of the types of people they hope will actually apply. I mean if someone not in the know concludes they are arrogant pricks and "I wouldn't want to work there", hey, probably no loss. It might even be saving them wasted time (by reducing the number of applications from clueless people). But talking to the highly qualified like they are uninformed 5 year olds who need everything explained, well, there goes your best potential candidates. Good luck filling it now.
- alexwolfe 15y agoRegardless of how "In the know" you are, I doubt your going to feel awesome sending your cover, full resume, and project to HugeMeme@gmail.com
- Mz 15y agoI'm not saying they got it right. Just that there may be another explanation for the specific line that was being criticized as "arrogant". That struck a chord with me because of how often I get accused of arrogance. I don't think I am arrogant. If you really are dramatically better at something than other people, owning that fact is a socially uncomfortable but somewhat unavoidable part of life. (If you try to say "no, no, I'm nothing special" when you really are that much better, that gets called "false modesty" and people heap flack on you for that as well. Damned if you do, damned if you don't.)
- alexwolfe 15y agoYah, I appreciated your explanation there were definitely some good points and you probably hit the nail on the head of what they were trying to achieve. They didn't come across to me as arrogant either, just unprofessional. Doesn't make them horrible in any way just makes the job posting not the most appealing in my eyes.
- Mz 15y agoThey didn't come across to me as arrogant either, just unprofessional. I left out additional thoughts that they sounded "young" to me, which fits with your assessment (of "unprofessional"). So they're a tad green. They're a startup aren't they? <shrug> Peace.
- redguava 15y agoI think it would be naive to assume "person that knows all about hacker news" = "great candidate". It could be argued spending too much time on hacker news is not what you want in your employees. Back to the main point, the real issue I have is they are too busy to write an informative job post actually encouraging people to apply, to me that isn't respectful of your audience. They wan't someone to join and be a part of their team, do they really want to start the conversation like this.
- Mz 15y agoIt could be argued spending too much time on hacker news is not what you want in your employees. That doesn't really make sense to me, personally. Check the leader board. Almost everyone on it appears to be an extremely competent hacker. (Though I think at least one is an extremely competent lawyer.) I personally generally hate job listings. I think they all make little sense. I work for a large company and I find the job postings there completely unfathomable. It's one of the reasons I am still stuck in an entry level job: The job board at the company I actually work for is almost completely illegible to me. The last job I applied for I only applied because a senior manager clued me it was a job on her team and encouraged me to apply. I didn't get it but I at least had some fucking clue where it was, who it was with and what it entailed, information I cannot ferret out from the official postings. (Note: I still didn't know what it paid, information I would have liked to have.) I think most job postings completely suck. Is this worse suckitude? I don't really know. I just don't think there is any reason to conclude that it sucks "because they are arrogant".