4 ms·
And sadly, in 2011, speakerphones and audio conferencing still sucks massively. I do some work at a large university where they have abundant bandwidth and the
by ams6110 15y ago
And sadly, in 2011, speakerphones and audio conferencing still sucks massively.
I do some work at a large university where they have abundant bandwidth and the latest "telepresence" hardware, and as often as not you are still dealing with laggy audio/images, freezes, dropouts, echos, individual participants having technical issues or ignorant of how to use the systems, etc. It just doesn't work smoothly enough to be a pleasant experience, and often times is such a distraction as to render the entire exercise a waste of time.
- jrockway 15y agoWe have a couple million-dollar Cisco telepresence setups where I work, and the experience has always been pretty great. One time, it was 2am and my friend and I had just been kicked out of a bar near our office. There was also a severe thunderstorm warning in effect (with a lot of lightning) so we decided to go back to work instead of riding our bikes home in a tornado. Being rather inebriated, we did not do much work. Instead, we wandered around the building and found the telepresence rooms. We wondered, "how do we link these up and have a conference". There was a phone in each room, and they had some digits on them, so I went to the other telepresence and punched those digits into the phone-like device there. Connected! We then had a conversation for a good hour or so; it was so much like real life that it wasn't worth the effort to get up and walk back to the other room to have a "real" "in-person" conversation. There was no latency. Eye-contact was eye-contact. Everything was the right size. The displays may have even been Retina Displays; I didn't notice any pixels like I might when watching HDTV. So all in all, not bad when done right. It passed the "wait out a tornado while drunk test", which I think says a lot.
- dredmorbius 15y agoWell, duh: two highly engineered rooms proximally located with high-speed data links (presumably) between them. So: being right next door was practically like being ... right next door.
- HeyLaughingBoy 15y agoThe point is that the hardware works quite well. I don't remember who makes our telepresence system, but connecting to a branch office over 1,000 miles away, the audio & video quality is still "like next door."
- miahi 15y agoPlantronics using (forcing) audio conference is eating their own dog food.
- rickmb 15y agoThe problem with those setups is that although they work great for meetings, they're not suited for casual use. And casual, informal communication is a major factor in teamwork.
- JoeAltmaier 15y agoThere are startups addressing this. Sococo is one (I work there).
- dredmorbius 15y agoWhat's far worse is when the systems get deployed in a typical office without much regard for what makes for a good teleconferencing environment. Just as "open floorplan", hot-desked, minimal personal space offices make lousy working environments for technical workers, a glass, steel, and dry-walled office with no acoustic absorbing materials, poorly distributed mikes, wide range of speakers with varying levels of accent and enunciation (one Russian I'd worked with was the black hole of speech, even in person words were unintelligible beyond an event horizon of approximately 12 inches), and the usual technical glitches (digital distortion, dropouts, varying volume levels from multiple remote locations, ambient noise locally or remotely ...) and the experience is uniformly barely tolerable. There's a reason any professional AV situation (panel, conference, broadcast session) has one or more sound engineers. People may not appreciate the complexity, but it's a non-trivial problem. Yes, it's cheaper than flying a bunch of people all over the planet (a lot cheaper), but "cheaper" != "good experience". And when the result is that the time is in fact wasted as you say, I'd say it's worse than the alternative (no meeting, written communications, personal travel).