4 ms·
I haven't ever heard of a pupil who was interested in STEM, but decided to go for a medical degree, just in order to prove himself. The whole premise sounds li
by Tomte 4y ago
I haven't ever heard of a pupil who was interested in STEM, but decided to go for a medical degree, just in order to prove himself.
The whole premise sounds like an invention to me.
Moreover, there are clearly prestigious technical universities even in Germany, although the author is correct that they aren't quite as prestigious as American ones.
RWTH Aachen and TU München are the two standouts. And then there are specialized champions: Tübingen for bioinformatics, I think. Definitely Saarbrücken for Computational Linguistics.
- 0x008 4y agoAdding to that, the whole "schtick" of german education is that the distribution is less extreme on the tails than other countries (looking at you, USA...). So we have a lot of high-class technical universities which are mostly interchangeable in the quality of students they produce, with a few stand-outs (like the ones you mentioened), which, however, stand out less extreme than in the aforementioned US.
- hnbad 4y agoIt's also ironic to talk about how egalitarian German academia supposedly is when the school system in contrast is three-tiered for historical (explicitly classist) reasons, and higher education itself retains this multi-tiered approach through the distinction between universities ("Universität"), universities of applied sciences ("Fachhochschule"), trade schools ("Berufsschule") and the like. There may be fewer extreme outliers within the university system but that doesn't mean the system as a whole is egalitarian. Also it's not clear if its a bad thing if universities aren't retaining "elites" if a signficant part of research in Germany isn't happening at universities themselves. If that is a problem, the problem isn't that "elite academics" aren't properly supported, it's that the institutions to support them have been moved out of the universities into a more privatized market, but that sounds like a different conversation.
- Nitrolo 4y agoThat's why I was really surprised about the content of the article (to be honest I haven't made it past the TL;DR yet), I would have guessed that the problem would be too little egalitarianism. Kids here are sorted into career paths at age 10 by sending them to Gymnasium, Realschule, or Hauptschule. To even attend higher education you need to have an Abitur, which means going to a Gymnasium or putting in extra years of study after your Realschule. The argument is that this division allows every kid to learn at a level appropriate to them, but the reality is that an overworked teacher of 20+ kids is supposed to accurately assess everyone's level and then give a recommendation for one of the schools. My impression is that a lot more weight is put on formal qualifications here than in the US, so in practice this choice sorts you into your future social status for most kids. My N=1 annecdote is a friend of mine who recently finished his PhD at TUM, the teacher wanted to send him to a Hauptschule. If his parents hadn't intervened his life would probably be very different right now. Annecdotaly I know a couple of engineers who went to Realschule and then had to work hard to get an Abitur before going to Uni. Who knows how many smart people were discouraged from pursuing higher education because it would mean two more years of high school just to even start. The system seem arbitrary at best to me, and at its worst is just reinforcing class status through generations. Parents with university degrees will fight to have their kids go to Gymnasium, or the teacher might send them because they know they come from an Akademikerfamilie, and the others better hope their teacher likes them.
- Tomte 4y ago> My N=1 annecdote is a friend of mine who recently finished his PhD at TUM, the teacher wanted to send him to a Hauptschule. Similar, but extended family in my case: was to be sent to a special-needs school (which doesn't even lead to the opportunity to get vocational training), parents fought (hiring a lawyer, and including psychological examinations), child grew up to finish two masters degrees and one PhD.
- hef19898 4y agoThis early classification of kids, for lack of a better term, is so screwed up. And it has all kinds of issues around social background, racial discrimination and whatnot. Ever PISA study I remember basically gave us the same feedback, black on white. Not that I expect it to change in my lifetime so. it did get considerably easier, as opposed to easy, to get access to university level education when starting out at a Hauptschule since I went to school. Back then, like 20 odd years ago, it was basically impossible to do so. I have the highest respect of everyone who actually goes from a Hauptschule to a university degree, this is probably the hardest way to get higher education imaginably around here.
- bryanrasmussen 4y agoWhen he says >I would change my mind on the importance of this problem if.. he should add a point III - if it turns out students don't actually go into Medical school because they want to "prove themselves"
- hef19898 4y agoWhile some doctors can be arrogant bastards, those people aiming at medical studies are usually highly devoted to the field. One would assume the high entry barrier, based on the Abitur average (upon graduation of the highest tier basic education, and don't get me started how that system is fucked up in its own way), would drive people not directly qualifying for a slot to other fields. Guess what, it doesn't. Since you can get slot by simply waiting it out (your average in improved by 0.1 per semester, at least that's how the NC system worked back the day I care about it). And there are people that wait for years until they qualify for a slot. If working for years side jobs, as waiters or what not, and miss those years of white collar salaries in the end, only to have to spend years of training to start working cruel shifts at a hospital at the early days of their medical careers, doesn't show dedication I don't know what. Side note: All the doctors I met so far, ranging from GPs all the way to surgeons and oncologists, would have made for less than stellar engineers. My oncologist maybe, but being a good oncologist is probably saving more lives than being an electrical or mechanical engineer.
