6 ms·
Here's a moderation idea: treat people as grownups and allow everything (everything permitted by the law, that is). Just let individuals ban whoever they want
by coldtea 4y ago
Here's a moderation idea: treat people as grownups and allow everything (everything permitted by the law, that is).
Just let individuals ban whoever they want from THEIR view.
If you want to be super-fancy, you could then see if some account X is banned by many of individual users from appearing on their feed, and give individuals an option to have those automatically banned from their own feeds after some threshold percentage.
So, if X is a jerk/spammer and individual many discussion group users have banned them (from their own view), give users the option to automagically have X banned from their own feed too once they hit say 10% of other members banning them.
This off-loads bannin a little, and as long as individual users have the option to check which those "auto-banned" are and e.g. except them from being auto-banned for them, it still maintains freedom.
In HN with showdead etc, I've never seen any "dead" comments that I couldn't just have as regular comments and just ignore on my own...
- pixl97 4y agoWell it turns out, people aren't grownups. So your idea pretty much fails there. Wait, you think I'm wrong, well, prepare for a thousands of posts and flamewars on this discussion! Oh it's also going to spill over into the gardening discussion that generally gets 5 post a day, but now will see 600 because of our firestorm. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brandolini%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brandolini%27s_law demands moderation. Community and society demand moderation. Hell, I'd even go as far and say physics demands it. The internet breaks our ideas of social norms on moderation by taking distance and anonymity and shoving them in the same place all at once. And much like if you take groups of conflicting fundamentalist religious groups and put them together, the enviable violence outbreak affects everyone around.
- coldtea 4y agoI'm not sure where exactly you think my idea fails. I didn't say to expect they'll behave like grownups in that they wont post anything immature, bad, etc. I said "treat people as grownups", that is, as capable on seeing something they don't like or find offensive or whatever. And if they're not capable, that's on them. So, if a discussion becomes a flamewar with "thousands of posts", so be it. Members can always ignore it. So, if the thousands of posts are from the same small number people (over-posting) and others find those annoying, then can chose to invidividually to ban them, or snooze them, or not. But, if the thousands of posts are by thousants of members (and not bots), then why shouldn't they be left to continue to post and discuss this way, even if its a flame war? They're having fun, and others can ignore or ban them. Now, if they verbally abuse someone though (e.g. threaten their life, dox them, and such), well, that could be moderated and members who do that could be banned. The rest of opinion, whether deemed controversial, unpopular, misinformation, or bullshit, can stay. I don't care much about "Brandolini's law". Who is the arbiter of what's bullshit and why are they? The moderator? Well, that's tautological (they're arbiter of non-bullshit merely because they have the power to moderate).
- pixl97 4y agoThe problem you have here is one of physics. You as a human exist only because of a staggeringly massive number of filters that have allowed you to pass (at least from a non-theist view). Brandolini's law applied to evolution is Darwinism. Simply put, if you focused on bullshit rather than survival you were dead. Coming back to computer physics, simply put we don't have access to unlimited energy and storage space. I can generate trash faster than you can install servers to keep it, and much faster than anyone can afford to pay for the space. Companies that do not control spam simply go out of business, industrial Darwinism. You can ignore physics as much as you want, but it's not ignoring you.
- coldtea 4y ago>Simply put, if you focused on bullshit rather than survival you were dead. Which is neither here, nor there, as the stakes in a discussion forum or media are not "survival". Nor is the danger from something you don't like (or tons of them) life threatening. >Coming back to computer physics, simply put we don't have access to unlimited energy and storage space. I can generate trash faster than you can install servers to keep it, Again, neither here nor there. That is about spam, our subject is moderation. Gmail, for example, also has spam filters, but we don't consider it moderation...
- pixl97 4y ago>as the stakes in a discussion forum or media are not "survival". I mean, as discussion forms commonly dox people, or brigade and convince members to go kill people IRL I really think maybe you're incorrect. >Gmail, for example, also has spam filters, but we don't consider it moderation... We whom? This has been debated on HN for as long as HN existed. Most would consider it moderation, but seemingly as a whole we have given up the battle as spammers are a plague of locust that will consume all. >Again, neither here nor there. Handwaves away physics, good way to accept technical reality of the situation here.
- coldtea 4y ago
- UncleMeat 4y agoThere are a few challenges with this approach. 1. Blocking people is reactive. It means that everybody still sees the first time somebody DMs them calling them a slur. If you instead take the approach of "block everybody that the ML system thinks is alt-right" or "block every post that the ML system thinks is spam" then you are right back at the fun problems of false positives and defaults. 2. People aren't just concerned about their personal experiences on these services. Advertisers are concerned about their ads showing right next to posts calling jewish people evil. Citizens are concerned about the radicalization effect such that even if I don't see conspiracy posts about liberals eating babies, those vortexes still lead to social harm.
- coldtea 4y ago>1. Blocking people is reactive. It means that everybody still sees the first time somebody DMs them calling them a slur. Well, that's the "treat people as grown ups part". In that: treat them as if they can read something they disagree with the "first time" and they wont melt. Calling people slurs or violent threats etc could always still be banned - first time you do it, you're out, or three strikes, or similar. That's unrelated to content (whether the content is controversial or some disagrees with the view, etc), and easy to implement and check. >Advertisers are concerned about their ads Sucks to be them then! Advertisers shouldn't stiffle speech. Disney also didn't like to be associated with gay content, not that long ago. And all kind of partisan political views could be pushed for or against by advertisers. They should not have such a say. In fact I think they should not be allowed by law to be picky on placement on any forum of speech (magazines, social media, etc) where they like to have their ads in. Either they shun the medium altogether, or they buy slots that can appear whenever, alongside whatever. This way also people know it's not the advertisers choice or responsibility of being alongside X post, as they can only buy slots on the whole medium wholesale.
- UncleMeat 4y ago> Well, that's the "treat people as grown ups part". In that: treat them as if they can read something they disagree with the "first time" and they wont melt. It isn't one time. You get a "first time" with each new harasser. It becomes a regular occurrence that when you open your inbox somebody is there shitting on you. > Calling people slurs or violent threats etc could always still be banned - first time you do it, you're out, or three strikes, or similar. Why? The whole point of the idea is that people don't get banned. Returning to "well, sufficiently bad users will be banned" is just returning to the state today with people completely disagreeing about what "sufficiently bad users" means. > Sucks to be them then! Advertisers shouldn't stiffle speech. The "public forums" (twitter, youtube, facebook) are all ad supported. Without advertisers those products simply die.