4 ms·
> Z-library were in it for commercial gain (you could access a certain number of books but to get more you had to pay for a subscription). They started out as a
by bawolff 4y ago
> Z-library were in it for commercial gain (you could access a certain number of books but to get more you had to pay for a subscription). They started out as a fork of library genesis, whose mission has always been strictly non-commercial and about providing free access to everyone without limits.
Ick.
I'm sympathetic to piracy, but the moment people start to make money off of pirated works it starts to feel much more wrong.
- 1dry 4y ago
- hdjjhhvvhga 4y agoPersonally, I use libgen to check if I actually want a given book, and if I do, I buy it (a physical copy, if possible). So, for me, it's a kind of a virtual bookshop.
- 1dry 4y agoThat's great of you to buy the book as well, major kudos. I would bet most are not as altruistic as you. Do not traditional libraries and their ebook lending systems, however inconvenient, provide the same service? All one needs to do is be patient until the book you are interested in becomes available. In the meantime, maybe you can check out a different book that is available that you might not have discovered otherwise!
- zolland 4y agoWhat is the difference between me waiting for a single book at my library to be passed between 5 people, and me just reading it online?
- beermonster 4y agoPresumably the library paid for their copy? [Edit] Also check out OverDrive / Libby
- bheadmaster 4y agoThe library would've paid for the copy regardless of whether or not the person actually borrowed the book - the act of borrowing itself makes no difference.
- nihilius 4y agoI do the same, i live in germany and wanted a book from UK, sadly it has 4-5 weeks delivery time but our vacation was a week away. So i downloaded the book, read it on our vacation and had the physical copy a few weeks later deliverd. Later i bought the book a second time when the german version released. With another book i bought for my wife and wanted to read at the same time, i downloaded it and we could both read it and talk about it simultaneously. Some other time i wanted to read a book at home with a physical copy and on my kindle during some time when i was outside in the garden. Cause in a hammock the kindle is easier to hold. Every time i had purchased the physical copy and the illegal download was just for convenience. No harm done.
- wardedVibe 4y agoI just want a copy of the thing I paid for that I can use on whatever machine in whatever way I want without a bunch of bullshit hoops
- 1dry 4y ago
- wardedVibe 4y agoOh I also buy a physical copy, especially if they're relatively obscure. I'm the kind of yahoo who also donates to artists patreons.
- primax 4y agoI don't accept that I need to purchase the same work several times for them to be able to eke out a living. Especially given the price of many books.
- joshxyz 4y agoi pirated mp3 files back then, is ed sheeran living under a bridge now? if youre worried about artists and authors, you got no idea how much cut publishing houses and music labels take from them.
- rndgermandude 4y agoArtists - just like inventors etc - should be compensated for their work, but in my humble opinion not in what has become now essentially perpetuity. So, an artist eeking out a living on something they worked hard on and released a month ago or two years ago gets sympathy from me. An artist who released a thing 20 years ago and still wants to eek out a living off that, such an artist doesn't really have my sympathy. The great-grandchildren who want to get paid for something an ancestor released 120 years ago[0]? Hell no, go do something yourself to make money. If you're Lars Ulrich in 2000 and sue Napster over songs you released 10-20 years ago, while sitting on a net worth of maybe around 100-200M USD (now 350M), then my sympathy is with the pirates. This doesn't touch the issue of how a lot of artists are not making much money, not because of pirates but because of predatory music labels and publishing houses. It also ignores the problems with the "lost sales" theory. A lot of the pirates would have never paid for stuff they downloaded in the first place. And a lot of pirates started paying after pirating some stuff. E.g. I remember discovering a lot of artists from songs I illegally copied on LAN parties back in the day[1], usually artists too small to be on a lot of rotation on radio and MTV (yes, MTV used to have music, crazy) which I probably would have never known about otherwise. And I gave lots of money to these artists, buying their CDs, going to their concerts when possible, and so on. In the same vein, I discovered artists on whatcd and similar pirate places later on. And doesn't touch on the "please take my money" issue... There are a lot of things that are out of print, etc, that you cannot pay for. E.g. large companies holding licenses to content may even take works out of print deliberately in tax avoiding schemes - I am not a Hollywood accountant, but from my limited understanding they can declare a loss when doing so which is worth a lot more in tax reduction than keeping a title in print. And it also doesn't even touch humanity's need to preserve important cultural artifacts for the future. [0] Remember, up to artists death + 70 years copyright term. While this exact scenario has probably not happened yet, as these rules are too new, you get a glimpse of what will happen in the future when you look about all the legal fighting still happening over Sherlock Holmes - a figure and body of worked created mostly before copyright law even existed. [1] Yes, I am old. If you have no idea what a LAN party is, it's basically a bunch of people actually meeting in some venue with their computers, wire everything together into a temporary LAN, to play games and swap files, which back in the day really was the only sane way to do mulitplayer and filesharing stuff as internet speeds were so limited, and internet was usually very expensive, often still paying by the minute.
- bheadmaster 4y agoBecause digital copyright is artificial scarcity.
- 1dry 4y agoWhat is wrong with that, especially as it facilitates the creator's being able to earn income from their irreplaceable work?
- bheadmaster 4y agoOne could argue that the whole purpose of society is to get rid of scarcity. Creators being unable to earn income is a problem - but artificial scarcity is not a good solution, as it benefits the few at the expense of many. Imagine if everyone was prohibited from sharing news over internet because "free distribution of news harms the journalists who rely on newspaper sales" - that'd be absurd, wouldn't it? Old-school copyright relied on the natural scarcity of paper and other distribution resources - digital age has lowered the distribution cost to zero, so the old model does not work anymore. Another model of rewarding authors is needed, one that does not rely on restriction of distribution.
- psychphysic 4y ago> One could argue that the whole purpose of society is to get rid of scarcity. BAM you just blew my mind at quarter to 8 on a Friday.
- noduerme 4y ago> One could argue that the whole purpose of society is to get rid of scarcity. Scarcity of resources has nothing to do with scarcity of artistic works. Literature isn't fungible like a commodity, and can't be grown or mined as needed. It's also not a professional service or a form of labor. You can't put a gun to a farmer's head and make them write something brilliant, the way you can make them farm potatoes. One could just as easily argue that society exists to organize labor in a way that increases specialization and efficiency. The reduction of scarcity is just a side effect. Specialization breeds scarcity in every new speciality until it becomes universally reproducible. Art is the forwardmost outcropping of specialization - it exists in advance of what it describes being known or understood - and by definition it is always the most scarce speciality. The artifice in making distribution of it remain difficult is therefore an extension of the natural place of scarce ideas in a world of abundant things.
- dghlsakjg 4y agoThe download limit was per day per ip address, and they would remove limits for active community members. I have a hard time believing they were doing anything more than paying for hosting bills.
- flyingsky 4y ago> [...] but the moment people start to make money off of pirated works it starts to feel much more wrong. "Piracy" is expensive! Most people do not donate to support these things it's understandable if they decide to charge a few cents or bucks to keep the light on.
- acomjean 4y agoAre you suggesting people who pirate don’t want to pay?
- ezplorer 4y agoThey were not. >Z-library were in it for commercial gain (you could access a certain number of books but to get more you had to pay for a subscription)< That's a lie mixed with some truth. They have a download limit yes, but one that resets every 24 hours. You can download free 5 books even without an account, and with an account 10 and even more if you used the telegram bot. Like other user mentioned, that policy probaly was to discourage datahoarders and scrapers. And if you donated to the project you recieved the benefit of being able to download more books per day.