- Semaphor 4y ago> And there are people that wait for years until they qualify for a slot. But those are outliers, aren’t they? I’ve dated a med student, and been flatmates with others, the only times I’ve heard of people waiting was if they were doing a gap year or something, 1.5 years for NC improvements being pretty much the maximum and already rare.
- hef19898 4y agoSure, the majority gets into medicine rather quickly. I have yet to meet an engineer of any domain to actually wait longer than mandatory civil or military service. My impression has always been that the average med student is more dedicated than the average engineering student (I am the latter, met quite a few of the former before I started university). And that dedication starts years before going to university, simply because the entry barriers are so much higher.
- squaredot 4y agoI agree with that. In addition to that, German students who want to go to elite schools also go abroad (like ETH of Zurich), this is probably an effect that is unknown to US people.
- hnbad 4y agoIf anything, I'd say that it's a class thing. Children from an upper class "pedigree" ("old money" especially) are often expected to study medicine, law or business[0]. This has little to do with intrinsic "talent" other than these children's parents often being able to afford private tutoring to make up for any academic shortcomings. In fact, politicians (even ones from aristrocratic backgrounds) have repeatedly been involved in scandals over academic fraud like hiring ghost writers to write their thesis in order to get a degree to make them appear more respectable[1]. Talented students still can be and are pursuing STEM degrees but a lot of research these days often doesn't entirely happen directly in the universities themselves but in organizations like the Fraunhofer institutes (also Max-Planck, Helmholtz, Leibniz and DFG), which neatly toe the line between being a quasi public institution and being a for-profit commercial entity. Ironically, a huge shift in German universities happening around the time of the EU replacing local degrees like the German "Magister Artium" with more "standardized" ones like BA/MA was an attempt to push the concept of "elite universities" via special funding programmes supporting university faculties that were already prospering to replicate the exact US model (while also introducing tuition fees for public universities, before having to roll them back due to public outrage). Also on a complete tangent, the graph the article uses clearly shows a sharp decline during the Nazi regime followed by Germany plateuing until the 1990s or so and then having another smaller decline until flatlining again. The article blames the sharp decline in the 1930s and 1940s on "explicit talk of nurturing an elite" being a problem in the Nazi era, which is a ridiculous conflation of modern and past anti-semitism (the Nazis' scapegoat was "international bankers", not "the elites") but also completely misunderstands Nazi ideology, which heavily embraced elitism and "excellence" but was kneecapped by its obsession with avoiding "Jewish" or "degenerate" science. This honestly reads like it's written by someone whose only understanding of Nazism comes from some ahistorical "actually the Nazis were left-wing because they had 'socialist' in their name and used leftist talking points to gain broader support" memes. The other drop in the 1990s is also interesting. The author claims Germany's "problems" are the result of a democratization of universities and egalitarianism but the obvious thing that changed in the 1990s is that "Germany" expanded to include what was previously East Germany, which regardless of any merits of Eastern Bloc academia in the previous decades at this point was economically destitute and underwent a rapid privatization followed by massive "brain drain" as those who could afford to moved westward. [0]: This is also where you're more likely to find "fraternities" which are a much more niche phenomenon and more specifically tied to conservatism than in the US. "Burschenschaften" typically have strict gender roles and historically were more strongly tied to German aristocracy. Though some practices (like fencing duels which would often result in facial scars carried with pride) have fallen out of use, they still often value "tradition" to the point of embracing "völkisch" nationalism, which has a large overlap with white nationalism in the US. [1]: This is less true with younger generations but traditionally Germans would put a lot of stock into both aristrocratic honorifics and academic titles. Academic titles are still protected by law in Germany (i.e. it's a felony to use the title "Dr." or "Doktor" unless you have a doctorate from an institution Germany recognizes) though and people will still treat aristocratic names as if they were titles although aristocratic titles were officially rolled into family names. To explain this for English-speaking readers: imagine you were a "Lord" and your name was "Adam Smith", then your name would have become "Adam Lord Smith" and you would be correctly addressed as "Mr Lord Smith" but some people would still call you "Lord Smith" out of respect -- German laws are actually considerate enough to allow women to use the female equivalent of the title in their family name despite it officially just being part of the name so the daughter of Mr Lord Smith could still be Ms Lady Smith.