5 ms·
Interesting. I must say, that doesn't look like we're currently in a recession. On the other hand, if the job market is actually that tight, you'd expect empl
by AnimalMuppet 4y ago
Interesting. I must say, that doesn't look like we're currently in a recession.
On the other hand, if the job market is actually that tight, you'd expect employees to have pricing power. (Maybe they do, and it's just taking both workers and management a while to get used to that idea?)
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoIt could also be that there is a mismatch in skills.
- bombcar 4y agoYeah, you have to account for that. Everywhere there's a huge shortage of jobs paying at or below $20/hr. Likely caused by most of those people moving up to jobs in the 25-30/hr range.
- bioemerl 4y agoMillinnials are growing out of their 20s, basically, and gen Z is tiiiiiny
- hdaz 4y agoOr what the definition of "unemployed" means :) (( too many loopholes ))
- okaram 4y agoHow would you define it? What loopholes? Why isn't any of the other published measures not enough for your purposes?
- dragontamer 4y agoThe reason why there's a debate is that by some measures, we're in a recession, but by other measures, we're not. Jobs is extremely strong. From a jobs perspective, we are not in a recession. And so cues the debate. Which measures _should_ we focus on? Etc. etc. The only thing with any certainty, is that I know we'll be retroactively be declared to have been in a recession for months. The NBER is 100% trusted on calling the recession, but they're also always late to the party by several months. NBER always calls the recession accurately, because they backdate their calls. Ex: in 2008, NBER declared that we've been a recession since 2007. -------- Because of this effect, everyone wants to be "correct faster than NBER", so you see a whole lot of talking-heads talking about recession way too early (ie: before all the economic indicators prove we're in a recession). Everyone wants to predict the future after all, so that they can feel smarter about the whole situation. EDIT: It should be noted that in the real world, it takes weeks, maybe months, to collect and process the statistics. That is to say, we won't know how good our economy in October 2022 is, until maybe January of 2023. That's why NBER is late, they need the time to collect statistics and analyze them. But its also why everyone who is trying to call the Recession "as it happens" (IE: call a January Recession in January) is inevitably going to be wrong, because they're baseless and without any actual data backing that sentiment. Data and statistics take time. Many months. Just sit tight and wait. Have patience. There's no real benefit (or downside) to being "early" or "late" to calling the recession. Getting the call correct is important. It takes many months to spin up employees and/or fire them anyway (good severance pay is multi-month affair after all)
- lesuorac 4y ago> There's no real benefit (or downside) to being "early" or "late" to calling the recession. Isn't there a large financial benfit? Like if you could predict any up/down turns you know when to start buying/shorting stocks. Or even if you're a bank maybe don't lend out a ton of money at say 2% when next month you can lend at 5%.
- dragontamer 4y ago> Like if you could predict any up/down turns you know when to start buying/shorting stocks But the stock market doesn't always go down in a recession. And vice versa, a recession may happen, but the stock market may be fine. Ex: the recession of 1990 barely budged the stock market. While the Stock Market Crash of 1962 had nothing to do with the economy. > Or even if you're a bank maybe don't lend out a ton of money at say 2% when next month you can lend at 5%. But that's speculation upon the Fed Rate, which isn't about recessions at all. For example, the Fed Rate increased in from 0% in 2015 to 2% in 2019. Or from 1% in 2004 through 5% in 2006.
- Victerius 4y agoGive me one logical reason why we should give the NBER the authority to declare whether the United States of America is in a recession. First, the NBER is not a government agency. It's a private organization. Second, there is no law that says that the NBER has the legal authority to declare recessions.
- dragontamer 4y agoYou've got it backwards. As a society, we've already given NBER the authority to declare recessions. They are the official recession caller of the country. Its you who has to argue why NBER's methodology is wrong.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lotsofpulp 4y ago
- bioemerl 4y agoWhat is going on? Low unemployment. High inflation. High interest rates. These are the hallmarks of an industrialization. Labor is needed to be more productive. Business wants capital to do it. Lack of labor and productivity results in supply shortages that raise prices, while labor shortages forces salaries to match. Stocks, looking for dividends, will do poorly because of high pay, labor costs will eat profits and eaten profits will kill stock values, leaving to the appearance of recession. Individuals will barely scrape by neutral because inflation offsets higher pay But a good investment that raises productivity will pay very very handsomely in the future. And those that don't? Will be inflated away to nothing. Order is being restored to the post 2008 insanity. Many tech companies won't survive the jump.
- lotsofpulp 4y ago>Individuals will barely scrape by neutral because inflation offsets higher pay Not if they are selling the type of labor that is experiencing increase in prices, because: >Lack of labor and productivity results in supply shortages that raise prices, while labor shortages forces salaries to match.
- bioemerl 4y agoThe only way for labor to come out on top is if productivity increases. With war, population shrinking, disruption around the world, I expect productivity (in total) to be somewhat stagnant. Which means the top dogs will be forced to make less while they figure out how to fix things through productivity going up once the disruptions are over. But also that the average Joe will get a larger slice of a smaller pie. Assuming I'm right. Who knows what will actually happen.
- bushbaba 4y agoIf you break down the latest jobs report by industry. You’ll see jobs are declining in all sectors but hospitality and transportation.
- bioemerl 4y ago
- yamtaddle 4y ago> On the other hand, if the job market is actually that tight, you'd expect employees to have pricing power. (Maybe they do, and it's just taking both workers and management a while to get used to that idea?) Is it not the case in your area that every fast food joint and small business has a "hiring" sign up with a starting wage listed that a lot higher than it was ~3 years ago?
- adam_arthur 4y agoEmployees have pricing power, which is why wage growth is running far ahead of what's consistent with 2% inflation. The labor market tends to be tightest before a recession because it forces the Fed to hike until it breaks. https://www.atlantafed.org/chcs/wage-growth-tracker https://www.atlantafed.org/chcs/wage-growth-tracker
- alexb_ 4y agoLook at how (relatively) low it was in September 2007. One can assume in February it was even lower - and February is when Greenspan said a recession was obviously coming. The subprime mortgage crisis started in April 2007. But the job market didn't really get fucked until 2008. There's a delay with these types of things - I personally predict that a year from now, a lot of companies (especially ones in the tech sector fueled by immense amounts of cheap debt and the assumption ad revenue always goes up) will collapse. That's when you see the spike in unemployment, not now.
- JumpCrisscross 4y agoUnemployment is a classic lagging indicator [1]. [1] https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/what-are-leading-lagging-and-coincident-indicators/ https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/what-are-leading-la...