3 ms·
It's not enough to oppose SOPA, we need laws that explicitly prohibit the bad parts. Some things need to be fenced off or the animals will ruin it, and make no
by rhizome 15y ago
It's not enough to oppose SOPA, we need laws that explicitly prohibit the bad parts. Some things need to be fenced off or the animals will ruin it, and make no mistake, if SOPA fails they'll try again and again until they reach a maximum. The only way to prevent this from happening again (and make no mistake, they already have backup plans) is to prohibit it.
- gojomo 15y agoWe actually already have a law against the bad parts: the Bill of Rights and specifically the First Amendment.
- rhizome 15y agoI'm not sure that's enough.
- thret 15y agoI'm quite certain it's not enough.
- gojomo 15y agoThe 1st Amendment was enough for the Supreme Court to knock down 1989's Flag Desecration Act (US vs. Eichman, 1990), parts of 1994's Communications Decency Act (Reno vs. ACLU, 1997), 1998's COPA (Mukasey vs. ACLU, through 2009) and 2002's McCain-Feingold (Citizens United, through 2010) as unfairly restrictive of free speech. Congress passes lots of dumb speech-restricting laws that eventually get knocked down. When these DNS-delisting enforcement operations – those from either before or hypothetically after SOPA might pass – finally get real, full-stack court review, they could very well wind up judicially prohibited as unconstitutional. It just takes a while.
- rhizome 15y agoWhich is exactly the thing that should be legislated up front. There's no need to spend decades waiting for a good case to challenge bad law. I shudder to think about "oh, we'll just work it out in the courts" before the law is even passed.