3 ms·
Anecdotal evidence is not helpful when trying to evaluate an economy. For that matter, an economy is always too complicated to usefully describe in a single wo
by jfengel 4y ago
Anecdotal evidence is not helpful when trying to evaluate an economy.
For that matter, an economy is always too complicated to usefully describe in a single word. They come up with broad terms like "recession" and give them rigorous definitions in order to get some kind of handle on it, but it doesn't reflect everybody's experience. In fact, it may not reflect anybody's experience: some will do worse, and some will do better.
The definition is "less total stuff getting done". Measuring "stuff" is already hard; defining how much "less" constitutes something to be worried about is even harder.
One common definition is "Two straight quarters of declining GDP". GDP isn't a great metric, but at least it's consistent-ish.
The US had one declining quarter of GDP, at the end of last year, and it's been up ever since. Europe as a whole has not had any negative quarters, though a few countries have.
GDP isn't a great metric, and others use a more complicated metric trying to get at how people and businesses feel: the price of goods, how much they earn, etc. GDP is supposed to be the aggregate of all that, but aggregates are misleading, in the same sense as "Mark Zuckerberg in a room full of poor people means billionaires on average". Sometimes it's useful; sometimes it isn't.
It's clear that inflation is up; that's good for some people (like people who owe debts, and can now sell their goods for more money to pay off those debts) and bad for others (those with money in the bank). None of it is where economists want it to be -- even the low unemployment figures mean something is off kilter. (Too many people employed means that people who would otherwise be doing something like training or hobbies or retired are dragged into working for some reason.)
In other words... the economy is what it is. If you're doing OK, fantastic. Others are not. Others are doing better. Overall, it's not a crisis, but worrying. There are signs that it will improve, as we get past the pandemic and start to treat the Ukraine war as a baseline rather than a downturn.
Does that help clarify at all? Or just make it more confusing?
- samstave 4y agoSerious Q: what % of the GDP is silcon valley/tech-market? vs the fraudulent financial market?
- jfengel 4y agoRight now, US Tech is about $1.3 trillion, out of a total GDP of $23 trillion. It's pretty consistently about 10% of GDP. Enough to have a noticeable effect: a 1% decline in GDP is an enormous deal, so if one imagined a 10% layoff through the tech industry it would be a real crisis. It's not that bad, of course. It would be more worrying if it were an indicator of broader employment issues. Instead it seems to be specific to the Silicon Valley business cycle: a lot of growth with more hiring than really necessary, followed by an outsized contraction.
- samstave 4y agobut if 50% of twitter employees are cut, regardless of role, where will they go? you have skilled employees (3500) actual people suddenly looking for work and likely in a small area of circumference...
- jfengel 4y agoMaybe nowhere. But since total US unemployment is 6 million, it's not a big deal in the context of "national recession". I get the impression that it's unlikely that Twitter employees will remain unemployed long in Silicon Valley, unless they want to take an extended break. Lots of places are looking to hire. It may be a step down, but right now unemployment just isn't a national issue. (Six million total unemployed sounds like a lot, but economists expect about 4% of the ~200 million American workers to be unemployed at any moment due to the inevitable friction of people not finding jobs instantly.)
- samstave 4y agoSure, but I am wondering how many of those employees are actually in the bay area... FB is flailing, Goog is a nightmare to get hired at, as is Apple (because of their corp egos)... (ive been here and in industry for 26 years, I know these companies DNA well... they are age-ist egomaniacs... so if you dump 3500 twitter workers on the streets os san francisco... thats going to be a tough market. and with the likelihood that many are renters, in one of the most expensive cities in the US, outcomes will be grief. Musk better give a good severance for the careers he's abt to kill - because he can afford to do so.
- mxuribe 4y ago> ...and others use a more complicated metric trying to get at how people and businesses feel... Yeah, agreed, but i wonder how much of what will happen is more self-fulfilling prophecy, where a critical mass amount of people "feel lousy", and hence unconsciously push all sets of invisible levers of the economy which push the world/countires/companies into something closer to a recession. I'm going to call the global economy the "mopey teen economy"...because even if things are not "that bad", the consensus will make everyone feel like things are not so great. ;-)
- jfengel 4y agoIn the 1970s, Jimmy Carter got hammered for saying that. The threat is nearly invisible in ordinary ways. It is a crisis of confidence. It is a crisis that strikes at the very heart and soul and spirit of our national will. We can see this crisis in the growing doubt about the meaning of our own lives and in the loss of a unity of purpose for our nation. The situation was worse then, but oil played a huge part in both. It wasn't just malaise. A key input had gone up, causing genuine inflation, regardless of monetary policy. (The solution in the 1980s was a massive expansion of government debt, with the same expansion of the money supply as the Fed could do with low rates.) As always, there is a lot of politics: some people want the economy to feel bad, others don't. Today we have a lot more vigorous public square holding the same old discussions.
- taolegal 4y ago> causing genuine inflation There's something obfuscatory about calling this inflation instead of what it fundamentally is: scarcity. I get that inflation means a price rise, but inflation is (or should be) fundamentally about monetary policy (devaluing money) rather than supply and demand.
- jfengel 4y agoThe term predates monetarism. It means price rises of all kinds. It's difficult enough to condense prices into a single measure without distinguishing what causes what. All the economists want for that term is to say, "Here is a standard basket of goods, and here is the average price paid for it." Even that much is hard enough to do that it requires a government bureau to do the calculation. It would add extra confusion to redefine the term "inflation" to refer solely to price changes caused by monetary policy rather than supply or demand. Economists are likely to continue to use the term to mean what they've meant by it for over a century.
- willsmith72 4y ago> Too many people employed means that people who would otherwise be doing something like training or hobbies or retired are dragged into working for some reason Is this right? I'm sure I was taught the labour force figure used in calculating unemployment figures doesn't include people like this
- jfengel 4y agoYou're correct, and I got ahead of myself. I got it right(er) in a sub-comment later. Economists expect a certain number of people to be looking for jobs and not finding them because they don't match what their local market needs. It's friction. If the rate dips too low, it suggests that employers are digging too deeply to find anybody, probably by raising salaries, and risks unbalancing the rest of the economy.