3 ms·
I always find the backlash against Mozilla odd here. Not to say that they don't have lots of problems, but the top comment here is about cronyism. But as an alt
by godelski 4y ago
I always find the backlash against Mozilla odd here. Not to say that they don't have lots of problems, but the top comment here is about cronyism. But as an alternative browser are we better to support Chrome? A singular company that wants to control the way the internet works (which means chromium is playing with fire too). These threads just fill with Mozilla hate which in turn promotes people's usage of Chrome. It's okay to not like Mozilla, but we do need to recognize that innovation and what's best for us and the internet relies on there being adequate competition. So I ask that you think of the unintended consequences when criticizing in an extreme manner.
A similar pattern seems to happen with other technologies. Signal is a great example. If we place apps/corporations as binary good or evil, the truth is that they are ALL evil. But that does not allow us to put pressure to push them to do good. It prevents us from promoting competition. And remember that a lot of people, even here on HN, don't understand the complexities and nuances that you're expressing your viewpoint from. So don't grab your pitch-fork, grab your pen. Do be critical, but not sensational. There is a difference between complaining and critiquing and social media tends to promote the former because people fighting encourages more engagement (not a metric HN heavily relies upon). It's up to us to break this cycle and choose how we speak and act online. It's clear at this point that those with the platforms aren't going to encourage this behavior, so we have to take the hard route.
We can be critical without being sensational.
- jjcon 4y ago> So I ask that you think of the unintended consequences when criticizing in an extreme manner. I don't think hiding our criticism for "the greater good" is an appropriate path forward at all. Mozilla and Firefox have real problems and plugging our ears while they go up in flames isn't going to help. At least if we are vocal in our desires they have a chance to listen and right the ship (if there is any hope of that at this point). Personally I'm all for the standardization around the blink engine (which has been contributed to by Facebook, Google, Microsoft, Adobe, Intel and tons others) at this point. I see it as similar to the internet backend standardizing around linux. It makes it way easier for developers to reliably test against an ever evolving and complex web.
- switchbak 4y agoThey said "Do be critical, but not sensational", they're not asking you to hide criticism, just to do it in a productive fashion.
- jjcon 4y ago> So I ask that you think of the unintended consequences when criticizing in an extreme manner. What is this supposed to mean then? The implication is that we think of the greater good when formulating our criticism - something I am saying is the opposite of productive. We should attack Mozilla's incompetence head on, not give them a pass for deeds in a bygone era.
- godelski 4y agoI noted what those unintended consequences are. They are that the less knowledgeable do not understand the nuances of the criticisms. All they hear is "Firefox bad, so I'll stay with Chrome." The reason of this is the sensational behavior, not the critique itself. I personally don't want any browser to have a monopoly (or excessive control) over the internet. A global utility. Competition is needed. Firefox has a lot of issues, no one is denying this. This would be a different issue if the the bashing were equal. But this is akin to hyper focusing on Montana's Greenhouse emissions. They're problematic (one of the highest per capita) but clearly there are bigger fish to fry (<1% of US emissions). If we focus all our efforts on Montana then Texas incidentally gains, since they are the largest contributor to US emissions. Perspective matters.
- jjcon 4y ago> All they hear is "Firefox bad, so I'll stay with Chrome." Which is exactly what I am suggesting people do in my comment (note I go on to say why I see it as a good thing that the Chrome renderer is taking over). I didn’t just criticize your critique I suggested why I thought it was wrong on multiple levels but somehow that got missed in most of these threads. Mozilla won’t win on ideology, they have to win by being a superior technology.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pvg 4y agoIf you want to make these threads better just write about your own views, especially if they are not well represented by other comments. It helps a lot more than writing meta in the end.