3 ms·
The scoop: a JPEG XL developer explains how JPEG XL is uniquely better than AVIF, webP, and PNG, and laments the Chrome team's decision to drop the experimental
by nine_k 4y ago
The scoop: a JPEG XL developer explains how JPEG XL is uniquely better than AVIF, webP, and PNG, and laments the Chrome team's decision to drop the experimental support for it.
AFAICT, JPEG XL does not seem to have the licensing complications of JPEG2000.
- tgv 4y agoYou're seriously underselling the article.
- nine_k 4y agoI'm trying to entice reading it! :)
- zokier 4y ago> AFAICT, JPEG XL does not seem to have the licensing complications of JPEG2000. Well, there is this thing https://jpegxl.io/articles/rans/ https://jpegxl.io/articles/rans/
- vanderZwan 4y agoYou're technically correct, but: > Several variants of the coding procedure Asymmetric Numerical Systems (ANS) may be found in most modern codecs, such as AV1, Z-Standard compression, or even rANS in JPEG XL. ... this is hardly the fault of the JPEG XL developers though, that's the US patent system being ridiculous. Also, in the current discussion context that patent screws over any new compression format, not JPEG XL specifically. Note: general compression, not just image compression (ok, sure, QOI isn't affected. QOI also isn't relevant here). It's obviously a defensive patent anyway, because between AV1, zstd and JPEG XL Microsoft would have to fight an alliance of literally everyone else out there if they'd plan on suing anyone.
- derf_ 4y agoAV1 does not use rANS in any form. The quoted sentence is simply incorrect. However, any necessary patent claims owned by Microsoft, an AOM member, would be freely licensed to everyone for use in AV1 implementations if it actually did use rANS. Which it doesn't.
- vanderZwan 4y agoThe quote doesn't state that AV1 uses rANS, it states that it uses a variant of ANS. JPEG XL uses rANS.
- oittaa 4y agoI might be wrong, but doesn't AVIF benefit enormously because all the new phones, CPUs, GPUs, etc. support AV1 codec out of the box?
- JyrkiAlakuijala 4y agoit was often argued, but HW codecs are not used in practice -- they have other compromises (quality, size limitations, setup times, single central resource when there are often 100 images on a web page) that make them difficult to be used for images simd based software coding if more than fast enough, at least for JPEG and JPEG XL